3.1. Structural Properties of Orthorhombic Rubrene
As shown in Table 1, a lattice constant of 26.79
(50.8257 a.u.) was obtained and it is in good agreement with the experimental value of Ref. [
20]. Table 1 shows the optimized lattice parameters a = 26.7903 Å, b = 7.17001 Å, and c = 14.2112 Å for Orthorhombic Rubrene. These values are in close agreement with those reported in theoretical studies Ref. [
33] and Ref. [
34].
Table 1.
Calculated and measured lattice constant of orthorhombic Rubrene.
Table 1.
Calculated and measured lattice constant of orthorhombic Rubrene.
Reference |
Lattice Constants |
Method/Theory |
|
a () |
b () |
c () |
|
Present work |
26.79 |
7.17 |
14.21 |
GGA |
Ref. [33] |
26.86 |
7.19 |
14.43 |
GGA |
Ref. [34] |
26.660 |
7.142 |
14.025 |
vdW-DFT |
Ref. [34] |
26.965 |
7.206 |
14.442 |
Experiment at 294K |
Ref. [35] |
26.789 |
7.170 |
14.211 |
Experiment at 100K |
Ref. [36] |
14.1289 |
7.1455 |
26.7450 |
GGA |
The relaxed structure of orthorhombic Rubrene (
Figure 1b) shows the compound to be a polymorph with the Cmca space group. Whenever Rubrene molecules unite to form Orthorhombic crystals, the resulting molecules have a centrosymmetric structure with 2/m symmetry. The cell parameters of Orthorhombic Rubrene crystal (as reported in Table 1) shows the molecules are organized in a herringbone packing pattern with nearly complete
-
stacking in the b direction. This is responsible for its large charge-carrier mobility, which has been affirmed in several pieces of research [
16,
34]. The mobility of charge carriers in Orthorhombic monocrystals can approach 40 cm
2/Vs, which is equivalent to that of amorphous silicon [
37,
38]. As seen in most organic crystals, Rubrene’s electronic transport is very anisotropic. High mobility values can only be obtained along the lattice’s b axis. The features obtained from
Figure 1b agrees reasonably well with the results of Ref. [
34] and [
39]. The structural properties obtained in this work agree with previous theoretical and experimental values.
3.2. Electronic Properties
Figure 2 depict the density of state and band structure, as well as the state and behaviour of electrons in an Orthorhombic Rubrene crystal. The numerical values for the direct bandgap between the Highest Occupied Molecular Orbit (HOMO) and the Lowest Unoccupied Molecular Orbit (LUMO) are shown in Table 2. The highest valence band results from the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO), whereas the lowest conduction band results from the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO). Generally, an energetic bandgap of ∼1-5eV has been recorded for OS such as Orthorhombic Rubrene [
33], as they tend to have a diminishing density of states around the Fermi energy. This is proportional to the size of the electrical gap, which is fairly considerable. This reduces the density of thermally generated charge carriers in pure organic crystals, such as silicon.
Table 2.
Comparison of band gaps (HOMO - LUMO) of orthorhombic Rubrene obtained in this work, experiments and previous calculations.
Table 2.
Comparison of band gaps (HOMO - LUMO) of orthorhombic Rubrene obtained in this work, experiments and previous calculations.
Reference |
Band Gap |
Theory |
|
Nature |
Energy (ev) |
|
Present work |
Direct |
1.26 |
PBE |
Ref. [36] |
Direct |
1.13 |
PBE |
Ref. [40] |
Direct |
1.357 |
B3LYP 6-311G |
Ref. [41] |
Direct |
2.50 |
B3LYP/6-311G(d,p) |
As shown in the band structure (
Figure 2), the bottom of the conduction band (CB) and the top of the valence band (VB) occur at the same momentum value. This implies that the band structure of organic semiconductor Rubrene has a direct bandgap, as can be observed with some other organic semiconductors. The direct bandgap of 1.26 eV obtained within PBE agrees with the calculation of Ref [
36] using PBE also with a direct bandgap of 1.13 eV Ref. [
41] and [
42] found a greater disparity between HOMO and LUMO. Their calculated band gap is 2.50 eV and 2.60 eV respectively at B3LYP/6-311G(d,p) level, which differs from other calculations. So far, there is no theoretical literature report on the consequential variation in the HOMO-LUMO gap [
43]. The highest VB’s structural characteristic controls hole transport behaviour. The band splitting of the VB of orthorhombic Rubrene is fairly minimal. Pressure increases intermolecular interaction, resulting in increased mobility [
44]. High mobilities are only for holes, and electron mobilities are several orders of magnitude lower [
42,
45]. Rubrene is a p-type material, as are the vast majority of organic semiconductors [
42].
The number of possible electrons (or hole) states per volume at a given energy is given by the density of states as shown in
Figure 2. The density of states distribution at the top of VB is relatively smooth in the orthorhombic Rubrene.
The high-symmetry points’ reciprocal coordinates are
= (0, 0, 0), X = (0, 0, 0.5), S = (0, 0.5, 0.5), Y = (0, 0.5, 0),
= (0, 0, 0), Z = (-0.5, 0, 0), U = (-0.5, 0, 0.5), R = (-0.5, 0.5, 0.5), T = (-0.5, 0.5, 0), and Z = (-0.5, 0, 0). Each band in the band structures occurs in pairs because the orthorhombic Rubrene crystal structure comprises two molecules in a unit cell.
Figure 2 depicts the band structure along the k-path
– X – S – Y –
– Z – U -R – T - Z, where
-Z corresponds to the `a’ crystal axis and
-Y to the `b’ axis in real space [
16].
3.3. Elastic Properties
The values of the computed C
ij show that the Born-Huang Stability criteria have been fully satisfied [
46] which proves Rubrene to be mechanically stable. The estimated bulk modulus B, shear modulus G, Young’s modulus E, Poisson ratio, Pugh ratio, and Vickers Hardness using the Voigt-Reuss-Hill approximation are shown in Table 4 [
47]. According to [
48], a material is considered to be ductile if its bulk to shear modulus ratio, B/G, is more than 1.75; otherwise, it is brittle. The obtained Pugh ratio is 0.74667, which shows Rubrene to be brittle than ductile. This property implies the ability to break with minimal elastic deformation when stressed and no considerable plastic deformation. Brittle materials have more strength than ductile materials. Brittle materials are more resistant to compression. Even high-strength brittle materials absorb relatively little energy before breakage. This feature proves the ability of orthorhombic Rubrene as an organic semiconductor useful in redefining the future of flexible and stretchable electronics. Furthermore, the Poisson’s ratio can also prove the ductility of a material if the ratio is greater than 0.26 and brittleness is less than 0.26. The obtained Poisson ratio is 0.03292, which agrees with the Pugh ratio can classify orthorhombic Rubrene as brittle.
Table 3.
Comparison of independent elastic constants of orthorhombic Rubrene obtained in this work, experiment and previous calculations.
Table 3.
Comparison of independent elastic constants of orthorhombic Rubrene obtained in this work, experiment and previous calculations.
Reference |
This work |
Ref. [20] |
Ref. [34] |
Ref. [34] |
Method |
PBE |
AIREBO |
vdw-DFT |
Experiment |
C11 (GPa) |
18.8 |
15.54 |
25.31 |
18.48 |
C12 (GPa) |
-8.7 |
1.08 |
6.94 |
2.63 |
C13 (GPa) |
1.6 |
2.08 |
6.78 |
7.68 |
C22 (GPa) |
13.6 |
17.85 |
16.99 |
13.39 |
C23 (GPa) |
9.4 |
10.82 |
10.53 |
7.77 |
C33 (GPa) |
14.6 |
13.29 |
13.94 |
14.32 |
C44 (GPa) |
7.2 |
2.03 |
6.66 |
6.46 |
C55 (GPa) |
13.2 |
1.97 |
4.41 |
2.8 |
C66 (GPa) |
6.5 |
3.36 |
3.67 |
6.8 |
The Vickers hardness H
v is obtained as shown in Table 4. The hardness of a material measures its resistance to plastic deformation produced by applied forces. The result helps characterise the elastic and plastic properties of a solid. The predicted Vickers hardness H
v of 1.080 GPa was obtained for orthorhombic Rubrene using Chen’s model [
49]. The result shows that orthorhombic Rubrene is far from hard and cannot be classified as superhard.
Elastic Constants (GPa) = Calculated elasticity tensor for orthorhombic Rubrene
Also, the calculated reduced elastic constants and anisotropy ratio (C
22/C
33) of orthorhombic Rubrene obtained in this work is shown in Table 5. The values of reduced constants C
22, C
33, and the anisotropy ratio (C
22/C
33) are in close agreement with the result of Ref [
34] from the experimental and vdw-DFT method. These findings may be beneficial not only for studying the strain effect on carrier mobility [
16], but also for Rubrene’s actual use as a flexible electrical device [
34].
Its directional elastic properties need to be analysed and visualised to better understand an anisotropic material such as Rubrene. This includes the young modulus, linear compressibility, shear modulus and Poisson ratio as shown in
Figure 5. The debye temperature and average Debye sound velocity recorded in this research for orthorhombic Rubrene are 331.008K and 2384.484m/s, respectively (Table 4).
Table 4.
Calculated Voigt-Reuss-Hill approximation moduli for orthorhombic Rubrene in this work
Table 4.
Calculated Voigt-Reuss-Hill approximation moduli for orthorhombic Rubrene in this work
Method |
PBE |
Bulk Modulus (GPa) |
4.163 |
Shear Modulus (GPa) |
11.519 |
Young Modulus (GPa) |
5.576 |
Poisson Ratio |
0.03292 |
Pugh Ratio (B/G) |
0.74667 |
Vickers Hardness (GPa) |
1.08 |
Average Debye sound velocity ( m/s ) |
2384.484 |
Debye temperature (K) |
331.008 |
Table 5.
Calculated reduced elastic constants and anisotropy ratio (C22/C33) of orthorhombic Rubrene obtained in this work, experiments and previous calculations.
Table 5.
Calculated reduced elastic constants and anisotropy ratio (C22/C33) of orthorhombic Rubrene obtained in this work, experiments and previous calculations.
Reference |
Method |
C22(GPa) |
C33 (GPa) |
Anisotropy ratio (C22/C33) |
This work |
PBE |
13.6 |
14.6 |
0.93 |
[34] |
vdw-DFT |
15.08 |
12.12 |
1.24 |
[34] |
Experiment |
13.02 |
11.13 |
1.17 |
Young modulus is a mechanical property that measures the tensile/rigidity or stiffness of a material when the force is applied. It implies the ratio of the tensile stress to the proportional deformation/tensile strain.
Where tensile stress is the force per unit area and tensile strain is extension per unit length. The young modulus reported for orthorhombic Rubrene in this work is 55.76 kbar which shows Rubrene as a non-rigid material (Figure 4a).
Linear compressibility or the bulk modulus helps describe a material’s behaviour when pressure is applied, which can be either negative or positive. The 2D and 3D surface plot (Figure 4b and Figure 5b) shows the positive values of linear compressibility plotted in green and the negative value in red. The result indicates that orthorhombic Rubrene crystal structure exhibits negative linear compressibility.
Figure 4.
(a)Young’s Modulus, (b)Linear Compressibility, (c)Shear Modulus, and (d)Poisson Ratio’s in 2D showing its directional planes
Figure 4.
(a)Young’s Modulus, (b)Linear Compressibility, (c)Shear Modulus, and (d)Poisson Ratio’s in 2D showing its directional planes
Figure 5.
(a)Young’s Modulus, (b)Linear Compressibility, (c)Shear Modulus, and (d)Poisson Ratio’s in 3D showing its directional planes
Figure 5.
(a)Young’s Modulus, (b)Linear Compressibility, (c)Shear Modulus, and (d)Poisson Ratio’s in 3D showing its directional planes
Shear modulus is the ratio of shear stress to the shear strain. It gives information on how resistant a material is to deformations as shown in Figure 4c and Figure 5c. The 2D and 3D plots of the Poisson ratio Figure 4d and Figure 5d showed the lateral strain and the longitudinal strain on orthorhombic Rubrene. Poisson ratio for elastic materials is the ratio of the lateral strain and longitudinal strain, which gives information on how materials deform under loading. However, the calculated Poisson ratio value is 0.03292, which lies between -1 to 0.5. The result showed the pristine form of orthorhombic Rubrene as almost perfectly incompressible as there is little or no transverse deformation when axial strain is applied.
3.4. Temperature and Doping Dependent Properties
To address the thermoelectric properties, the electronic fitness test is crucial as it evaluates the thermopower for arbitrary band structures and conductivity [
32]. Suitable thermoelectric materials, in general, have intricate electronic structures that aren’t described by a simple parabolic band [
32]. Therefore, electronic fitness function calculation is necessary to identify such materials and address the
(Conductivity) and S (Seebeck coefficient) conflict.
The Electronic Fitness Function (EFF) displayed in
Figure 6 shows an increase with temperature for both concentrations, which is caused by the rising temperature and which improves its thermoelectric performance. There is a dip at carrier concentration 6.5 x 10
21 for the hole concentration and reaches peak at 2 x 10
21 and 1.1 x 10
22. This work also predicted that orthorhombic Rubrene has a high electronic fitness function at about 500K. Organic semiconductors like Rubrene are mostly p-type semiconductors.
The structure for the EFF in
Figure 6 shows larger p-type EFF values at high doping levels. This is attributed to the secondary conduction band contribution in Rubrene. Furthermore, as the temperature rises, it exhibits improved p-type performance. Valley anisotropy, higher band degeneracy, and multiband contributions in valence bands at higher energies, particularly at high doping levels, result in larger EFF in p-type materials. The features observed from these results show orthorhombic rubrene as a promising organic material for thermoelectric applications.
Figure 7 depicts the transport inverse effective mass as a function of carrier concentrations ranging from 300K to 800K. The result shows it exhibits a light, effective mass of holes. This agrees with the experiments performed in Ref [
50].
Figure 7.
Inverse Effective Mass as a function of the Carrier Concentrations from 300K to 800K
Figure 7.
Inverse Effective Mass as a function of the Carrier Concentrations from 300K to 800K
Figure 8.
Transport properties of Rubrene showing the power factor, electrical conductivity and Seebeck coefficient, respectively.
Figure 8.
Transport properties of Rubrene showing the power factor, electrical conductivity and Seebeck coefficient, respectively.