3.2. Thermal Characteristics of PLA/PCL Binary Fiber Composition
The processes of biodegradation, oxidation and hydrolysis are significantly affected not only by the surface morphology of the film or fiber material, but also by the structural organization of the amorphous and crystalline phases formed in the composite volume [
47,
48,
49]. Polymers in mixtures have mutual influence on crystallization processes. Let’s consider influence of addition of PCL to PLA on crystalline structure of blended compositions.
In the process of mixing of two polymers (PLA, PCL) along with the change of morphology of ultrafine fibers one should expect changes in their thermophysical and structural characteristics. DSC method was used to study thermophysical characteristics of the fibers. For this purpose, thermograms of PLA and PCL fibers and their blended compositions were obtained.
Figure 2 shows the heating peaks of PLA (a) and PCL (b). The DSC curves of polymer samples of different composition with component ratio from 100/0 to 50/50 % PLA/PCL showed 3 characteristic peaks: two endothermic peaks and one exo-peak. A characteristic feature of these thermograms is the overlapping of endothermic peaks of melting of PCL and glass transition of PLA, which complicates the calculation of the enthalpy of melting of PCL. The presence of exopeak at 85.95 ⁰C in PLA indicates the process of cold crystallization and formation of linear structures in the fibers, which indicates the presence of a large proportion of straightened chains in the polymer, which are characterized by a large entanglement at temperatures below 85.95 ⁰C. At higher temperatures, there appears the possibility to form crystalline and linear structures.
With the addition of 10 % PCL, the enthalpy of melting of PLA increases dramatically (
Figure 3) to the highest value. It can be assumed that the first portion of PCL is distributed in the system in the form of tiny particles, thereby plasticizing the structure of PLA and, as a result, the proportion of straightened chains increases sharply, ΔН increases almost 4 times relative to the initial PCL crystallinity.
It can be assumed that the growth of melting enthalpy is also affected by additional crystallization on PCL particles, probably at the small addition, its particles are the centers of crystallization. At the same time, the enthalpy of cold crystallization of PLA decreases sharply (2-fold). It was shown in [
23] that at PCL content up to 20-25 wt %, the mixture has a thin phase structure with small particles and a narrow particle-size distribution. At 30 wt. %, the content of dispersive phase structure enlarges and the particle size distribution expands. At PCL content of more than 40 wt %, the morphology of the phases becomes continuous, with the PLA-rich phase partially dissolving the PCL. With increasing concentration of PCL, ΔН begins to decrease, apparently, the particle size distribution expands, the effect of plasticization and additional crystallization begins to decrease.
Now let’s consider the change of enthalpy of melting of PCL. The complexity of calculating of this parameter consists in superimposing of the PCL melting peak (T
m=62 ⁰C) and the PLA glass transition peak (T
gt=64 ⁰C) on the thermogram. However, the total value of ΔН can be used to estimate the change in the melting enthalpy of PCL when mixed with PLA.
Table 1 shows that when PCL is added to the mixed composition up to and including 70%, its ΔН is extremely low, i.e., the proportion of crystallites and linear systems in PCL is negligible.
The results confirm the conclusion about the fine-dispersed distribution of PCL in the PLA matrix when it is added to the mixture up to 70%. And only starting from the 30/70 % PLA/PCL composition, when polycaprolactone forms a continuous phase, the formation of crystallites and linear systems of PCL occurs in the mixture, the proportion of which increases significantly with increasing concentration of the latter in the mixture (
Table 1).
Let us point out the reason for spontaneous straightening and additional orientation of the chains. It is known from thermodynamics that the conformational criterion k*= h/L (where h is the average distance between chain ends and L is the contour chain length) determines the tendency of a macromolecule to straightening and additional orientation or to folding into a ball. Each polymer has its own critical value k*. Chains with k>k* tend to additional orientation, macromolecules with k<k* tend to take a ball conformation. Therefore, a certain portion of straightened macromolecules is formed in the process of fiber production, however, the system does not fully assume an equilibrium state during molding and recrystallization with growth of crystallite sizes and the portion of straightened chains in the amorphous phase occurs during structure loosening (in this case by PCL particles). Isothermal thickening of longitudinal dimensions of crystallites occurs due to movement of the fold as a whole through the crystal, and also as a result of straightening of sufficiently straightened chains in inter-fibrillar and intrafibrillar regions. In this case the structure of amorphous regions also changes.
The nature of changes in the thermal characteristics of the binary PLA/PCL system depending on the composition of polymer components allows us to draw a preliminary conclusion that there is a certain region of concentrations from 50/50 and 30/70 % of PLA/PCL where phase inversion takes place, i.e., when the continuous (dispersed) phase of PLA transforms into dispersed phase. In this concentration range, the enthalpy of melting of PLA and PCL is characterized by very low values, there are no exo-peaks characteristic of PLA, and there is a kink in the dependence of ΔН on composition (
Figure 3).
The addition of small concentrations of PCL into the system promotes the formation of a certain fraction of more perfect crystallites with a melting point of about 220 ⁰C (the melting range lies between 160 and 220 ⁰C), while in the original PLA this range lies between 160 and 190 ⁰C. Note that the melting enthalpy data obtained by the DSC method provide information on both the fraction of crystalline phase and linear structures (structures made of straightened chains with a two-dimensional order) in the fiber.
With an increase in the concentration of PCL over 70% in the system, the enthalpy of melting of both PLA and PCL increases sharply (
Table 1). In the region of compositions with 80-90% PCL content the enthalpy of melting of this polymer is 33.6 and 33, 8 J/g, while in the homopolymer is 54 J/g. It can be assumed that at these compositions interfacial layers are formed, which partially prevent the formation of the crystalline phase.
Thus, the study of the crystalline phase (of also linear systems) of PLA, PCL and their mixed compositions has shown that the addition of polycaprolactone to PLA from 10 to 30% causes a sharp increase in the enthalpy of melting in this composition, and this is due to the plasticizing effect of finely dispersed particles of PCL. In the range of 50-70% PLA/PCL, apparently, there is a phase inversion, what leads to a sharp decrease in the enthalpy of melting. A further increase in the concentration of PCL in the mixture is accompanied by a sharp increase of ΔН in both polycaprolactone and PLA. Since the enthalpy of melting in the blended compositions with PCL content from 70 to 90 % is significantly lower than in the homopolymer, it can be assumed that interphase interlayers are formed in this material. A characteristic feature for these blended compositions is the decrease in the melting temperature of PLA as the concentration of PCL increases, starting from the composition 50/50 % from 170.5 to 165,1 ⁰C.
Sufficiently strong changes in the enthalpy of melting of the polymers under study should be accompanied by changes in the amorphous interlayers of fiber materials, what will be analyzed further using the EPR method.
3.3. Dynamic Characteristics of the Amorphous Phase of Mixed PLA/PCL Compositions
In partially crystalline polymers, the structure of the amorphous regions is largely determined by the influence of their crystalline phase. Consequently, the mixing of crystalline PLA and PCL polymers changes not only the degree of crystallinity of the biopolyether, but also the molecular dynamics in the amorphous regions. To study the molecular/segmental mobility, we used an EPR method using the stable nitroxyl radical TEMPO, which acts as a molecular probe.
Let us consider the effect of the composition of the PLA/PCL mixture on the dynamics of the polymer molecules. It was shown earlier that the EPR spectra of the radical in PLA homopolymer matrices are a superposition of two spectra corresponding to two radical populations with their characteristic correlation times τ1 and τ2 [
50,
51,
52]. Time τ1 reflects the mobility of molecules in denser amorphous regions with small free volume (the slow component of the spectrum), while τ2 reflects mobility in less dense regions with large free volume (the fast component of the same spectrum). The spectra for these polymers are shown in
Figure 4.
It can be seen that the spectra of PLA samples and PLA/PCL blended compositions with PLA content up to 70% look like a two-component system, i.e., there is an overlap of two spectra with slow and fast components. For samples with a PCL content of 70 % or more, the spectrum is single-component. The heterogeneous nature of the amorphous regions is due to the difference in the packing density of the polymer molecules and, therefore, to the different molecular dynamics. Because of their high potential barrier for internal rotation of chain links, PLA molecules are very rigid. The glassy dense mesh of this polymer prevents effective penetration of the radical, as confirmed by its low concentration in the samples (the radical was introduced at at 50 ⁰C). Using a special Simfonia and Winer program, concentrations of different density areas were evaluated. PCL has an elastic amorphous phase with high sorption properties. The amorphous phase of PLA is characterized by significantly higher correlation times and low radical concentration. As the PCL content in the mixture increases, the radical concentration increases dramatically (as shown in Figure. 5).
It is in the region of 50-70% of the PCL content that a kink is observed in this dependence. As it was already shown in the previous section, the PCL concentration range of 50-70 % belongs to the phase inversion range, where practically all characteristics change their character depending on the composition, and a phase transition takes place when the dispersed phase of the PLA transforms into the dispersed phase.
Using mathematical processing of the experimental spectra using a special program Simfonia and Winer (Bruker
®), the correlation times in PLA and PCL with different proportions in the mixture were calculated. Subtracting the spectrum of PCL from the spectra of the mixture composition, the correlation time τ1 in PLA was calculated (
Figure 6a).
The correlation time τ2 was calculated similarly (
Figure 7a).
The figure shows that this parameter increases sharply (τ1 and τ2) when up to 20% PCL is introduced into the system, what suggests the presence of a transition of the amorphous structure of PLA from glassy to highly elastic state. The addition of up to 20% PCL causes its finely dispersed distribution in the system (as shown in [
23]), what plasticizes the structure of the mixture and causes the growth of straightened macromolecules in the composition and, as a result, the molecular dynamics increases dramatically. In the concentration range from 20 to 50% PCL a decrease of τ1, τ2 is observed, what is caused by a decrease in the effect of plasticization of the structure by PCL particles due to an increase in their size [
23]. At higher polycaprolactone concentrations in the mixture (from 50 to 70%), a kink is observed in the dependence of τ2 on the polymer composition, and further growth of the PCL concentration in the system leads to weak changes in the correlation time, despite a significant increase in the enthalpy of melting of this material. The growth of the share of crystalline regions and linear structures at the introduction of PCL of 70% or more should be accompanied by an increase in the share of straightened chains in the amorphous interlayers, but experimentally such changes in the compositions have not been recorded. It may be assumed that in the area of phase inversion the dispersed phase of PLA passes into a dispersion phase, the radical concentrates mainly in the amorphous structure of PCL due to the rather loose structure of this polymer (molecular mobility in it is almost 30 times higher than in PLA and the concentration of the radical is ~8 times higher). The radical provides information mainly on the molecular mobility of PCL at its concentration of more than 70%.
Since the melting temperature of PCL lies in the range 50-75 ⁰C, and the glass transition temperature of PLA in the range 60-75 ⁰C, the radical was introduced into the mixture compositions at two temperatures: 50 and 75 ⁰C.
Let us consider the dependences of correlation times on the mixture composition when the radical is introduced into the fiber at 75 ⁰C. Correlation times were calculated similarly to the previous experiment.
Figure 6b and 7b show the dependences of the characteristic correlation time for the fast and slow components of the EPR spectrum on the mixture composition. It can be seen that with the introduction of the radical at 75 ⁰C the character of the dependences did not change, only higher values of τ were realized in the fibers with the composition from 0 to 50% PCL due to the accessibility for the radical of denser amorphous regions of the material. At a higher content of this polymer in the mixture, from 50 to 70%, a kink in the dependence τ on the composition of the composition was also observed. When the concentration of PCL in the mixture is higher than 70%, the molecular dynamics in the amorphous regions slows down insignificantly.
The nature of the dependencies of the correlation time on the mixture composition when the radical is added at 75 ⁰C differs only by higher values of τ1 and τ2 in the region with high PLA content (up to 50%) than when it is added at 50 ⁰C. At addition of more than 70 % PCL the curves coincide irrespective of the temperature of introduction of the radical.
Thus, the patterns of changes in the molecular dynamics in PLA/PCL fiber material are similar to the changes in the enthalpy of melting of this polymer, thus confirming the conclusion about the plasticizing effect of adding PCL up to 50%. At its small concentrations (up to 30%) the distribution of PCL occurs in the form of tiny particles, and perhaps they are also the germs of crystallization. In this case, the possibility for sufficiently straightened macromolecules to adopt the maximally straightened conformation and create additional crystalline and linear structures is realized (as confirmed by DSC data) and, as a result, ΔН τ
1 and τ
2 greatly increase. The observed changes can be explained by the transformation of the amorphous structure from glassy to highly elastic state. A further increase in the concentration of PCL in the system leads to an increase in the size of the PCL particles (according to the literature data) and the plasticization effect of the structure of the mixture composition decreases, a decrease in the dynamic and structural parameters is observed. In the region of compositions of 50-70% PLA/PCL a kink is observed in the dependencies of ΔН τ
1 and τ
2 on the composition, what is explained by the phase inversion in the mixture composition. At the PLA content of 70% the PCL becomes a continuous phase, the melting enthalpy of both PLA and PCL begins to increase significantly, but the correlation time increases insignificantly, what can be explained by weak changes in the amorphous regions of PCL. Regardless of the temperature of introduction of the radical into the PLA/PCL system, the character of the change in the correlation time from the mixture composition does not change (
Figure 6 and
Figure 7). When the radical is introduced at 75 ⁰C, τ1 and τ2 are characterized by higher values in comparison with these parameters obtained at 50 ⁰C only in the region of PCL concentrations less than 70%. At a higher concentration of PCL in the system, regardless of the temperature of introduction of the radical, these curves coincide.
The fraction of sorbed probe increases significantly with increasing PCL concentration in the material and in the region of 50-70 % PCL a kink occurs due to the formation of a much softer continuous PCL structure. At a higher addition of this material, the concentration decreases.
The closeness of the form of concentration curves, melting enthalpy, correlation time, reflecting the structural and dynamic nature of the polymer mixture, is determined by its phase transformation, namely, by the transition of PLA from dispersed material into a dispersion medium.
Additional information on the dynamic behavior of the PLA/PCL system of different compositions was obtained by studying the temperature dependence of the rotation speed of the molecular probe (
Figure 8).
In PLA homopolymer, the segmental dynamics decreases when the sample is heated to 40 ⁰C, indicating the heterogeneous structure of this polymer. During the heating, owing to heterogeneity of PLA, its intercrystalline structures are progressively involved into molecular transformation and the denser regions are getting accessible for TEMPO radical penetration with the retardant of its mobility. At higher temperatures (over 40 ⁰C) mobility begins to increase (
Figure 8). In mixtures with the addition of PCL up to 50%, the temperature dependence of the correlation time has a kink at temperatures of 40-50 ⁰C. In fibers with PCL content of 70 % and more, this dependence has a linear character, what indicates a homogeneous structure in which the radical is sorbed.
The effective activation energies Eτ, (
Figure 9) were calculated for the fast component when the radical was introduced at 70 ⁰C.
The values of Eτ decrease with increasing PCL concentration in the system and in the region of 50/50 and 70/30 % concentrations are characterized by rather the lowest values (the region of phase inversion). At higher PCL concentrations in the system, the Eτ values are slightly increased. The obtained result also confirms the conclusion about the presence of phase inversion in the region of PCL concentration 50-70%, what corresponds to all previous results.