1. Introduction
Mercury (Hg) can be found in three most common forms in the environment: elemental, inorganic, and organic compounds, such as methylmercury [
1]. Artisanal mining activity is a primary source of Hg contamination, using Hg to separate gold from other materials during mining [
2]. This activity leads to the accumulation of Hg in riverbeds, ultimately forming the highly toxic methylmercury (MeHg) compound [
3]. Natural and anthropogenic environmental disasters can drastically increase the exposure of human populations to MeHg poisoning [
3], representing a worrisome health issue and a global concern [
4,
5].
Consumed MeHg is rapidly absorbed by the body, widely distributed in tissues, and slowly excreted [
6]. Once consumed, MeHg easily crosses cellular barriers, including the placental and blood-brain barriers, with rapid access to the fetus and the central nervous system (CNS), respectively [
7]. Heavy metal intoxication affects the CNS possibly contributing to obesity and its consequences [
5].
Some metabolic consequences of pollution in humans may be attributed to chronic heavy metal exposure, with direct actions on adipose tissue, interfering with adipocyte signaling and releasing adipokines, a class of molecules associated with a plethora of biological functions [
8]. Chronic MeHg toxicity can also disrupt the adipose tissue but its effects on fat metabolism are not well understood [
9,
10].
Apolipoprotein E (ApoE) is a very important apolipoprotein involved in lipid metabolism. ApoE participates in the homeostatic control of plasma and tissue lipid contents, playing a critical role in the cholesterol liver clearance [
11]. ApoE is mainly synthesized in hepatocytes and plays several immune system-modulating roles, affecting the development of inflammation-related chronic diseases [
12,
13].
In this study, we evaluated the effects of MeHg intoxication (20mg/L in drinking water for 20 days) on the structural and functional alterations of the epididymal white adipose tissue (EWF) in ApoE knockout (ko) mice that show systemic ApoE deficiency and spontaneous dyslipidemia. ApoE ko mice have been used as an experimental cardiovascular disease and atherosclerosis model [
14], even at a young age [
15]. The findings of this study may shed light on novel nutritional interventions to reduce the impact of MeHg intoxication by improving the adipose tissue metabolism in dyslipidemic individuals.
4. Discussion
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study that investigated the impact of MeHg intoxication on the function and structure of a metabolic-active EWF in ApoE-deficient animals. The study intended to address how MeHg and ApoE deficiency alone or in combination affect EWF and liver tissues and assess whether ApoE deficiency and MeHg intoxication show compounded deleterious effects. ApoE ko mice are well-recognized to show spontaneous dyslipidemia, even early in life [
15].
As expected, MeHg-exposed mice had significantly higher concentrations of Hg in the fur, epididymal adipose tissue, and liver than the non-exposed groups, confirming the disseminated toxicity of the experimental model. Of note, Rizzetti et al could not find higher significant Hg deposition in the epididymal adipose tissue from exposed mice (challenged by 20mg/L of mercury chloride (HgCl2) in drinking water) compared to unchallenged mice [
19]. This difference is probably due to MeHg's greater capacity to overcome cellular barriers than Hg [
7].
Although we could find reduced weight gain in intoxicated C57BL/6J mice when compared to their non-intoxicated controls, this is not a universal finding in MeHg intoxication studies. Ferrer and colleagues found that when 8-week-old C57BL/6J mice were chronically exposed to lower doses of MeHg (0.5 or 5 mg/L in drinking water), they did not show changes in body weight. However, they reported that it did affect the expression of hypothalamic neuropeptides (which participate in food intake and body weight control) and increased the anorectic neuropeptide pro-opiomelanocortin (POMC) in a dose-dependent manner [
20].
Exposure to heavy metals to adipose tissue is considered biphasic and may range from increased adipogenesis in chronic low dose exposures to inhibition of adipose tissue differentiation in higher doses [
21], which may partly explain our findings.
In our study, intoxication with MeHg did not alter plasma triglyceride levels in wild-type and ApoE ko mice compared to their non-intoxicated controls. Nonetheless, triglyceride levels were higher in apoE ko mice regardless of MeHg exposure. Roque and colleagues found that 20mg/L of MeHg in drinking water induced hypertriglyceridemia in wild-type mice. This MeHg effect was augmented by ApoE deficiency [
15].
Additionally, ApoE ko mice displayed significantly greater levels of cholesterol when compared to wild-type controls, and MeHg-challenged ApoE ko mice showed even more pronounced hypercholesterolemia. From these findings, we could hypothesize that long-term MeHg exposure may be more harmful to dyslipidemic individuals. Mounting evidence indicates worsening cardiovascular risk and accelerated atherosclerosis in ApoE ko mice [
22]. Chronic MeHg intoxication may raise total blood cholesterol due to increased atherogenic or non-HDL fraction [
22]. MeHg seems to bind to sulfhydryl groups in the main apoprotein of the non-HDL fraction (apoB-100), which can induce conformational rearrangements that compromise binding with its receptors [
23]. Reduced LDL intake would contribute to a further rise in serum total cholesterol levels [
22].
In our protocol, AST and ALT were not significantly altered with MeHg exposure, which may not rule out subtle hepatotoxicity and perhaps later effects outside the study's timeframe. Although with another form of Hg intoxication, one study showed that HgCl
2-treated mice (subcutaneous dose of 4.6 mg/kg for three consecutive days) did not exhibit changes in liver aminotransferase activities [
24]. Yet, ApoE ko mice presented an increase in ALT and AST levels compared to non-intoxicated wild-type mice, with amplifying effects following MeHg intoxication, which suggests that dyslipidemic (increase in ALT, but not AST) mice are vulnerable to liver damage by MeHg. Hypercholesterolemic ApoE ko mice are at a higher probability of developing severe liver injury later, suggesting that increased oxidative stress and cholesterol products may act as a catalyzer in the process of liver aging [
25].
Our findings did not show significant MeHg-induced liver steatosis in wild-type mice; however, MeHg led to hepatic steatosis in ApoE-deficient mice, suggesting that a previous dyslipidemia state could predispose to this alteration. Leocadio and colleagues were able to detect nonalcoholic steatosis in the liver with increased Kupffer cell counts after exposing mice to a higher dose of MeHg (20mg/L in the drinking water) for two weeks in wild-type mice [
26]. This later finding reinforces the need for a more robust intoxication to trigger a significant liver pathology. Of note, Wistar rats, when treated with 5 mg/kg/day of MeHg and 1 mg/kg/day of diphenyl diselenide given intragastrically for 21 days, showed increased Hg accumulation in the liver and brain, leading to motor deficits and weight loss [
27].
The increase in oxidative stress and reactive oxygen species causes numerous toxic effects of MeHg. MeHg (0.5 mg/kg/day) for about 40 days significantly increased SOD, glutathione transferase, glutathione, and carbonyl activity [
28]. In our study, liver TBARS levels were augmented as a proxy of oxidative stress due to MeHg intoxication, corroborating with a strong body of evidence. Although ApoE deficiency did show higher TBARS levels than MeHg-exposed wild-type mice, this difference did not reach a significance level. Our data showed increased liver SOD activity as well; that effect may be partly explained by a compensatory effect to counterbalance the increased oxidative stress to better neutralize excess free radicals [
29].
Regarding lipid metabolism and plasticity, MeHg did not change the EWF weight, plasma leptin levels, and mean adipocyte size in wild-type mice. MeHg compounded with ApoE deficiency reduced overall EWF and mean adipocyte size compared to challenged wild-type mice, reflected by increased plasma total cholesterol, triglycerides, and tested liver transaminases.
Reduced absolute and relative weight of EWT and adipocyte size mice were seen with more prolonged mercury (HgCl
2) intoxication and at low doses. In addition, HgCl
2 was recognized as a potent environmental disruptor of the white adipose tissue by reducing the mean adipocyte size, affecting adipogenesis, adipokine synthesis, and secretion [
19]. We have documented a synergistic effect of ApoE deficiency and MeHg intoxication, reducing adipocyte mean diameter in EWF.
Furthermore, mice fed a high-fat diet and injected subcutaneously with HgCl
2 (1.0 mg/kg) showed decreased adipocyte size in males [
30]. MeHg (5mg/L) for 30 days was able to induce anorexia in C57BL/6J wild-type mice. MeHg intoxication has been associated with an altered leptin-induced Janus kinase 2 (JAK2)/STAT3 signaling pathway in the hypothalamus [
31]. Interestingly, HgCl2 treatment significantly decreased serum leptin levels with downregulation of leptin mRNA expression in white adipose tissue [
30]. When adipose tissue is transplanted from ApoE ko mice into wild-type recipients after being fed a standard chow or high-fat diet for 8 to 10 weeks, transplanted ApoE ko adipocytes were found significantly smaller than transplanted wild-type adipocytes after receiving a standard chow diet while following a high-fat diet the size of transplanted wild-type adipocytes increased by 10
6 × 10
3 μm
3 and the size of ApoE ko adipocytes increased by only 19 × 10
3 μm
3 [
32].
ApoE is highly expressed in adipocytes, which positively correlates with body fat mass. Conversely, ApoE deficiency in adipose cells compromises lipoprotein internalization and triglyceride accumulation in the tissue. ApoE-deficient lipoproteins cannot induce preadipocytes to form lipid-filled round adipocytes [
33]. Furthermore, when challenged with a high-fat and a high-sucrose diet, lower adiposity, and higher insulin sensitivity are seen in ApoE ko mice compared to ApoE-sufficed mice. The authors related the findings to reduced lipid transport to insulin-sensitive tissues, improving diet-induced obesity and insulin resistance in these animals [
34]. These findings corroborate our lower epididymal adipose tissue mass seen in the non-intoxicated ApoE ko mice.
In our study, we found an EWF-increased activity of creatine, L-phenylalanine, and L-tyrosine in a scenario of MeHg intoxication in wild-type mice. Creatine-dependent ADP/ATP substrate cycling has been identified in thermogenic beige adipocytes with UCP-1 involvement [
35]. It would be interesting to know whether chronic MeHg exposure could augment the number of beige adipocytes in EWF. L-tyrosine serum levels are elevated after long-distance aerobic exercise, with increased glucose and lipid metabolism [
36]. A high fat-induced mouse model of metabolic dysfunction-associated liver steatosis revealed that L-phenylalanine and L-tyrosine levels in liver samples were reduced when compared to the control group. Yu and colleagues have shown that L-phenylalanine and L-tyrosine were negatively associated with the levels of ALT, AST, perineal fat, and epididymal fat, but were positively associated with bacteria of the genus
Muribaculaceae in metabolomic analysis of cecum samples [
37].
In our metabolomics studies, we found increased EWF activity of L-acylcarnitine sphingomyelin, taurine, and hexaethyleneglycol in the context of double challenge with ApoE deficiency and MeHg intoxication. Interestingly, the L-carnitine and acylcarnitine pathway is involved in the generation of trimethylamine oxide (TMAO) following trimethylamine (TMA) oxidation by liver flavin-containing monooxygenases. TMA is produced by the intestinal microbiota. TMAO is considered a biomarker of atherosclerosis, as it disrupts the reverse cholesterol transport and increased the accumulation of foam cells in the arterial plaques [
38]. Elevated blood concentrations of L-acylcarnitine are also indicative of fatty acid oxidation disorders [
39]. In addition, it has been recognized that sphingomyelin plasma levels correlate with coronary heart disease even independently of cholesterol plasma levels and the blockage of sphingomyelin activity could reduce atherosclerosis in ApoE ko mice [
40]. Conversely, taurine supplementation is associated with improved adipose tissue metabolism and lipolysis and aging-related diseases [
41], and hexaethyleneglycol is considered a ligand of the Toll-like-9 receptor [
42] which may be compensatory mechanisms in the context of systemic adipose function. Plausible interactions of paracrine and systemic EWF function of these metabolites remain elusive.
The elevated levels of MeHg in the fur of mice in comparison to average human hair concentrations in worldwide populations is a limiting factor in our study. However, it is important to highlight that severe anthropogenic-related environmental disasters have increased substantially [
3], which can cause alarming levels of Hg contamination in water reservoirs to adjacent communities.
Figure 1.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on Hg concentration in hair (A), liver (B), and epididymal adipose tissue (C) of young ApoE ko and wild-type mice. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least ten mice per group. *p<0.05, ***p<0.001.
Figure 1.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on Hg concentration in hair (A), liver (B), and epididymal adipose tissue (C) of young ApoE ko and wild-type mice. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least ten mice per group. *p<0.05, ***p<0.001.
Figure 2.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on delta weight gain (A), weekly body weight gain, (B) plasma triglycerides (C) and total cholesterol (D) from ApoE ko and wild-type mice. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least six mice per group. **p<0.01. (B) a: CT x ApoE CT, b: ApoE ko CT x ApoE ko MeHg.
Figure 2.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on delta weight gain (A), weekly body weight gain, (B) plasma triglycerides (C) and total cholesterol (D) from ApoE ko and wild-type mice. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least six mice per group. **p<0.01. (B) a: CT x ApoE CT, b: ApoE ko CT x ApoE ko MeHg.
Figure 3.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on plasma concentrations of AST (A) and ALT (B), TBARS, and SOD concentrations in liver tissue wild type and ApoE ko adult mice. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least six mice per group. **p<0.01.
Figure 3.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on plasma concentrations of AST (A) and ALT (B), TBARS, and SOD concentrations in liver tissue wild type and ApoE ko adult mice. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least six mice per group. **p<0.01.
Figure 4.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on e EWF (A), leptin plasma concentration (B), adipose mean diameter (C, D) of wild-type mice and ApoE ko adults. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least six mice per group. *p<0.05, **p<0.01.
Figure 4.
Effect of oral administration of MeHg (20 mg/L) for 20 days on e EWF (A), leptin plasma concentration (B), adipose mean diameter (C, D) of wild-type mice and ApoE ko adults. Results are expressed as mean ± SEM by two-way ANOVA. N of at least six mice per group. *p<0.05, **p<0.01.
Figure 5.
Metabolomics data analysis for all biological scenarios: ApoE ko CT vs. ApoE ko MeHg vs. WT CT vs. WT MeHg. A. Partial least squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) of all biological scenarios. B. Variable importance in projection (VIP) scores of all biological scenarios, with their denotation including, metabolite name, experimental retention time and experimental monoisotopic mass. C. Heatmap with the molecular features displayed within their biological. clusters. D. Interactome analysis of VIP metabolites of all biological scenarios (node size≥2; edge confidence: medium=0.400).
Figure 5.
Metabolomics data analysis for all biological scenarios: ApoE ko CT vs. ApoE ko MeHg vs. WT CT vs. WT MeHg. A. Partial least squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) of all biological scenarios. B. Variable importance in projection (VIP) scores of all biological scenarios, with their denotation including, metabolite name, experimental retention time and experimental monoisotopic mass. C. Heatmap with the molecular features displayed within their biological. clusters. D. Interactome analysis of VIP metabolites of all biological scenarios (node size≥2; edge confidence: medium=0.400).
Figure 6.
Metabolomics data analysis for ApoE ko CT vs. ApoE ko MeHg biological scenario. A. Orthogonal partial least squares-discriminant analysis (oPLS-DA). B. Variable importance in projection (VIP) scores, with their denotation including, metabolite name, experimental retention time and experimental monoisotopic mass. C. Interactome analysis of VIP metabolites (node size≥2; edge confidence: medium=0.400).
Figure 6.
Metabolomics data analysis for ApoE ko CT vs. ApoE ko MeHg biological scenario. A. Orthogonal partial least squares-discriminant analysis (oPLS-DA). B. Variable importance in projection (VIP) scores, with their denotation including, metabolite name, experimental retention time and experimental monoisotopic mass. C. Interactome analysis of VIP metabolites (node size≥2; edge confidence: medium=0.400).
Figure 7.
Metabolomics data analysis for WT CT vs. WT MeHg biological scenario. A. Orthogonal partial least squares-discriminant analysis (oPLS-DA). B. Variable importance in projection (VIP) scores, with their denotation including, metabolite name, experimental retention time and experimental monoisotopic mass. C. Interactome analysis of VIP metabolites (node size≥2; edge confidence: medium=0.400).
Figure 7.
Metabolomics data analysis for WT CT vs. WT MeHg biological scenario. A. Orthogonal partial least squares-discriminant analysis (oPLS-DA). B. Variable importance in projection (VIP) scores, with their denotation including, metabolite name, experimental retention time and experimental monoisotopic mass. C. Interactome analysis of VIP metabolites (node size≥2; edge confidence: medium=0.400).
Table 1.
Effects of mercury intoxication (20 mg/L in drinking water) on histopathological scores in the liver of wild-type C57BL6/J and adult ApoE ko mice.
Table 1.
Effects of mercury intoxication (20 mg/L in drinking water) on histopathological scores in the liver of wild-type C57BL6/J and adult ApoE ko mice.
Groups |
Steatosis |
Ballooning |
CT |
0 (0-0) |
0 (0-1) |
MeHg |
0 (0-0) |
0 (0-2) |
ApoE ko CT |
0 (0-1) |
1 (0-2) |
ApoE ko MeHg |
0 (0-1)a,b
|
1 (0-2)b
|