1. Introduction
Lecanicillium lecanii KMZW-1, formerly known as
Verticillium lecanii, is a well-recognized entomopathogenic fungus belonging to the family Cordycipitaceae; order Hypocreales. Recently, biological control has garnered increased attention for managing agricultural insect pests, due to its environmental friendliness. Biocontrol agents such as
L. lecanii KMZW-1, have become a focal point for experts seeking sustainable pest management solutions.
Bactrocera dorsalis, commonly known as the oriental fruit fly, is a significant pest affecting a wide range of fruit crops [
1]. Effective control of
B. dorsalis is crucial for minimizing crop damage and financial losses.
Previous researches have showed the insecticidal potential of biocontrol agents. For example Methoxyfenozide and
Beauveria bassiana have demonstrated promising results in controlling B
. dorsalis. Chandramohan et al., (2016) reported mortality rates of 67.5%, 65.0% and 63.5% for Methoxyfenozide and 60.0%, for
B. bassiana [
1]. Similarly, Huang et al. (2014) found mortality rates of 78.2% for
B. bassiana and 75.6% for Methoxyfenozide against oriental fruit fly. These studies provide a theoretical basis for exploring new bio-control agents against
B. dorsalis highlighting the need for further research into the pathogenicity of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 [
2].
In recent years, advancement in biotechnology have provided new insights into the success of biological control. Genomic sequencing and comparative genomics analyses have become focal points in studying bio-control potential of entomopathogenic fungi, offering crucial insights about their biological characteristics and potential applications [
3]. For instance, comparative genomics and evolutionary analyses of the entomopathogenic fungus
Trichoderma harzianum have revealed the genetic features and evolutionary patterns related to its bio-control potential against plant pathogens [
4]. These findings offers deep understanding of the genetic characteristics, pathogenic mechanisms, and bio-control potential of entomopathogenic fungus. Whole genome sequencing has emerged as a powerful tool for understanding the genetic basis of biological traits and behaviors in various organisms. The complete genome analysis of
L. lecanii strain Lec8 revealed the genome size of 32.38 Mb, containing 9,531 genes, including those encoding proteins related to biosynthetic pathways which suggested strong entomopathogenic potential [
5]. Similarly, the complete genome sequencing of
L. lecanii strain 1502 which is known for its potential against aphids, revealed the genome size of 32.0 Mb, containing 9,312 genes [
6]. These findings revealed significant potential for
L. lecanii as a biocontrol agent though further research is needed for developing effective bio-control strategies. Fruit flies poses a major threat to a wide range of fruits and vegetables globally from tropical to subtropical environments due to their polyphagous nature [
7,
8].
B. dorsalis, in particular is a significant threat to horticultural crops in China and neighboring regions. Biological control of many insect pests including fruit flies, frequently employs entomopathogenic microorganisms [
9,
10,
11,
12]. This study aims to explore the entomopathogenic potential of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 against
B. dorsalis by utilizing complete genome sequencing and comparative genomics.
3. Results
3.1. Genome Assembly
The genome assembly of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 resulted in 27 contigs with a total length of 47,239,278 base pairs (bp). Key metrics include an N50 of 2,751,789 bp and an N90 values of 1,018,923 bp, indicating a higher proportion of larger contigs in the assembly and overall good contiguity. The GC content of the genome observed 51.16%, provided insights into its genetic composition (
Table 2). Importantly the assembly process gained closure without any gaps showing the of the genome assembly. This achievement is crucial for subsequent analyses such as gene structure analysis, functional annotation, and evolutionary analysis. The statistical results of gene assembly were as follows:
3.2. BUSCO Evaluation
We utilized the fungi_odb9 database in BUSCO [
16] which contains 290 conserved core genes for fungi to evaluate the completeness of our fungal genome assembly using BUSCO (v2.0). A total of 284 complete BUSCO genes were identified in our assembly, resulting in a genome completeness evaluation of 97.93%. Among these, 281 genes were identified as single-copy, constituting 96.90% of the total BUSCO genes assessed. The presence of these genes in a single copy showed the high accuracy and completeness of the genome assembly.
Additionally, 3 genes were identified as multi-copy, accounting for 1.03% of total genes. These genes likely exist in multiple copies or repetitive sequences influencing the assembly process. Four genes were predicted to be incomplete, accounting for 1.38% of total genes. These incomplete genes may result from assembly gaps or missing sequences in the genome as assembly process. Furthermore, 2 genes were not predicted at all, constituting 0.69% of total genes indicating that some conserved genes were not detected during the genome assembly process (
Table 3).
3.3. General Database Annotations
Gene sets were annotated using different databases GO Annotation, KEGG Annotation, KOG Annotation, Pfam Annotation, Swissprot Annotation, TrEMBL Annotation, and nr Annotation (
Table 4). A total number oof 13,867 genes were annotated indicating that the majority of genes obtained at least one functional annotation, providing a solid foundation for subsequent gene function studies For example, annotations varied across databases; GO Annotation annotated 9,994 genes, KEGG Annotation annotated 3,775 genes, KOG Annotation annotated 7,059 genes, Pfam Annotation annotated 10,510 genes, Swissprot Annotation annotated 8,390 genes, TrEMBL Annotation annotated 13,862 genes, and nr Annotation annotated 13,864 genes. For genes with lengths in the range of 100≤length<300 bp, annotations varied from 913 (KEGG) to 3,733 (All Annotated), indicating that even shorter gene fragments can obtain a certain degree of annotation. However, the genes with lengths greater than or equal to 300 bp, generally received higher annotation quantities. For instance, the nr database annotated 9,993 genes, indicating that longer genes are more likely to receive functional annotations.
3.4. GO Annotations
Gene Ontology (GO) annotation classification for the genes of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 given in
Figure 1. Biological Process (BP) with 4,444 genes, Cellular Component (CC) with 2,279 genes, and Molecular Function (MF) with 7,603 genes were found. Among these categories, the ‘metabolic process’ category has the highest number of genes, with 1,401 genes, followed by the ‘binding’ category with 938 genes. Additionally, there were categories such as catalytic activity, structural molecule, cellular component, and others, with gene counts of 689, 462, 239, and 218, respectively.
3.5. KOG Annotations
Energy production and conversion (C) contains approximately 1500 genes, the highest among all categories. This suggests that
L. lecanii possesses extensive energy metabolism pathways essential for adapting to variable environments and supporting
Figure 2 pathogenic potential. Amino acid transport and metabolism (E) included around 1000 genes indicating specialization in amino acid metabolism crucial for protein synthesis and cell growth. Nucleotide transport and metabolism (F) has a similar number of genes as the amino acid metabolism, approximately 1000 genes, reflecting complexity in nucleotide metabolism, crucial for fundamental life activities such as DNA replication, repair, and RNA metabolism. Carbohydrate transport and metabolism (G) also comprises around 1000 genes, indicating
L. lecanii’s ability to effectively utilize and regulate carbohydrate metabolism, crucial for energy production and carbon skeletons. Translation, ribosomal structure, and biogenesis (J) encompasses around 500 genes reflecting .
L. lecanii activity in protein synthesis, vital for its growth and development. Replication, recombination, and repair (L) includes a moderate number of genes, indicating
L. lecanii mechanisms for maintaining genome stability, crucial for its long-term survival and adaptability. Secondary metabolites biosynthesis, transport, and catabolism (Q) involves e relatively fewer genes, but is crucial for tproduction of bioactive compounds in
L. lecanii, potentially influencing pathogenic potential. Function unknown (S) encompasses genes whose functions are yet to be fully elucidated, Its presence suggested unexplored functional areas in the genome of
L. lecanii, which could include undiscovered novel functions or specific metabolic pathways.
3.6. KEGG Annotations
Figure 3 depicts the Glycolysis/Gluconeogenesis metabolic pathway in the genome of
L. lecanii KMZW-1, a fundamental pathway in cellular energy metabolism. This pathway begins with D-glucose and progresses through a series of enzymatic reactions, ultimately yielding pyruvate and ATP, crucial for energy production. Blue boxes in the diagram represent the presence of genes encoding key enzymes corresponding to the pathway, and the numbers within the boxes indicate the Enzyme Commission (EC) numbers, which are internationally recognized enzyme classification codes. Main steps include phosphorylation of glucose to glucose-6-phosphate (EC 2.7.1.1). Glucose-6-phosphate is then converted to pyruvate through multiple steps, involving key enzymes such as phosphofructokinase (EC 2.7.1.11) and pyruvate kinase (EC 2.7.2.3) Gluconeogenesis is the reverse metabolic pathway of glycolysis but involves different enzymes in certain steps. Alhough not detailed in the diagram, this pathway involves crucial enzymatic conversion that enable the synthesis of glucose, essential for cellular energy and metabolic processes in
L. lecanii KMZW-1.
The diagram also depicts other regulated metabolic pathways related to sugar metabolism, including Pentose Phosphate Pathway and Carbon fixation in photosynthetic organisms. These pathways essential for maintaining intracellular redox balance and synthesizing nucleotides, amino acids, etc.
The presence of genes encoding key enzymes in both glycolysis and gluconeogenesis pathways suggested that L. lecanii has the complete metabolic capability to regulate its energy production and storage.
Additionally, the diagram illustrates pathways related to sugar metabolism, such as Lactate fermentation and Pyruvate fermentation, which may function under anaerobic conditions or specific environmental condition.
Genetic Information Processing: Significant categories include “Ribosome” (101 genes, approximately 10%), “Spliceosome” (91 genes), and “mRNA surveillance pathway” (46 genes). These data indicate that
L. lecanii has complex protein synthesis and RNA processing mechanisms, which are crucial for its growth and adaptability (
Figure 4).
2. Cellular Processes: Processes like, “Endocytosis” (5%) and “Phagosome” (42 genes), which involve the uptake and processing of substances within the cell, likely play crucial role in L. lecanii’s nutrient acquisition and defense mechanisms.
3. Metabolism: Categories such as “Biosynthesis of amino acids” (166 genes, approximately 16%) and “Purine metabolism” (96 genes) encompass a relatively large number of genes, indicating that L. lecanii has complete pathways for amino acid synthesis, essential for cell growth and DNA synthesis.
Although not explicitly listed in the graph, L. lecanii’s genome likely contains genes related to environmental responses enabling it to adapt, to different environmental conditions, such as stress resistance. Also the presence of human disease-related categories though primarily focused on humans, may reflect potential mechanisms of interaction between L. lecanii and hosts, providing valuable insights into its role as a bio-control agent. Other Important Categories like “Peroxisome” (42 genes) and “Endocytosis” (5%) in cellular processes, as well as “Glycolysis/Gluconeogenesis” (73 genes) and “Citrate cycle (TCA cycle)” (42 genes) in Metabolism, these genes participate in cell energy metabolism and substance cycling, which are crucial for energy production and growth of L. lecanii.
3.7. Pathogenicity Test of L. lecanii KMZW-1 at Different Concentrations
The cumulative mortality of
B. dorsalis adults infected with varying concentrations of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 spore suspensions (female adults in Figure a, male adults in Figure b) over time are given in
Figure 5. The lines represent different concentrations of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 spore suspensions ranging from 1×10
4 spores/mL to 1×10
11 spores/mL, while CK (control group) represents the population not infected with the fungus. The cumulative mortality increases over time in all treatment groups, indicating that as time progresses, more
B. dorsalis adults were infected. In the female adult group treated with a spore concentration of 1×10
4 spores/mL, 6 deaths were observed on the 4th day, and the number of deaths continued to increase over time, reaching 10 by the 12th day. In the male adult group treated with a concentration of 1×10
5 spores/mL, 13 cumulative deaths were observed by the 7th day, reaching 16 by the 12th day. There is positive correlation between the concentrations of spore suspensions and the cumulative mortality of
B. dorsalis adults.
The higher the spore concentration, the higher the cumulative mortality rate over time. For instance, in the female adult group treated with a spore concentration of 1×1010 spores/mL, the number of dead B. dorsalis individuals increased to 21 by the 12th day. Similarly in the male adult group treated with a spore concentration of 1×1011 spores/mL, the highest concentration treatment group, the number of dead B. dorsalis individuals significantly increased, reaching 21 by the 12th day, the highest among all concentration groups. This likely occurred because higher concentrations of spore suspensions contain more active spores, increased the chances and speed of infection.
The difference between the control group (CK) and the treatment groups indicates that fungal infection was the main cause of increased mortality of B. dorsalis.
Regarding the time effect, in the early stages (e.g., first 5 days), the differences in mortality rates among different concentration treatment groups were not significant. However, as the experiment progressed, the mortality rate in the high concentration treatment groups becomes significantly higher than that in the low concentration treatment groups. This indicates that L. lecanii KMZW-1 requires some time to proliferate within the host and cause death.
By comparing the insecticidal rates of different high concentrations against female and male adults of B. dorsalis, it is evident that L. lecanii KMZW-1 has asignificantly higher insecticidal effect against male adults. At each concentration gradient, the insecticidal rate for male adults is approximately 10% higher than that for female adults.
Based on the calculation, the LogLC50 of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 against adult
B.dorsalis females was determined as 5.662 and against male adults as 4.486 (
Figure 6). A significant increase in the mortality observed as spore concentration increased from LogC4 to LogC9. Particularly at LogC6 and higher concentrations, the mortality rate rapidly reaches high levels, suggested a strong lethal effect of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 against
B. dorsalis.
4. Discussion
In recent years, whole-genome sequencing emerged as important tool for elucidating the genetic characteristics and biological mechanisms of bio-control fungal strains. Comparative analyses have revealed distinct genomic features among these strains including variations in GC content, numbers of coding genes, and specific gene clusters. In this study, Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) sequencing technology was employed with a sequencing depth of no less than 150X (second-generation ≥50X, third-generation ≥100X), ContigN50 ≥1M. The genome of L. lecanii KMZW-1 spans 47,239,278 bp, across 27 contigs, with a GC content of 51.16%. The completeness of the genome assessed by BUSCO was of 97.93%. Repeat sequences totaled 228,359 bp, showing 0.48% of the genome. Genome predictions identified a protein gene length of 2,304,086 bp, 41,984 exons, 28,086 introns, 4 repeat sequences with a total length of 1,029 bp, 78 rRNA non-coding genes, 4 non-coding RNA families, 303 tRNA, 49 non-coding RNA families, and 7 pseudo genes predicted with a length of 1,463 bp. antiSMASH analysis detected 29 gene clusters with a total length of 1,336,365 bp.
Our findings align with previous whole genome sequencing studies on different organisms. For example, through-genome of VD18R19 was determined to be 4,123,380 bp, in size with a GC content of 43.80%. It encodes 4,245 genes, including 85 tRNA genes, 30 rRNA genes, 33 sRNA genes, and 60 tandem repeat sequences. Using antiSMASH software predicted, VD18R19 was predicted to contains 6 genes cluster inovolved in the synthesis of antibacterial secondary metabolite such as surfactin, plipastatin, bacillibactin, bacilysin, bacillaene, and subtilosin A. Comparative genomic analysis indicated a high structural homology between VD18R19 and the model strain
B. subtilis 168 [
50]. In another study by Zhao et al. (2022), third-generation PacBio sequencing technology was employed to sequence strain CSR-2. The genome analysis revealed comprehensive insights into its genetic makeup and potential applications. The genome sequencing of strain CSR-2 showed a length of 3,202,366 bp, encoding 3,007 genes, with an average gene length of 943.76 bp [
51]. Similarly, whole genome sequencing of
B. subtilis strain DNKAS was conducted followed by comparative genomic analysis with eight other
B. subtilis strains, focusing particularly on genes related to biofilm formation. DNKAS has genome size of 4.15 Mb, with a GC content of 43.42%, and 4,359 predicted coding genes. Among these 4,217 genes were annotated with direct homologous protein cluster classification. Notably, DKNAS share 1,354 homologous genes with the other
B. subtilis strains stdudied. Furthermore DNKAS possesses 26 genes related to biofilm formation, including functional genes corresponding to
B. subtilis NCD-2 [
52]. This study performed comprehensive functional annotation of the genome of
L. lecanii KMZW-1, including annotations fron GO, KEGG, KOG, Pfam, Swissprot, TrEMBL, and Nr databases. The results showed 9994 GO annotations, 3775 KEGG annotations, 7059 KOG annotations, 10510 Pfam annotations, 8390 Swissprot annotations, 13862 TrEMBL annotations, and 13864 Nr annotations. In a similar study Li et al., (2023) conducted whole genome sequencing of strain SQ-2 using the Illumina MiSeq X10 platform. They used antiSMASH tool was to identify genes responsible for the biosynthesis of secondary metabolites. The genome SQ-2 was determined to be 3,486,537 base pairs, with a GC content of 46.63%, encoding a total of 4,298 genes. Eleven gene clusters associated with secondary metabolite biosynthesis were identified, including six clusters responsible for the synthesis of antifungal compounds such as bacillaene, bacilysin, butirosin, fengycin, bacillibactin, and surfactin [
53].
Similarly, Li et al., (2022a) employed a combination of second-generation Illumina HiSeq and third-generation PacBio sequencing technologies for whole genome sequencing of strain MC2-1. The complete genome size of MC2-1 was determined to be 3,929,792 base pairs, with an average GC content of 46.5%, encoding a total of 4,015 genes. The genome contains 86 tRNA genes, 27 rRNA genes, and 81 sRNA genes, along with 2 genomic islands, 1 prophage, and 9 CRISPR-Cas systems [
54]. Genes annotation in the NR, Swiss-Prot, COG, GO, and KEGG databases yielded 4,015, 3,347, 2,996, 2,841, and 2,223 genes, respectively. Due to high damaging potential of
B. dorsalis, its control often involves multiple tactics including the use of etomopathogenic fungus. In this study,
B. dorsalis adult females and males were treated with different spore suspensions of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 strain at different concentrations (1×10
7, 1×10
6, 1×10
5, 1×10
4 spores/mL). After 12 days of treatment, the cumulative average mortality rates of
B. dorsalis adults were recorded as follows: 56.67% (68.89%), 52.22% (58.89%), 44.44% (53.33%), and 34.44% (46.67%) for females (males), respectively, compared to a survival rate of 85.56% (80%) in the control group.
The calculated LogLC50 for L. lecanii KMZW-1 against female and male B. dorsalis adults were 5.662 and 4.486, respectively. Furthermore, after treatment with high concentrations (1×1011, 1×1010, 1×109, 1×108 spores/mL) of L. lecanii KMZW-1, the cumulative average mortality rates of B. dorsalis adults were significantly higher than the control 14.44% (20%) after 12 days, reaching 67.78% (75.56%), 67.78% (75.56%), 65.56% (77.78%), and 58.89% (76.67%), respectively.
These findings are consistent with the results of many other researchers assessing the pathogenicity of different entomopathogenic fungus against
B. dorsalis. For example, Cherry and Moore, (2006) extensively observed the infection of
M. anisopliae on
B. dorsalis and found that approximately 70% of the treated fruit fly larvae were heavily infected, with a survival rate of only 30% [
55]. These results indicated that
M. anisopliae has high pathogenicity against
B. dorsalis similar to the pathogenic potential observed with the
L. lecanii KMZW-1 in this study. Additionally,
B. bassiana is another commonly used entomopathogenic fungus that can infect and kill various pests, including
B. dorsalis. Field experiments involving
B. bassiana treatment showed an average mortality rate of 85% for
B. dorsalis. Furthermore, the hatching rate of oriental fruit fly eggs was significantly reduced to 35% [
56].
Similarly, Jackson and Dunlap, (2012) found that
Isaria fumosorosea treatment significantly reduced the survival rate of
B. dorsalis larvae upto 40% with an infection rate of 90% [
57]. In our studies,
L. lecanii KMZW-1 exhibited a concentration-dependent effect on both male and female adults of
B. dorsalis with a markedly higher impact on male adults. This suggests the strong potential of
L. lecanii KMZW-1 for use in integrated pest management programs targeting
B. dorsalis.