1. Introduction
Pain is an unpleasant experience that can cause tissue damage and inflammation at the periphery and hypersensitivity in the central nervous system (CNS) [
1]. At the level of the CNS, all components of the pain system undergo epigenetic, molecular, and functional reorganization following a nociceptive stimulus, which can result in a persistent or chronic pain state [
1,
2,
3]. The neurobiological aspects of nociception are generally well-characterized [
1]; however, there is a lack of comprehensive research on the regulation of epigenetics and the molecular mechanisms associated with the pathophysiology of burn injury-induced pain. Epigenetic regulations, such as DNA cytosine methylation, expression of noncoding RNAs, and certain histone modifications (such as acetylation, methylation, phosphorylation, etc.), have been found to play a role in learning and memory formation [
4,
5] as well as in several CNS disorders [
6]. Upon exposure to a noxious stimulus, epigenetic machinery can induce and maintain chronic pain states [
2,
3,
7].
Our understanding of histone modifications induced by burn injury remains limited. The majority of available neuroepigenetic data in pain research is derived from neuropathic pain models, primarily conducted in rats and focusing on the dorsal root ganglion [
3,
7]. Recent research into the epigenetic regulation of nociceptive circuitry has indicated that pain conditions related to tissue injury, such as burn injury or peripheral formalin administration, lead to increased phosphorylation of histone H3 at serine 10 (p-S10H3) in the ipsilateral dorsal horn of the spinal cord [
8,
9,
10]. Recently, we have shown that CRISPR/cas9-based mutagenesis of histone H3 in the dynorphinergic (Pdyn) neurons of the spinal dorsal horn decreases acute thermosensation [
11]. Similar outcomes were observed when the phosphorylation of S10H3 was inhibited by MSK1/2, indicating the importance of the p-S10H3 in pain processing [
8]. Therefore, p-S10H3 has been considered to play a significant role in acute pain sensitization. p-S10H3 can attract and interact with other histone H3 modifications, including histone H3 acetylation [
7,
12]. This interaction between different histone modifications can influence chromatin structure and gene expression. p-S10H3 acts as a bridge, facilitating communication between various epigenetic marks on histone proteins. This indicates the presence of additional epigenetic post-translational (PTM) tags by which nociceptive sensitization is triggered in response to (sub)acute painful stimuli. Therefore, we hypothesized that histone H3 undergoes additional post-translational modifications (PTMs) simultaneously with the phosphorylation of S10H3 in the spinal cord following burn injury. The primary objective of this study was to assess the impact of peripheral burn injury on histone H3 modifications in the spinal cord, utilizing chip-grade histone H3 PTM-specific antibodies.
Our previous findings confirmed that Pdyn neurons, a major component of the endogenous pain-modulating system, play an important role in the development of thermal hyperalgesia after burn injury, at least at the spinal cord level [
11]. Consequently, our further objective was to investigate the potential involvement of Pdyn-expressing neurons in the epigenetic alterations induced by burn injury.
A recent study by Mészár et al. [
11] shows that the histone H3 mutation at serine 10 does not impact formalin-induced chemo-nociception. This implies that pain models originating from different sources - such as burn injury
vs. formalin application - may activate distinct downstream pathways with unique gene expression patterns. To elucidate the pain characteristics induced by burn injury, we performed a genome-wide RNA-seq analysis to investigate the transcriptomic profiles of the lumbar spinal cord in mice following severe scalding-type burn injury. Additionally, the gene expression patterns elicited by burn injury were compared to those induced by formalin-induced inflammatory pain models in adult male mice. This comparative analysis facilitated the identification of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and the delineation of associated key signaling pathways and functional groups.
Our double immunofluorescence data provide direct morphological evidence highlighting the crucial role of Pdyn neurons in burn injury-evoked pain processing mediated via p-S10H3 in mice. The current study may also help us understand the epigenetic and molecular mechanisms involved in burn injury and provide evidence that the central processing of pain models with different origins converges and diverges along certain pathways.
3. Discussion
Burn injury leads to specific epigenetic reprogramming, altering functional gene networks associated with pain-associated behavior. Epigenetic tags related to burn injury pain (such as p-S10H3, H3K4me1, H3K4me2, H3K4me3, and H3K4me3K9ac) were elevated in the spinal cord of mice compared to non-treated control. Histone H3 phosphorylation at serine 10 was detected in most Pdyn-containing neurons shortly after burn injury. These findings highlight the role of Pdyn neurons in burn injury-evoked pain processing via p-S10H3. Notably, the differentially expressed genes (DEGs) observed between burn injury and formalin application indicate distinct segregation in pain processing mechanisms between the two groups. Our findings prove that the Wnt signaling pathway is a key player in the burn injury, while formalin exposure induces JAK-STAT signaling in mice.
Neurons in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord (SDH) are known to play a key role in the regulation of nociceptive information flow. Epigenomic regulation is essential to these regulatory mechanisms [
7]. Epigenetic mechanisms, particularly histone post-translational modifications (PTMs), play a vital role in regulating various biological processes, including neurodegenerative disorders [
15,
16] and neuropathic pain states [
7,
17]. In addition, it has been implicated in the pathophysiology of burn injury [
8,
9,
10].
Recent investigations into the epigenetic regulation of nociceptive circuitry revealed that tissue injury-associated pain conditions such as burn injury increased p-S10H3 expression in the SDH neurons [
8,
9,
10]. We have previously shown that CRISPR/cas9-based mutagenesis of histone H3 in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord decreases acute thermosensation [
11]. Similar outcomes were observed when the phosphorylation of S10H3 was inhibited by MSK1/2 [
8], indicating the importance of the p-S10H3 tag in pain processing. Therefore, at least in its early phase, p-S10H3 has been considered to play a significant role in pain processing. p-S10H3 is a dynamic modification that serves as a recruitment signal for other histone H3 motifs [
7,
12,
18,
19]. The concept of a “histone code” was first proposed by Strahl and Allis in 2000 [
20]. It suggests that stimulus-dependent modifications occur on one or more N-terminal histone tails, either sequentially or in combination [
20]. Hence, investigating the pain-specific "histone code" and subsequent gene expression alterations is of great (pre)clinical significance for understanding the mechanisms of various pain models. Based on the aforementioned concept, it is plausible to hypothesize that pS10H3 is not likely to be the sole modification in the spinal cord of mice following burn injury. However, little is known about additional histone H3 modifications in response to burn injury. To address this issue, histone H3 posttranslational modifications induced by burn injury were investigated using high-quality chip-grade antibodies. These antibodies specifically recognize various histone H3 PTMs, including phosphorylation at serine 10, mono-, di-, and tri-methylation at lysine K4, and multiple PTMs on histone H3 (H3K4me3K9ac). While these epigenetic modifications (PTMs) have been associated with the processing of neuropathic pain, as reviewed by Torres-Perez et al. [
7], their role in the context of burn injury remains unexplored. However, we cannot rule out the possibility that additional tags on histone H3 or other histone proteins, such as histone H4, may also be implicated in the modulation of tissue damage-associated burn pain.
Our findings indicate that burn injury had an impact on all histone H3 PTMs that were examined. Notably, three out of the five post-translational modifications (H3K4me1, H3K4me3, H3K4me3K9ac) showed significant upregulation in the overall protein levels of the spinal cord. This result aligns with existing reports (see below), and our confocal image analysis also supports this observation. It is important to note that methylation of histone H3 at Lys9 or Lys27 is generally associated with transcriptional repression, while methylation of histone H3 protein at Lys4, Lys36, or Lys79 is typically linked to transcriptional activation [
21]. Recent studies have indicated that histone acetylation in the spinal cord plays a significant role in the sensitization of nociceptors, particularly in animal models of neuropathic pain [
22,
23]. At the onset of a burn injury and during burn-induced tissue repair, there was a change in the acetylation pattern of histone H3 and H4 in the skin in a relevant porcine burn model [
24]. The results of the WES study suggest that heightened levels of histone H3 acetylation at Lys9 (K9) may contribute to the development of pain symptoms following tissue damage in a mouse burn injury model. It has been recently demonstrated that the overall level of histone H3 acetylation in rats increases in the spinal cords after burn injury [
25]. However, in a different study using a full-thickness burn injury model, rats displayed a significant decrease in histone H3 acetylation at lysine 9 (K9) six hours after lethal burn injury [
26]. We have not addressed this discrepancy. Nevertheless, these studies utilized varying antibodies and stimulus intensities (i.e., different burn pain models). The lack of significance in the p-S10H3 level in our WES assay might be due to this epigenetic mark being present in only a small subset of cells. As a result, this modification remains undetectable when analyzing the entire cell population in the spinal cord.
Most of the relevant data about post-translational modifications (PTMs) of histone proteins after tissue injury comes from studies on isolated skin tissue of pigs [
24], spinal cord tissue [
8], and brain samples of rats [
26]. Similarly to our study, their conclusions were based on a heterogeneous cellular population consisting of neuronal and non-neuronal cells. Studies published to date lack cell type-specific epigenetic analyses focused on a subset of a certain neuronal population. Own previous findings confirmed that dynorphin-expressing (Pdyn) neurons, which are a major component of the endogenous pain-modulating system, have an important role in the development of thermal hyperalgesia following burn injury, at least at the level of the spinal cord [
10]. Dynorphinergic neurons participate in diverse spinal circuits, influencing sensory processing. Specifically, they are involved in gating mechanical sensation [
27,
28] and chemical itch [
29,
30] as well as regulating thermal sensitivity [
10]. It should be noted that both GABAergic inhibitory and VGLUT2-positive excitatory Pdyn-lineage interneurons exist in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord [
10,
27,
31]. We have previously found that nuclei expressing p-S10H3 predominantly belonged to Pdyn+ neurons following peripheral noxious heat [
10]. Within these neurons, the excitatory dynorphinergic neurons, rather than the inhibitory subset, contribute to the processing of acute nociception in burn injury through a p-S10H3-mediated epigenetic process [
10]. This finding suggests that the two subpopulations of Pdyn neurons may have distinct functional roles in mediating nociceptive responses to different sensory modalities. Therefore, it would be valuable to investigate the specific contribution of these subgroups of Pdyn neurons to burn injury-induced epigenetic changes and subsequent molecular processes. However, this was beyond the scope of the current study.
Cell-type specificity was investigated using transgenic animals expressing cell-type-specific reporter genes. The Pdyn neuron-specific expression of various histone H3 tags was determined by conventional immunofluorescent staining utilizing transgenic Pdyn::EGFP animals. We found that a majority, potentially up to two-thirds, of the Pdyn neurons showed elevated histone H3 PTMs-IR signals after burn injury. However, significant differences between the ipsilateral and contralateral sides of the spinal cord were observed only for p-S10H3. Our data suggests that Pdyn neurons contribute to the epigenetic modifications associated with burn injury in the mouse spinal cord, which is supported by our previous observations [
7,
10].
Epigenetic modifications resulting from burn injury can influence gene expression patterns related to the stimulus, affecting sensory perception and the pain experience. The molecular mechanism of various chronic pain conditions was extensively studied in its acute phase (1–2 weeks after pain model establishment) and later in its chronic phase [
32,
33,
34,
35,
36]. However, the gene expression profiling of the spinal cord following burn injury has not yet been investigated. To the best of our knowledge, this study represents the first comprehensive profiling of gene expression changes and key signaling pathways in the mouse spinal cord following subacute burn injury using bulk RNA-seq. Moreover, we conducted a comparative analysis of gene expression patterns between burn injury and formalin-induced inflammatory pain in mice to gain deeper insights into the molecular pathogenesis of burn injury-induced pain. We aimed to determine whether identical or distinct transcriptional alterations are responsible for the development of pain elicited by various nociceptive stimuli. According to the criteria (-1 > logFC < 1), a total of 98 and 86 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified in the spinal cord after burn injury and formalin injection, respectively. Only a small number of genes overlapped between the experimental groups, indicating that a large proportion of genes were expressed differentially depending on specific sensory modalities.
The list of the top 20 up-and down-regulated genes in the L4-L6 spinal cord of mice after burn injury differed from what we detected after formalin-induced inflammatory pain. RNA-seq analysis revealed that the mitochondrial intermembrane space RNase T2 (RNASET2) showed the highest upregulation after burn injury. RNase T2 degrades rRNAs, enhancing nuclear transcription and protein translation through a compensatory mechanism [
37]. COMP was found to be overexpressed as a cell adhesion molecule, while MMP28, responsible for extracellular matrix degradation, exhibited reduced expression. The aforementioned alterations have a definite impact on tissue remodeling and the dynamics of the extracellular matrix, potentially contributing to an augmented sensitivity of the nociceptive circuit in tissue damage-associated burn injury. It has been reported that proteases such as MMPs play a crucial role in neuropathic pain by cleaving extracellular matrix proteins (perineuronal net) and/or activating IL-1β, and phosphorylating pERK1/2, which is a marker for central hypersensitization [
38,
39,
40]. The connection between tissue remodeling and noxious stimulus remains incompletely elucidated but is likely to promote a prolonged pain state, probably through mechanisms involving the activation of microglia [
41,
42]. Furthermore, MMP28 also influences the process of myelination [
43]. Burn injury led to downregulation of the relaxin (RXFP1) and adenosine receptors (ADORA3). These transcripts are implicated in neuroprotection by reducing inflammation and tissue damage [
44,
45]. Another important finding is that early response genes that control cell survival and proliferation, such as Fosb and Egr1, were among the most significantly upregulated transcripts in response to burn injury. Surprisingly, in the inflammatory pain model, they remained unchanged or slightly downregulated. Furthermore, genes such as RASGRP4 and BANK1, which are linked to the positive regulation of the MAPK cascade, ranked among the top 15 upregulated genes affected by burn injury. This result is consistent with our recent findings that up-regulation of p-S10H3 expression partially depends on ERK/MAPK downstream signaling in the spinal cord following various nociceptive stimuli [
8,
9]. Formalin treatment upregulated genes associated with energy production (e.g., MT-ATP8, MT-CO2), chromosome condensation (NCAPH), and inflammation (e.g., CD93) while downregulating genes involved in c-myc-mediated apoptosis (e.g., CDCA7) and the MAPK cascade regulation (e.g., C1QTNF1). The transcript encoded by the C1QTNF1 gene plays a role in the dysregulation of lipid metabolism and inflammatory responses in macrophages during the development of atherosclerosis [
46].
Regardless of their origin, both pain models lead to the upregulation of genes involved in mitochondrial function (e.g., HBA-A2, MT-ATP6). Recent transcriptome analysis revealed that hemoglobin genes such as HBA-A2 are significantly upregulated at the cortical level following spinal cord injury [
47]. In neurons, hemoglobin may be linked to their need for oxygen and their role in managing oxidative stress. It is believed to help protect against oxidative damage and support mitochondrial function [
48]. However, its specific function in neuronal responses to injury is an area of ongoing research. Egr4, a transcription factor, was also found to be overexpressed in response to both painful conditions. Egr4 provides neuroprotection in ischemic stroke by modulating the JNK signaling pathway, as outlined in a recent publication [
49]. Genes implicated in chromatin remodeling (CBX2) and the regulation of the apoptotic process (CASP15) exhibited downregulation in the spinal cord in response to noxious stimuli, irrespective of their origin. CBX2 can bind to histone H3 trimethylated at Lys-9 (H3K9me3) or Lys-27 (H3K27me3) [
50], thereby influencing chromatin structure. A recent study demonstrated that CBX2 inhibits MAPK pathway repressive genes via H3K27me3 to activate ERK signaling [
50]. Consequently, the downregulation of CBX2 in response to nociceptive stimuli may facilitate the permissive transcription of downstream genes. Interestingly, in chronic pain models, nerve injury resulted in the opposite effect on CBX2 expression [
35].
In our study, we conducted a KEGG pathway analysis to examine the upregulated differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in different pain models. We observed that genes associated with the apelin signaling pathway and arachidonic acid metabolism, along with protein degradation processes, exhibited a significantly higher level of upregulation following burn injury as opposed to the formalin model. Both apelin and arachidonic acid (AA) signaling are related to pain modulation and perception in the nervous system with opposite effects. Apelin has an analgesic effect, while the AA derivative prostaglandins exhibit pro-nociceptive activity contributing to pain exacerbation [
51,
52,
53,
54]. The KEGG pathway analysis uncovered that PI3K-Akt signaling and ECM-receptor interactions were more prominently associated with the formalin-induced inflammatory pain model than the burn model, which aligns with a previous observation [
55]. The two experimental pain models we utilized demonstrated nearly identical effects on focal adhesion, apoptosis, and thermogenesis, as evidenced by the comparable number of affected genes and the significance of their false discovery rate (FDR) values.
The activation of the Wnt signaling pathway is observed in CNS disorders caused by degeneration and neuroinflammation [
14]. This pathway is a crucial marker of neuronal inflammation and oxidative stress in CNS diseases and the progression of neuropathic pain [
22,
56,
57,
58]. Our research revealed that both typical and atypical Wnt signaling pathways appear to play a role in regulating burn injury in a mouse model, at least in the early phase of noxious input. A previous study by Wu et al. [
59] demonstrated the involvement of the Galectin-3 (Gal-3)-dependent Toll-like receptor-4 (TLR-4) pathway in a rat model of full-thickness burn injury, particularly during the later stage of the injury. We observed that burn injury led to the overexpression of Wnt ligands Wnt10a (canonical pathway) and Wnt11 (non-canonical pathway), along with their receptors Fzd1 and Prickle3. Notably, the non-canonical Wnt signal pathway influences the MAPK pathway as well. Prior research has supported the role of the MAPK pathway in burn injury-induced facilitation of the nociceptive circuit (central sensitization) and resulting hyperalgesia [
8,
9]. In conclusion, burn injury primarily affects the initial elements of both the canonical and non-canonical Wnt signaling pathways, with a specific impact on Wnt ligands and their associated receptors.
This study has several limitations. Firstly, the time course of epigenetic post-translational modifications in the spinal cord was not examined; only the 5-minute post-injury marks were investigated. Secondly, tissue collection for RNA sequencing was conducted 1 hour after the nociceptive stimuli, representing the subacute phase of the pain models. The sampling time was selected based on ethical and animal welfare considerations. Sampling at different time points is likely to result in diverse expression patterns. Thirdly, bulk RNA sequencing lacks the resolution to differentiate between specific nervous system cell types, such as neurons, microglia, and astrocytes. Not only neurons but also glial cells undergo activity-dependent changes associated with tissue injury. These changes are also mediated by epigenetic tagging, contributing to the development of pain facilitation, as confirmed by [
23,
60]. However, the current project did not address the investigation of such changes. Nonetheless, future studies should consider conducting cell type-specific analysis using single-nucleus RNA-seq to obtain comprehensive genetic profiling data of selected subpopulations. Fourth, instead of repeating multiple runs with RNA samples, a single run was conducted using pooled biological samples collected from 12-13 animals in each group. Finally, RNA-seq served as a preliminary/pilot screening method for the transcriptional profiling of experimental models of pain; however, the identified DEGs have not been validated at the protein or functional level. Recognizing our limitations, further comprehensive experiments will be necessary to confirm their actual significance in burn injury-induced nociceptive circuits.
Our findings enhance our understanding of central nociceptive processing in the context of burn injury. The current gene expression screening sheds light on the molecular mechanisms behind nociception from diverse sources. We hope that our study will generate exciting new hypotheses and experimental ideas for future pain research. Therefore, it is crucial to continue ongoing research in this field to improve pain management strategies for burn injury-related conditions.