3.1. Drugs of Covid-Box Showed High Activity and Selectivity against T. gondii Tachyzoites
The antiproliferative effect of 1µM of each 160 drugs and compounds present in the Covid-Box was screened against tachyzoites of the RH strain of
T. gondii for seven days of treatment. Thirty compounds inhibited parasite proliferation in at least 70% (
Figure 1A-H). Of the 30 best drugs, seven were excluded from the studies. Two (AF03, Amiodarone - MMV001992; BC06, Proscillaridin - MMV001433) were initially excluded because they presented signs of cytotoxicity for the host cells during the initial screening. Other five drugs (Itraconazole (AC06 - MMV637528); Doxycycline (AE05 - MMV000011); Cyclosporine (AF04 - MMV001860); Doxorubicin (BA05 - MMV004066); Digitoxin (BC04 - MMV002436) were excluded as their activity
T. gondii have been extensively studied before [
23,
28,
29,
30,
31,
32,
33] (See details of the compounds and drugs in
https://www.mmv.org/mmv-open/covid-box/covid-box-supporting-information). Thus, 23 drugs were selected for the IC
50 and cytotoxicity analysis (
Table 1).
The drugs Cycloheximide (MMV000031), Bortezomib (MMV009415), Digoxin (MMV002832), and (-) -Anisomycin (MMV1634116) were the most active, inhibiting the proliferation of
T. gondii with IC
50s values lower than or equal to 30 nM (
Table 1). The drugs Salinomycin, Mycophenolic acid, Abemaciclib, Midostaurin, Emetine, and LY2228820 inhibited T. gondii proliferation with IC
50 lower than 100 nM (
Table 1). The drugs Ivermectin (MMV672931), Almitrine (MMV1804175), Apilimode (MMV1804187), Bemcentinib (MMV1804190), Niclosamide (MMV003461), Regorafenibe (MMV1804185), and Merimepodib (MMV1804359) were also highly active against
T. gondii, presenting IC
50 in the range of 0.15 – 0.48 µM (
Table 1).
The cytotoxicity assay showed that most compounds were highly selective against
T. gondii, and the SI ranged from 3 to 304 (
Table 1). Drugs with IC
50s less than 30 nM (Cycloheximide and Bortezomib) had the highest SI. Overall, all 23 compounds were selective, and for three of them (Apilimod, Midostaurin, and Salinomycin), this is the first report of activity against
T. gondii (
Table 1).
3.2. Covid-Box Drugs Show Potential Oral Druggability
Through the SwissADME [
42] platform it was possible to obtain information about the physical-chemical properties of the drugs that showed the best activity against
T. gondii. From these analyses, it was possible to predict whether these compounds are in accordance with the predictors of Lipinski's rule of 5 (RO5) and Veber (
Table 2). We also compared PYR, SDZ, CLI, AZT, and ATO, which are currently used for treating toxoplasmosis. RO5 states that drugs with more than 5H-bond donors, more than 10H-bond acceptors, molecular weight (MW) greater than 500, and calculated LogP (a measure of lipophilicity) greater than 5 are less likely to have good oral absorption and permeation. In addition to the RO5 of Lipinski et al. (1997) [
43], the two predictors of Veber et al. (2002) [
44] also point that compounds with Total Polar Surface Area (TPSA) equal to or < 140 Å2 and with ten or less rotating bonds have a greater chance of success in oral bioavailability.
The analyses were carried out for the 23 drugs from the Covid-Box selected in the antiproliferative assay and those used as the gold standard (PYR and SDZ) and alternative (AZT, CLI, and ATO) for toxoplasmosis. As expected, PYR and SDZ results agreed with Lipinski's RO5 and Veber's predictors. among the drugs used as alternative treatments, only AZT violates two Lipinski rules (MW and 5H-bond donors) and one Veber criterion (TPSA <140Å2) (
Table 2). Of the 23 selected from the Covid-Box, 10 (AA02, AB03, AB04, AE06, AF09, BB10, BD08, BD11, BF06, and BG06) showed compliance with RO5 and Veber`s predictors (
Table 2). The other drugs and compounds showed at least one or more non-compliance with RO5 and Veber (
Table 2).
Information on the pharmacokinetic properties of selected drugs from the Covid-Box and drugs already used in treating toxoplasmosis were obtained using the platform. Caco-2 permeability values (log Papp at 10-6 cm/s) above 0.90 predict high intestinal permeability. The drugs AA04, AB03, AC10, AG03, AG04, AG08, AG11, and BA07 had log Papp at 10-6 cm/s above 0.90, and AB04, AE06, AF09, AH03, and BB10 showed values of log Papp at 10-6cm/s > 0.70 – < 0.90, which can be inferred that these also have the potential to present high intestinal permeability [
45]. The other drugs showed values below 0.60 log Papp at 10-6 cm/s (
Table 3). It should also be noted that even the compound BD11, presenting a Caco-2 value below 0.90 (0.553 log Papp at 10-6 cm/s, Intestinal Absorption (Human) = 69.8 %) (
Table 3) was the compound selected in the in vitro tests that most inhibited parasite proliferation with an IC
50 value = 0.02 μM (
Table 1). Volume of distribution values (VDSs) predict drug distribution in tissue. It is known that the lower the interaction of drugs with plasma proteins, the faster they will be absorbed and, therefore, the faster they will be directed to their site of action. Thus, the higher the VDSs value above 0.45 log L/kg, the more the drug is distributed in tissues than in plasma, and values below -0.15 L/kg are considered poorly distributed [
45]. Seven drugs or compounds selected from the Covid-Box (AA04, AE06, AF05, AG03, AG04, AG11, and BA07 showed high distribution, and the drugs used for the treatment of toxoplasmosis: SDZ and 0.329), and Covid-Box: AA02, AC10, AD02, AF09, BD02, BD08, BD11, BF06, and BG07 showed VDss higher than -0.15 log L/kg (
Table 3). Fraction unbound analyses showed that BF06 and BD11 were the drugs with higher proportion of free state in plasma (
Table 3).
The Central Nervous System (CNS) is a common site of infection of
T. gondii; thus, we evaluated the predictors for CNS and BBB permeability of the Covid-Box drugs (
Table 3). For CNS permeability, compounds with logPS > -2 are predicted to penetrate, but with logPS < -3 are unable to penetrate. From the Covid-Box, six drugs (AA02, AC10, AF09, AG08, BA07, and BG07) showed a prediction of CNS penetration, and 12 presented logPS between -3 and -2 and had the potential for penetration, too (
Table 3).
For BBB permeability, LogBB values above 0.3 predict that a compound could readily cross the BBB, and the ones with < -1 are poorly permeable [
45]. According to this platform, none of the drugs and compounds selected from Covid-Box and most of the current ones used for toxoplasmosis treatment showed prediction for high crossing into the brain. However, thirteen (AA02, AA04, AE06, AG03, AG04, AG08, AH03, BA07, BA09, BB10, BD11, BF06, and BG07) showed values > -1. Of the drugs already used in the treatment of toxoplasmosis, the only one with a value above 0.3 was ATO (0.401 log BB). PYR presented a value close to the expected value (0.278 log BB) (
Table 3).
Using the SwissADME platform, we obtained the Boilled-Egg graph, which also predicts if the drugs have the potential to cross the BBB and have high gastrointestinal absorption (HIA). The BBB permeability data provided by pkCSM was compared with the one provided in the Swiss ADME Boilled-Egg plot [
42]. Of the analyzed drugs used for toxoplasmosis treatment, only PYR and ATO showed characteristics with potential BBB permeability at the points drawn above the egg yolk in the graph (yellow color) (
Figure 2). The pkCSM program predicted that only ATO could cross the BBB (
Table 3). On the same graph, it is possible to predict the compounds' passive gastrointestinal absorption (HIA) properties. Those that were plotted in the egg white region (SDZ and CLI) would be more easily absorbed in the gastrointestinal tract by passive transport than the compounds that were plotted in the gray region of the graph (AZT) (
Figure 2A). In addition, the graph provides information such as whether the drugs are glycoprotein inhibitors. Only PYR, SDZ, and ATO drugs are not P-gp substrates (marked with red dots in the graph) (
Figure 2A). Compounds that are P-gp inhibitors show increased absorption, while P-gp substrates reduce their absorption [
46].
Of Covid-Box, AG04 (
Figure 2B), AE06, and BA07 (
Figure 2C) presented characteristics with potential permeability to the BBB (points drawn in the upper part of the yolk of the graph) (
Figure 2B-C); this information complies with the results obtained for BBB permeability with pKCSM. According to the results obtained in this analysis, none of the others are predictable for readily crossing the natural protections of the CNS [
47]. The drugs AA02, AA04, AB03, AC10, AD02, AG03, AG08, AG11, AH03, BA09, BB10, BD08, BD11, BF06, BG06, and BG07 (
Figure 2B-C) show potential for an easier absorption in the gastrointestinal tract by passive transport. Of the Covid-Box drugs: AA02, AB03, AB04, AF09, AG04, AH03, BA09, BB10, BD02, BD11, and BF06 are non-P-gp substrate (marked with red dots in graph) (
Figure 2B) and AA04, AC10, AD02, AE06, AF05, AG03, AG11, BA07, BD08, BG06, and BG07 are P-gp substrates substrate (marked with blue dots in graph) (
Figure 2C).
3.3. Analysis of the Effect on Ultrastructure Induced by Drugs and Compounds of Covid-Box by Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM)
To confirm that selected Covid-Box drugs and compounds exert a direct effect on T. gondii, we analyzed the ultrastructure by TEM of tachyzoites after the treatment with Cycloheximide (BD11), Bortezomib (BG06), (-)-Anisomycin (BF06), Ivermectin (AF05), Almitrine (AG04), and Merimepodib (BD08) (
Figure 3,
Figure 4 and
Figure 5).
Untreated parasites showed normal morphology and organization (
Figure 3A-B), tachyzoites treated with Cycloheximide at a concentration of 62.5 nM show increased endoplasmic reticulum area (stars) and alterations on the plasma membrane structure (arrowhead) (
Figure 3C). When tachyzoites were treated with 125 nM Cycloheximide, it was observed that vacuoles containing parasites were completely lysed; the asterisk shows the disruption of the cell membrane (
Figure 3D). Parasites treated with the drug Bortezomib at a concentration of 62.5 nM showed Golgi complex alteration (white arrow and star in
Figure 3E), disruption of nucleus (N) division, as evidenced by the presence of two and three nucleus profiles in
Figure 3E and
Figure 3F, respectively. Treatment with Bortezomib also caused vacuolization of tachyzoites cytoplasm (asterisks
Figure 3F).
The tachyzoites treated with 100 nM (-)-Anisomycin (BF06) showed disorganization of the endoplasmic reticulum architecture (stars in
Figure 4A-B, and inset B). It was also possible to observe drastic changes in the morphology and cell division of the parasite, making it possible to observe a single parasite with two nuclei (N) (
Figure 4C). Treatment with 1μM Ivermectin (AF05) (
Figure 4D-F) induced the formation of myelin-like structures [
48,
49] (arrowhead in
Figure 4D and inset), resembling a process of cell death by autophagy. In
Figure 4E,F, it is possible to observe tachyzoites showing intense vacuolization process (asterisks).
Treatment of the tachyzoites with 1 µM Almitrine (AG04) also induced myelin-like structures (inset in
Figure 5A) and impairment of the parasite's cell division (
Figure 5B).
Figure 5B shows a mass of mother cell in a drastic vacuolization process (asterisks) containing two daughter cells.
Figure 5C and inset also show a tachyzoite presenting Golgi complex (GC) disorganization. Changes in the Golgi complex (GC in
Figure 5D,E) were also observed in parasites treated with 1.5 μM Merimepodib (BD08). We also observed disorganization of the rhoptries (inset in
Figure 5E) and an intense vacuolization process (asterisks in
Figure 5F) after treatment with Merimepodib.
Figure 5.
A-F. Transmission electron microscopy of the T. gondii after treatment with the drugs AG04 -Almitrine and BD08 – Merimepodib for 48h. (A) Parasites treated with almitrine at a concentration of 1 μM showed an alteration in the cell division process, and it was possible to see two daughter cells in a single parasite; it was also possible to observe a process suggestive of autophagy in the tachyzoites (detail - white arrowhead in insert). (B) After treatment with almitrine, we also observed an intense vacuolization process (asterisks). (C) In addition, 1 μM almitrine also induced fragmentation of the Golgi complex (insert). (D) Parasites treated with 1.5 µM merimepodib induced Golgi complex fragmentation. (E) Another important alteration observed after treatment with 1.5 μM merimepodib was rhoptry disorganization, which can be seen at a higher magnification in the insert. (F) In this figure, it is also possible to observe the intense process of vacuolization in parasites treated with 1.5 μM merimepodib (asterisks). M - Mitochondria; N - Nucleus; GC - Golgi complex; Rp - Rhoptries.
Figure 5.
A-F. Transmission electron microscopy of the T. gondii after treatment with the drugs AG04 -Almitrine and BD08 – Merimepodib for 48h. (A) Parasites treated with almitrine at a concentration of 1 μM showed an alteration in the cell division process, and it was possible to see two daughter cells in a single parasite; it was also possible to observe a process suggestive of autophagy in the tachyzoites (detail - white arrowhead in insert). (B) After treatment with almitrine, we also observed an intense vacuolization process (asterisks). (C) In addition, 1 μM almitrine also induced fragmentation of the Golgi complex (insert). (D) Parasites treated with 1.5 µM merimepodib induced Golgi complex fragmentation. (E) Another important alteration observed after treatment with 1.5 μM merimepodib was rhoptry disorganization, which can be seen at a higher magnification in the insert. (F) In this figure, it is also possible to observe the intense process of vacuolization in parasites treated with 1.5 μM merimepodib (asterisks). M - Mitochondria; N - Nucleus; GC - Golgi complex; Rp - Rhoptries.