Particle preparation:
Silica particles half covered by gold (Janus particles) and isotropic particles (ISO fully covered by gold) were formulated to compare their properties. The particles are produced through attachment of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) or from the deposition of a thin layer of gold on a silica particles. Four classes of particles were synthesized: pristine silica, isotropic AuNPs/Silica particles (“called ISO”), Janus AuNPs/Silica particles (“called JP”) and Janus thin Au layer/Silica particles (“called JP-PVD”) (see
Figure 3 for the scheme of the different synthetic pathways). The silica particles were classically synthesized following the classical Stöber method [
41,
42] to produce 475±50 nm size particles (Figure SI-1 and Figure SI-2). The AuNPs of ~25 nm stabilized by citrate were synthesized using a reverse Turkevich protocol from Sivaraman et al [
43] (Figure SI-4).
The attachment of gold nanoparticles on the silica were obtained through the same chemical procedure for Janus and isotropic particles to ensure the similar linkage for both kind of particles. APTES is first grafted on silica surface in soft conditions (water and room temperature) following a protocol described by Cuoq et al [
19] to produce silica particles functionalized with amine group. Then, preformed citrate gold nanoparticles are attached trough the amine function to the silica particles by mixing under sonication the amine grafted silica with the AuNPs water suspension. This procedure allows to obtain AuNPs-silica hybrid particles. When applied on isotropic amine grafted particles, isotropic AuNPs/Silica particles are obtained and characterized by SEM (Figure 5 a). For the Janus particles, a prior step is needed to ensure a partial grafting of silica particles by APTES. This can be achieved by the scalable wax pickering emulsion method developed for 100 to 500 nm silica particles by Ravaine et al [
22,
44] and initially proposed by Granick et al for larger silica particles [
21]. It consists of attaching silica particles at the solidified wax/water interface of the so-called “colloidosome” to functionalize a part of the silica particle surface. Colloidosomes were obtained through the slight hydrophobization of the silica particles with CTAB, to produce an oil in water pickering emulsion above the melting point of the wax before a temperature quench in ice to solidify the wax. The optimal concentration of CTAB was identified by a combined zeta potential measure of silica coated with CTAB [
20] (figure SI-5) and SEM analysis of the colloidosomes produced for 4 CTAB concentrations below the CTAB critical micellar concentration (cmc) (Figure SI-6, SI-7 and SI-8). 0.02 mM and 0.04 mM CTAB produced well defined colloidosomes for the chosen wax (
Figure 4). The monolayer of partially embedded SNPs in 0.04 and 0.02 mM CTAB (observed at higher magnification in (
Figure 4b and d), respectively) confirms SNP wettability altered via aliphatic chains of CTAB. The size of the colloidosome in function of the CTAB concentration is summarized in Figure SI-9 and Table SI-1).
The colloidosomes serve as a plateform for partial grafting of the silica particles. The surface of silica not embedded in the solidified wax is grafted with APTES in soft conditions similar to the conditions used for isotropic particles. The Janus SNP-NH
2 particles were isolated by dissolving wax in hexane (Figure SI-10). Finally, the Janus SNP-NH
2 particles were functionalized by AuNPs through the addition of preformed AuNPs to the Janus SNP-NH
2 water dispersion in an ultrasonic bath. For Janus synthesis, the experimental parameters (CTAB concentration, silica concentration, ultraturax energy, APTES concentration, AuNPs concentration, ultrasonic mediation, etc ..) were optimized to ensure the reproducibility of the Janus particles production from one batch to another. The
Figure 5 shows the SEM characterizations of isotrope and Janus particles made of silica particles with grafted AuNPs. The gold and Si identification was verified by EDX for isotrope and Janus particles (Figure SI-11 and SI-12 respectively), however quantification was not possible because of the Si wafer used for the analysis.
Figure 5.
SEM images of a),b) isotrope silica nanoparticles functionalized with AuNPs (ISO) and c),d) Janus AuNPs/silica nanoparticles synthesized from colloidosomes strategy (JP). The red lines show the particle alignments.
Figure 5.
SEM images of a),b) isotrope silica nanoparticles functionalized with AuNPs (ISO) and c),d) Janus AuNPs/silica nanoparticles synthesized from colloidosomes strategy (JP). The red lines show the particle alignments.
The silica coverage rate by AuNPs and the average distance between grafted AuNPS can be extracted from the SEM images. Distance between particles can be directly measured on the SEM images or calculated in average from the number of AuNPs per SNP. The
Table 1 summarizes the obtained values.
The number of gold Nanoparticles per SNP, for isotropic and Janus differs by approximately a factor 2 (see
Table 2). The face to face distance between AuNPs is slightly inferior to the size of AuNPs diameter for both kind of particles ensuring that the produced particles are similar and only differ by the presence of an area of depleted of AuNPs for JP. The minimal distance between the AuNPs results from the equilibrium between VdW interaction and electrostatic repulsion between AuNPs (for 25 nm AuNPs size, the equivalence of the VdW potential with thermal energy is at 20 nm and for 20 nm AuNPs size, it is 15 nm) [
45,
46]. However, this minimal distance does not result in an 2D organized paving of the space, but rather as lines of AuNPs, that may reveal a subsequent order in the SNP or in the grafting process. Multiple SEM observations of JP highlighting distinctive asymmetric assembly of gold nanoparticles with minimal aggregates confirms that the protocol is successfully robust and reproducible with an efficiency for bulk quantity of around 100 mg Janus Particles with little variation from one particle to another. Recently, Trihan et al [
47] have shown that hetero-aggregation between amine functionalized silica particles and citrate stabilized gold nanoparticles is efficient to optimize the total gold density and homogeneity, emphazing the particle size ratio silica/gold to minimize the curvature effect. They obtained an isotropic surface coverage density of 15% with smaller AuNPs size (8 nm) on SiO
2 particles of 600 nm. In our case, we attain a surface coverage density between 7 and 10% for ISO and Janus particles, a number in the same range of order of the one obtained by Perro’s et al [
22] from bulk synthesis with colloidosomes. From their TEM images, 72 AuNPs (of 15 nm) can be counted with a ~ 15 nm face to face distance on Silica particles of 250 nm. With a different approach based on liquid/liquid interface in a microfluidic device, Abou-Hassan et al synthesized Au-SiO2 Janus particles with a surface coverage density of ~ 10% [
48].
In the literature, Janus particles have been highly reproduced from the Perro’s protocol based on solidified emulsion pathway, with however few characterisation on the Janus particles. Our originality here is to produce a family of particles with 2 different coverage rates (half and total surface) produced by similar grafting process.
Another kind of Janus particles were produced by Physical Vapour Deposition methods (PVD) of gold on spin-coated SNP on glass. The gold layer is deposited on a prelayer of chromium to ensure a good adhesion. A layer of 20 nm thickness gold was deposited, a value chosen to be close to the size of the gold NPs in the isotropic and Janus AuNP/SNP. Lastly, ultrasonication of the glass slide (submerged in Milli-Q® water) ensured maximum extraction of physically produced gold/silica janus particles (PVD). The PVD Janus particles were caracterized by SEM (
Figure 6).
Because of the sub-micron size of the particles, Focused Ion Beam (FIB) can not be used for the characterisation of the gold layer contrary to Rashidi studies on gold/polystyrene Janus particle of 5 μm diameter.27 Therefore, rough estimation of deposited gold layer was achieved by calculating the thickness gold layer from SEM observation of 17 PVD particles. At the resolution of ~ 5.56 nm/pixels, the value for gold layer in central position is ~20±2 nm, and ~18±2 nm around the edges, which is due to the curvature of spherical silica particles. These values are in coherence with the targeted deposited value chosen for the physical vapour deposition.
Summary of the different class of synthesized particles:
A family of 4 different particles have been synthesized. The
Table 2 lists the particles and their characteristic features (Janus or not) and briefly highlights the methods followed and the learning outcomes as important factors for the reproducibility. The Janus-PVD (JP-PVD) particles are heavier by nearly a factor two in comparison to Janus-AuNPs (JP).
Mobility in bulk solution:
The mobility of the four type of particles was studied by dynamic light scattering in the presence or the absence of H
2O
2. DLS has indeed the capability to characterize micro and nano motor motions. The correlation curves were fitted in most cases by one exponential, with a correlation time in the 7. 10
-4 s range. However, in some cases, a second exponential had to be added to adjust the signal, with a correlation time in the 3. 10
-1 s range (see Table SI 2) for the values and
Figure 7 for a typical example of one and double exponential fitting).
This two exponential behaviour appears in the literature for particles having a significant degree of anisotropy. One DLS signal is coming from the translation motions and one from the rotational motion. For the size of particles considered and the order of magnitude of the relaxation times that can be deduced from Eq 3 and 1, the fast signal can be assigned to translational motions and the slow one to rotational motions (when it is observed). However, the exact exploitation of the rotational component requires both polarized and depolarized DLS measurement that were not conducted here [
35,
49,
50]. Therefore, only translational diffusion constants are presented in
Table 3.
In the absence of H
2O
2, the diffusion coefficient can give access to the hydrodynamic radius through Stokes Einstein relationship. The radii measured are very near from the geometric ones expected for JP particles (see Table SI 3) which reached 700 nm! One explanation could be that the Janus particle present a unique heterogenitity of interfacial energy that is, in simulations, expected to impact their diffusion behaviour [
51]. We may connect this specific interfacial energy to the colloidosomes process that might leave residual wax on the surface. Another explanation could be that the pronounced asymmetry of these particles could reinforce the rotational DLS signal for these samples, leading to an apparent enlargement of the translational signal.
In the presence of H
2O
2, we observed a significative evolution of the diffusion coefficient for ISO and JP. Their maximum increase in diffusion is of about 30% and is achieved at 1% in H
2O
2.These values are in agreement with other, Janus systems composed of gold [
49] and ten times lower than the one obtained on Pt. No signitificative variation was observe for SNP, which was expected and JP-PVD, which was more surprising.
Comparison:
Our approach, based on a common synthetic platform, first revealed bias in the values measured in both methods used in particle motion qualification for Janus particles, DLS and PTV. However for both techniques, variation in diffusion coefficient is visible for gold functionalized SNP particles in the presence of H
2O
2, ensuring an effect of the reactivity between gold and H
2O
2.The chosen approach also demonstrated that the explicit preparation of Janus structure is not mandatory to obtain a motion at intermediate fuel concentration. In
Table 4, it is indeed shown that Janus particle are only marginal faster that the so-called ISO ones. However, if isotropic particles can achieve motion in chemical gradients, asymmetry is theoretically mandatory if the concentration in fuel is homogeneous [
16]. We can therefore consider three different possible hypothesis to explain the motions:
1) The catalytic activity create local gradient due to insufficient mixing during the measurement. However, it can not be the case in microfluidic experiments as particles explore all the space of the channels.
2) The catalytic activity is sufficiently low to occur at the same time only on a limited number of spots on the particle. The low number of spots distributed randomly will thus create an asymmetry. If it may not be sufficient for the production of a local chemical gradient, this may lead to asymmetric local heating, and thus to thermophoresis. This may explain why ISO and JP have similar efficiency at intermediate concentration in fuel (< 5%), but not at high concentration (10%) were the reactive sites will be more synchrone.
3) The AuNPs are not distributed evenly enough on the silica surface to ensure a real isotropy. This hypothesis was indeed introduced to explain the chemotaxis of PLGA gold particles [
14]. The main argument for this is the observation of a rotational component in ISO DLS signal that is the signature of anisotropy. The defects in the organization of the AuNPs on ISO particle are sufficient to provide them with their motion capabilities.
Our result do not allow to distinguish between the two latter explanation and may be a combination of the two phenomena.