1. Introduction
The male urethra can be susceptible to various pathologies, such as hypospadias or stenosis, which often require surgical intervention to restore function [
1,
2]. Current clinical treatments predominantly rely on the oral mucosa harvested from the inner cheek [
3,
4]. This tissue is advantageous due to its constant exposure to a humid environment, similar to that of the urethra. However, notable differences exist between oral and urethral mucosa and harvesting oral mucosa can lead to complications at the donor site. Additionally, the limited quantity of tissue that can be harvested may be insufficient in some cases.
In light of these challenges, alternative sources of graftable tissues have been actively pursued, with tissue engineering emerging as a promising solution over the past few decades [
5,
6]. Tissue engineering enables the reconstruction of tissues in the laboratory, providing potential substitutes for organs or serving as preclinical models [
7,
8,
9]. Regardless of the intended application, a precise understanding of the function and histology of a target tissue is essential.
Histological knowledge of the human male urethra is relatively incomplete. From the prostate to the urinary meatus, the literature generally describes two types of epithelia [
10]. However, a few studies have reported additional epithelia types, particularly in specific regions such as the distal Fossa Navicularis. For example, Holstein et al. described a region in the distal Fossa Navicularis containing cells rich in glycogen, which they hypothesized may play a role in protecting against urinary tract infection [
11].
To advance our understanding of the human urethral histology, it is crucial to conduct a detailed study of the urethra, defining its distinct regions and transition zones. Such research is particularly important for tissue engineering, where accurately replicating the native urethra is key to ensuring the functionality of engineered substitutes. This study, based on 4 specimens, aims to provide valuable insights for clinicians and researchers alike, offering a comprehensive and up to date reference for the human urethra’s histological organization.
4. Discussion
The interest in making this study was to provide pictures of the different epitheliums found in the distal male urethra. Many articles describe with schematic forms what types of epitheliums are present in the urethra, but they often simplify the classification and do not provide pictures to back their observations. For example, an article published in Nature Reviews Urology only described two types of epitheliums in the spongy urethra without any pictures [
10], whereas we observed 4 different sections and can provide pictures to back it. Some articles with pictures are available, but they are rare and often old. For example, one of the only article describing the majority of the epitheliums found in the urethra [
11], contains few pictures. Also, these pictures were good for the time, but limit the interpretations we can make, notably because they are not colored. These article also do not provide a systematic review of all the epithelium. The authors will select specific regions of interest and ignore the transitions between the different ones.
The epithelial tissues found in the distal male urethra can be categorized into four distinct types (
Figure 9). The glans is lined with a stratified squamous epithelium with excretory ducts. It is the only epithelium in the urethra with dermal papillae and a keratin layer. For the distal fossa navicularis, the epithelium is also stratified and squamous but lacks the excretory ducts. Notably, this is the only epithelium in the urethra containing glycogen. Additionally, a valvule was observed in this region of the urethra in two out of the four penises examined. The proximal fossa navicularis features a smaller stratified squamous epithelium with excretory ducts and glands. Finally, the spongy urethra has a rectangular pseudostratified epithelium, also containing glands and excretory ducts. Those observations were consistent with the four penises observed.
Our description of the epithelium lining the glans aligns with that provided by Holstein et al [
11] but expends the finding by noting the presence of dermal papillae and excretory ducts that are in this epithelium. The distal fossa navicularis is consistent with the description from both Holstein and Hausmann [
12]. In the proximal portion of the fossa navicularis, our observations are similar to those of Hausmann and Holstein, although neither study reported the mucous glands we identified. The epithelium lining the spongy urethra in our observations corresponds with descriptions found in various articles [
11,
13,
14].
The urethra contains various epithelial structures, each serving a distinct function. The keratinized epithelium found in the glans provides a better protection against friction. The dermal papillae, rich in small blood vessels, ensure an adequate vascularisation [
15], which is essential since this epithelium has multiple cell layers. The epithelium of the distal fossa navicularis contains glycogen in its upper layers, which provides a substrate for Lactobacillus bacteria, similar to those found in the vagina. These bacteria create an acidic environment that protects the urethra from ascending pathogens [
11,
16]. These lactobacilli constitute the normal FN microbiota, and can have various roles as demonstrated in FN or vagina: modulate the inflammatory response [
17,
18], promote wound closure [
18] and protect against infections [
19]. Protection from microbial, bacterial or viral infections is primarily due to the mucus, which traps microbes, but also to the acidification of the environment through the production of lactic acid [
20,
21]. There is also production of hydrogen peroxide and bacteriocins [
22,
23]. Finally, this flora competes directly with pathogens for their adhesion sites. A faster wound healing also limits the entry of pathogens. A decrease in lactobacilli in the FN or vagina correlates with an increase in sexually transmitted infections [
19,
24,
25,
26,
27,
28]. The epithelium in the spongy urethra, which expands through most of the urethra [
1], forms an impermeable route for the urine and the sperm to exit the body, while protecting the underlying tissue [
29].
These diverse epithelial structures found in the urethra highlight the importance of integrating the multiple types of epitheliums observed when reconstructing a urethra for patients with hypospadias. While the urothelium provides an impermeable pathway for the urine and the sperm, the epithelium of the distal fossa navicularis offers protection against infections. Current gold-standard tissue engineering techniques for urethral reconstruction only uses the urothelium [
10], but this approach does not utilize the protection offered by the fossa navicularis.
Along the urethra, many glands can be found, either in the epithelium or in the stroma. They are mostly present in the distal part of the spongy urethra and at the proximal end of the proximal fossa navicularis. These glands correspond to Littré’s glands [
30]. Two types were described by Krstić. The ones present in the epithelium are small and containing mucus secretive cells. The one in the connective tissue are bigger and have excretory ducts opening into the epithelium [
14]. We observed both types in our penises. The mucus secreted by these glands contains glycosaminoglycans, which protects the epithelium from the urine and the pathogens and lubricates the urethra to allow a better passage from the urine and sperm [
14,
31,
32].
Beneath the epithelium lies a dense network of blood vessels, which ensures efficient distribution of nutriments. Since there is no vascularisation in the epithelium, the cells must get their nutriments and get rid of their waste through diffusion, explaining the need of intense vascularisation under the basal membrane.
The two valvules seen in the distal fossa navicularis have previously been described as the lacuna magna or sinus of Guérin [
33]. This lacuna is formed by a septum (valve of Guérin), an extension of the ingrowth of the ectoderm that would normally form the distal fossa navicularis [
34]. This lacuna may also cause different symptoms, such as dysuria and post-void bloody spotting [
35]. Shenoy also describes the valve of Guérin as a “horizontal bar stretched across the roof of the navicular fossa” and documented observing it in 98% of cases. A reason explaining why we only found this valve in 50% of our penises comes from its small size and its localisation varying from one person to another [
36].
A limitation in this study comes from the facts that all the patients underwent a minimum of two year of hormonal treatment prior to sex affirmation surgery. Given that estrogen treatments can cause expansion of the distal fossa navicularis [
11], it is possible that this area expanded, altering the organisation of the urethra. However, this expansion could be advantageous for these patients. Specifically, if cells from the distal fossa are extracted and harvested, they could be used in tissue engineering to create vaginal-like tissue, which could then be grafted during the surgery. This approach may offer a better alternative to the current gold standard in vaginoplasty, which is penile inversion [
36]. Penile inversion has several downsides, including limited tissue availability and the absence of protective vaginal flora. At this moment, the only tissue engineering methods available for vaginoplasty uses buccal mucosa cells [
37]. However, this technique takes time and can create morbidity at the donor site [
38]. An engineered tissue coming from the patient distal fossa navicularis could provide a better protection against pathogens and HIV [
16], while also reducing the need of fetching tissues from other sites [
39].
Figure 1.
Urethra collection from male-to-female vaginoplasty surgery. A schematic representation of the region collected from the penis, A. A representative photo of a specimen, B. Puncture wounds are seen in the distal fossa (red circle). This specimen presented a macroscopically visible valvule (black circle).
Figure 1.
Urethra collection from male-to-female vaginoplasty surgery. A schematic representation of the region collected from the penis, A. A representative photo of a specimen, B. Puncture wounds are seen in the distal fossa (red circle). This specimen presented a macroscopically visible valvule (black circle).
Figure 2.
The glandular urethra. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining of the glandular urethra. Blue arrows highlight the keratin layer. Excretory ducts are pointed to by black triangles. Dermal papillae are labelled with yellow arrows. The basal membrane marked by a yellow star. Scale bars represent 100µm.
Figure 2.
The glandular urethra. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining of the glandular urethra. Blue arrows highlight the keratin layer. Excretory ducts are pointed to by black triangles. Dermal papillae are labelled with yellow arrows. The basal membrane marked by a yellow star. Scale bars represent 100µm.
Figure 3.
The glans-FN epithelial transition. PAS (A) and PASd (B) staining of the glans-FN epithelial transition. Glycogen apparition is pointed to by white arrows. Excretory ducts are labelled by black triangles. Dermal papillae are labeled with yellow arrows. Scale bars represent 500 µm.
Figure 3.
The glans-FN epithelial transition. PAS (A) and PASd (B) staining of the glans-FN epithelial transition. Glycogen apparition is pointed to by white arrows. Excretory ducts are labelled by black triangles. Dermal papillae are labeled with yellow arrows. Scale bars represent 500 µm.
Figure 4.
The distal fossa navicularis. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining were performed. The basal membrane is marked by a yellow star. Some glycogenated cells are labelled with white arrows. D1 shows a zoom of the epithelium. Scale bars are 100µm for A,B,C,D and 50µm for D1.
Figure 4.
The distal fossa navicularis. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining were performed. The basal membrane is marked by a yellow star. Some glycogenated cells are labelled with white arrows. D1 shows a zoom of the epithelium. Scale bars are 100µm for A,B,C,D and 50µm for D1.
Figure 5.
The proximal fossa navicularis. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining were performed. A gland in the epithelium is labelled with a black triangle. The basal membrane is marked with a yellow star. Scale bars represent 100µm.
Figure 5.
The proximal fossa navicularis. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining were performed. A gland in the epithelium is labelled with a black triangle. The basal membrane is marked with a yellow star. Scale bars represent 100µm.
Figure 6.
The spongy urethra. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining were performed. Glands are labelled with black triangles. The basal membrane is labelled with yellow star. Scale bars represent 100µm.
Figure 6.
The spongy urethra. H&E (A), Laidlaw (B), PAS (C), and PASd (D) staining were performed. Glands are labelled with black triangles. The basal membrane is labelled with yellow star. Scale bars represent 100µm.
Figure 7.
Glands in the spongy urethra. Alcian Blue staining reveals large glandular structures (A). Details are seen in A1. Scale bars are 500 µm for A and 350 µm for A1.
Figure 7.
Glands in the spongy urethra. Alcian Blue staining reveals large glandular structures (A). Details are seen in A1. Scale bars are 500 µm for A and 350 µm for A1.
Figure 8.
The urethral valvule. H&E staining of the distal FN (A). The tissue is oriented with the glans to the left and the prostate to the right. A1 shows a zoom of the valvule. A2 shows a transition from a thin to a thick epithelium. High density stromal cells are pointed out with a black star. Glycogen containing cells are shown with a white arrow. Scale bars are 700 µm for A and 400 µm for A1 and A2.
Figure 8.
The urethral valvule. H&E staining of the distal FN (A). The tissue is oriented with the glans to the left and the prostate to the right. A1 shows a zoom of the valvule. A2 shows a transition from a thin to a thick epithelium. High density stromal cells are pointed out with a black star. Glycogen containing cells are shown with a white arrow. Scale bars are 700 µm for A and 400 µm for A1 and A2.
Figure 9.
Summary of the urethral epithelial histology from the gland to spongy urethra.
Figure 9.
Summary of the urethral epithelial histology from the gland to spongy urethra.