Introduction
Maintaining the physiological function of blood platelets is crucial for overall hemostasis and several physiological processes [
1,
2]. Reduced activation response of blood platelets can lead to excessive bleeding, whereas hyper-activation of platelets contributes to thrombotic complications. Platelet hyperactivity is associated with several processes, such as inflammatory and immune responses, angiogenesis, atherosclerosis, regeneration of liver tissue, and cancer metastasis[
3,
4,
5,
6]. Platelet hyperactivity is related to cardiovascular disease (CVD) and many other human diseases, such as cancer, renal diseases, Alzheimer’s disease, and microorganism infections. However, the mechanisms are not well known [
4,
6,
7,
8]. The Framingham Heart Study revealed that persistent platelet hyperactivity is also associated with future arterial and venous thrombosis [
9]. Individuals with diabetes, a sedentary lifestyle, obesity, and insulin resistance have platelet hyperactivity, which contributes to atherosclerotic plaque development and other platelet-mediated diseases [
10,
11,
12].
Figure 1 depicts the association of platelet hyperactivity with CVD. Platelet hyperactivity is not only associated with CVD and stroke because platelet inhibitors slow down also cancer progression and related morbidities [
13]. Platelets play critical roles in inflammation and immune responses [
14,
15] by release of IL-6 and NFkB[
16], circulating platelet microparticles [
17,
18], and CRP levels [
15,
19]. The hyperinflammatory status can compromise the body’s response to external stresses and predispose to diabetes or atherosclerosis.
Beyond the hemostatic process, platelets are involved in many processes through complicated interactions with many cells. Aspirin is the most used antiplatelet therapy for the secondary prevention of CVD [
20] , even though it causes several serious side effects. There are several reasons, including the fact that 25-30% of people are aspirin resistant and the side effects, making aspirin unsuitable for the primary prevention of CVD [
21]. Aspirin prophylaxis is not recommended in individuals without CVD, as per the European Guidelines on CVD prevention [
22].
Maintaining regular platelet activity is critical in preventing platelet-associated diseases such as CVD, cancer metastasis, immune disorders, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, sickle cell disease, inflammatory diseases, bowel disease, rheumatoid arthritis, myeloproliferative disease, Alzheimer’s disease, the understanding the causes and mechanisms of action of the modifying factors of platelet hyperactivity are critical in preventing these diseases.
Consequently, there is growing interest in naturally occurring anti-platelet inhibitors that people can regularly consume. Many dietary antiplatelet components are identified that can reduce platelet hyperactivity without side effects [
23,
24,
25,
26,
27]. Bioactive compounds of dietary origin with antiplatelet activity become operative when continued platelet hyperactivity in response to inappropriate nutritional and lifestyle factors or exposure to smoke/air pollution [
28,
29,
30], hyperglycemia and hyperlipidemia [
31], and specific exercise patterns [
32]. This review highlights the development of bioactive compounds and their roles in preventing the hyperactivity of blood platelets and associated diseases.
Figure 2 shows that platelet hyperactivity is related to hemostatic and non-hemostatic diseases. The relevance of platelet hyperactivity in the context of many diseases, including the growing epidemic nature of CVD, has strongly suggested the use of more natural approaches in the primary prevention of degenerative diseases.
Platelet Hyperactivity in Many Pathological Conditions
Human blood platelets are involved in hemostasis and thrombosis, including inflammation, infection, immunobiology, cancer metastasis, wound repair, and angiogenesis [
33]. Since platelet hyperreactivity increases in hyperlipidemia, hyperglycemia, oxidative stress, and cancers [
34,
35], understanding how platelets become hyperresponsive and contribute to CVD under these conditions is needed to prevent CVD [
36].
Activated platelets secrete mRNA, nucleotides, enzymes, metal ions, microparticles, mitochondria, ATP, ADP, growth factors, chemokines, cytokines, protease inhibitors, adhesive glycoproteins serotonin, histamine, γ-aminobutyric acid, glutamate, epinephrine, dopamine, histamine, factor V, calcium and many others [
37,
38,
39]. Platelet microvesicles contain multiple bioactive molecules, RNA, and proteins involved in these processes [
40,
41]. The release of these factors by the activated platelets changes the cell membrane architecture, including blood vessel walls, affecting the immediate milieu [
24]. Platelet activation, aggregation, and the subsequent generation of an occlusive intra-arterial thrombus are essential in developing CVD and platelet-mediated diseases [
42,
43].
Pathological Conditions Such as Metabolic Syndrome, Insulin Resistance, Obesity, Hypertension and Tumors Enhance Platelet Hyperactivity
Metabolic syndrome (MetS) is a cluster of conditions related to abdominal obesity, insulin resistance, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, and inflammation [
44]. MetS is associated with increased platelet reactivity, probably caused by associated hyperglycemia, dyslipidemia, and low-grade systemic inflammation. Platelet hyperactivity in MetS is induced by inflammation, obesity, dyslipidemia, hypertension, oxidative stress, and other metabolic disease[
45]. Higher plasma levels of fibrinogen, PAI-1, thrombin, von Willebrand factor, factor VII, and other coagulation factors, as well as significant platelet aggregation, are also observed MetS [
46]. The MetS components increase platelet activation by increasing calcium concentration and activating arachidonic acid,20:4n-6 (ARA) signaling pathways. Platelet hyperactivity in dyslipidemia contributes to the thrombotic risk [
47]. Platelet activation in dyslipidemia is induced via classic agonist receptor signaling pathways and pattern recognition receptors[
47]. Platelets are stimulated by oxidized phospholipids present in low-density lipoproteins (LDLs) via specific pattern recognition receptors [
48]. CD36/fatty acid translocase is platelets' scavenger receptor for oxidized lipids [
48].
Oxidative stress may promote platelet hyperactivity by reducing physiologically accessible NO in MetS. Cigarette smoking and sedentary lifestyles also increase oxidative stress and platelet hyperactivity[
29]. Platelets oxidize LDL by stimulating the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and degrading the LDL receptors by releasing proprotein convertase subtilisin/kexin type 9. Thus, platelet dysfunction and hyperlipidemia stimulate atherogenesis[
49]. Moreover, reduced antiplatelet response to aspirin and higher platelet sensitivity toward agonists are observed in MetS. Therefore, hypolipidemic drugs modulate platelet function, whereas antiplatelet drugs normalize lipid metabolism. High levels of plasma leptin in obesity cause increased platelet aggregability[
50]. The overall effect of MetS and obesity contribute to platelet activation [
51].
Platelet function is influenced by ROS and nitric oxide (NO) metabolism [
52,
53]. Platelet aggregation is associated with increased glutathione disulfide levels and oxygen utilization. Changes may influence platelet-dependent thrombus formation in platelet or vascular redox status, antioxidants, and ROS and nitrogen species [
54]creation. Hyperglycemia, dyslipidemia, and insulin resistance in diabetic conditions induce platelet hyperactivity, activation of the vascular wall, inflammation, and endothelial dysfunction. Hyperglycemia also causes the overproduction of superoxide and activates protein kinase C and nuclear factor kB (NFkB) [
55]. NFkB stimulates the production of several inflammatory cytokines and increases cell adhesion molecules, such as CD40 ligand (CD40L). CD40L induces the production and release of pro-inflammatory cytokines [
56]. Since activated platelets express CD40L, indicating a link between hemostasis and inflammation [
57].
Diabetic platelets have an increased intrinsic activation profile, whereas these platelets have reduced influence of endogenous inhibitors and aspirin. Platelet hyperactivity in diabetes mellitus may result from hypersensitivity to agonists and loss of anti-aggregatory mechanism. Even though the usefulness of antiplatelet drugs in type 2 diabetes is not supported, Diabetic patients still use low-dose aspirin or other antiplatelet drugs as a potential therapeutic therapy [
58,
59]. In diabetes mellitus, there is an imbalance between platelet inhibitors such as NO and prostacyclin (PGI
2) and increased production of platelet-activating and vasoconstricting substances. Decreased endothelium synthesis of PGI
2 [
60] and reduced synthesis of NO was observed in type 2 diabetes mellitus[
61]. Platelets express receptors for adhesion and increased synthesis of TxA
2, thrombin, and deranged calcium metabolism in diabetes. Platelets shed more platelet microparticles (PMPs) in type 2 diabetics may play a role in inflammation and thrombosis. P-selectin-positive PMPs may aid in the recruitment and adhesion of leucocytes, and platelets initiate the atherosclerosis process.
Spontaneous platelet activation is involved in the hypertension [
62,
63,
64]. High blood pressure also stimulates platelet activation via increasing shear force on circulating platelets. Increased blood viscosity in patients with high blood pressure might also contribute to platelet hyperactivity. Under high-pressure flow, enhanced degranulation of platelets occurs [
65]. Atherosclerotic lesions induce platelet activation, possibly due to the dysfunctional endothelium and local flow disturbances [
66]. Numerous metabolic and physiologic changes in platelet reactivity in hypertension. Indeed, many studies have shown that various parameters of platelet activation are normalized with the treatment of hypertension[
67]. Platelets from hypertensive patients tend to form aggregates [
68], increased secretion of plasma β-thromboglobulin [
69], high soluble and membrane expression of P-selectin[
70], and increased intracellular levels of calcium[
71]. However, the association between these markers and the degree of hypertension or responses to therapy are not well known[
72].
Endothelial dysfunction is associated with the reduced production of platelet inhibitors and vasodilators, NO [
73]. Therefore, the reduced synthesis of NO increases hypertension and platelet hyperactivity [
74]. Similarly, dysfunctional endothelium produces less PGI
2 and increases platelet activity. Dysfunction of the endothelium in hypertension has a cross-talk with hyperactive platelets [
67]. Similarly, increased platelet activation/aggregation in response to endothelin could contribute to thrombosis [
75]. Hyperactive platelets are a critical earlier trigger for cancer-associated thrombotic events [
76,
77]. Interactions between platelets and tumor cells result in hyperactivity or activation of circulating blood platelets.
Modulation of Platelet Activity by Bioactive Compounds of Dietary Origin
It is evident that blood platelets play an essential role in maintaining hemostasis and, under hyperactive states, may also exert a pathophysiologic role and thus contribute to atherosclerosis and other diseases. In recognition of the roles of platelet hyperactivity in the atherosclerosis process, antiplatelet therapy has become essential in managing CVD. Indeed, antiplatelet treatment has significantly reduced the incidence of primary and secondary cardiac events in secondary prevention trials [
78]. However, the combination of lipid-lowering measures, blood pressure monitoring, and administration of antiplatelet agents decreased the incidence of cardiac events and strokes by up to 80% in people above 55 years old [
79]. However, aspirin’s effects are relatively weak and can cause severe gastrointestinal disturbances and bleeding problems in some individuals [
80]. Given the increasing incidence of CVD and the established role of platelet activity in mediating atherosclerosis, it makes sense to identify alternate means of maintaining platelet activity that does not increase bleeding time and are safe, effective and well-tolerated. This notion prompted research designed to understand the role of dietary ingredients in modulating platelet hyperactivity – i.e., dietary antiplatelet components.
Indeed, extensive in vitro and preclinical research demonstrates the efficacy of various food components in reducing platelet hyperactivity. However, there are only a small number of well-designed studies consistently demonstrating an antiplatelet benefit of only a few select dietary ingredients in healthy human subjects with measurable clinical outcomes. These include fish and fish oil, flavonoids in cocoa, and garlic. Therefore, this review's objectives are two-fold: summarize the available clinical science to substantiate the antiplatelet efficacy of these ingredients and highlight recent and emerging clinical evidence for a new dietary antiplatelet component derived from fruits, vegetables, and fish oils. The antiplatelet benefits of these ingredients on humans, along with clearly defined outcomes related to the primary prevention of vascular events, namely platelet function, are discussed. Therefore, there is an increased interest in identifying bioactive compounds from edible sources with beneficial health effects, efficiency, and fewer adverse effects [
4,
24,
81].
N-3 Fatty Acids
Since the first cross-cultural epidemiological studies in the 1970s, the CVD preventive role of n-3
long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (LCPUFAs), in particular docosahexaenoic acid,22:6n-3 (DHA), and eicosapentaenoic acid,20:5n-3 (EPA) emerged [
82]. Fish oil supplementation reduced platelet aggregation[
83]. E
ssential fatty acids, linoleic acid,18:2n-6 (LA), and alpha-linolenic acid,18:3n-3 (ALA), in turn, compete for desaturase and elongase enzymes for their metabolism to LCPUFAs. A higher dietary intake of ALA compared to LA leads to an enhanced synthesis of EPA and DHA metabolites, resulting in a higher production of TxA3 than the pro-aggregatory ARA-derived TxA2. Prostaglandin H2 is a precursor of other prostaglandins and thromboxane [
84]. Anti-platelet mechanisms of action by DHA and EPA are thought to be mediated via inhibition of phospholipase A
2 activity, which would diminish the liberation of ARA from platelet plasma membrane phospholipids; inhibition of platelet cyclooxygenase 1 (COX-1), which would decrease the conversion of ARA to TxA
2; competition with ARA for platelet COX-1 and formation of less active TxA
3, or by alteration of platelet membrane fluidity state; and inhibition of TxA
2 induced platelet aggregation and decreased receptor affinity for TxA
2[
85].
N-3 LCPUFAs have gained considerable attention for their ability to improve cardiovascular health and prognosis. In contrast, the n-6 fatty acids such as linoleic acid,18:2n-6 and ARA may increase platelet aggregation. Both EPA and DHA are incorporated into platelet membrane phospholipids replacing ARA, thus decreasing platelet aggregation via decreased production of ARA-derived platelet-aggregating eicosanoids [
23,
86]. EPA also competes with ARA for COX, reducing ARA-derived metabolites. Thus, EPA minimizes the synthesis of the pro-aggregatory ARA-derived TXA
2[
87,
88].
EPA and DHA also alter membrane fluidity, regulating receptor expression and thrombin generation [
89,
90,
91]
. Resolvins produced from both EPA (resolvins E) and DHA (resolvins D) reduce and inhibit thromboxane-induced platelet aggregation [
92]
. Oxylipins (11-HDHA and 14-HDHA) derived from DHA also inhibited protein kinase A-mediated platelet activation and regulated agonist-induced platelet aggregation [
93]
. DHA and its 12-LOX-derived oxylipins also modulated collagen-induced platelet aggregation.
Several studies such as
in vitro, clinical trial, observational, epidemiological and animal studies investigated the impact of seafood consumption and n-3 fatty acids on CVD. Human clinical studies showed that n-3 LCPUFAs impart antiplatelet effects. Fischer et al. (1983) [
94] showed that EPA supplementation at 4 gm per day through cod liver oil in eight healthy adult males for 25 days reduced platelet aggregation. In contrast, Gibney and Bolton-Smith (1988) demonstrated that consumption of a low dose of EPA (2.25 gm) plus DHA (1.35 gm) per day did not affect platelet aggregation in response to collagen or low levels of ADP in eight healthy adult males for six weeks. However, there was a significant increase in platelet aggregation when higher levels of ADP were used.
Additionally, platelet TxB2 production was affected [
95]. In contrast to other studies, the lack of DHA and EPA effect on platelet function may be due to the low dose of the n-3 fatty acids used in this study. In a randomized, double-blind study by Li and Steiner (1991), 3, 6, or 9 gm EPA per day supplementation to fifteen healthy adults for three weeks reduced platelet adhesion to fibrinogen within the first week. Under low shear rates conditions, the 3 and 6 gm per day inhibited platelet adhesion by 81.7% and 85.5%, respectively, and the 9gm dose inhibited rates of platelet adhesion at a similar level to the 3-gm dose. In contrast, platelet adhesion was maximally inhibited at high shear rates by the 3 gm of EPA per day [
96].
Pirich and colleagues (1991) also demonstrated that supplementing twenty healthy adult subjects with EPA (216 mg) plus DHA (140 mg) per day for six weeks reduced TxB2 synthesis and significantly increased platelet survival time [
97]. Indeed, the levels of DHA and EPA used were remarkably low, considering the positive benefits observed. However, this study's fish oil supplementation regimen also provided 390 mg of gamma-linolenic acid,18:3n-6. So, whether the effects observed above were due to the combination of DHA and EPA or the three fatty acids is unclear.
In 2002, Svaneborg and colleagues showed that 10 gm of fish oil per day to eighteen healthy adults significantly decreased TxA
2 production and showed no change in the bleeding time [
98]. In a more extensive randomized, double-blind study, Eschen et al. (2004) reported that EPA(3gm) and DHA (2.9gm) per day to sixty healthy adults for 12 weeks significantly decreased plasma P-selectin levels, used as an index of platelet activation [
99]. Consuming n-3 fatty acids for four weeks reduced platelet integrin (GPIIa/IIIb) activation, levels of fibrinogen, and factor V, but no effect on coagulation in healthy subjects [
100]. In 2008, Din and colleagues showed that 500 gm per day of mackerel consumption for four weeks reduced platelet-monocyte aggregation by ~35%, which returned to baseline after cessation of fish consumption [
101]. However, Eschen et al. (2004) found no change in soluble P-selectin levels [
99]. More recently, an open-label 4-week sequential study showed that EPA (1.86 gm) and DHA (1.5 gm) per day to thirty healthy adults decreased GPIIa/IIIb activation and significantly reduced the expression of P-selectin[
102]. Vericel and colleagues (1999) demonstrated that a low dose of EPA (30 mg) plus DHA (150 mg) per day for 42 days resulted in a reduction of platelet aggregation but not significantly [
103]. These data contrast those published by Croset et al. (1990) [
104] and Driss et al. (1984)[
105]. Herein, both investigators showed that low supplementation of EPA in elderly subjects significantly decreased platelet aggregation. In the study by Croset et al. (1990)[
104], healthy elderly subjects were provided with the EPA at (1984), which provided 150 mg EPA per day for one month[
105]. The discrepancy in the findings between the Vericel et al. study (1999) and that of Driss and colleagues (1984) and Croset and colleagues (1990) is most likely due to the level of EPA supplementation. In 2009, Guillot and coworkers[
106] demonstrated that 400 and 800 mg DHA per day for two weeks to twelve healthy elderly subjects significantly reduced platelet reactivity and TxA
2 production. Still, this effect was reversed when 1600 mg DHA per day was consumed. DHA intake at 200 mg/day did not affect platelet reactivity or TxA
2 production. The lack of an effect of very high intakes of DHA and EPA in healthy elderly subjects on platelet activity is consistent with findings from Larson et al. (2008), who showed no inhibition of platelet aggregation with 4 gm of n-3 LCPUFAs per day for 4 weeks[
102]. Most studies support the antiplatelet effect of marine fish or oils in healthy human subjects; although the dose used appears to be key in dictating a benefit, low and high doses do not always show a benefit.
Indeed, a meta-analysis of 15 randomized controlled trials in humans has confirmed that n-3 LCPUFAs inhibit platelet aggregation [
88]. EPA has also reduced P-selectin, oxidized LDL (ox-LDL) antibodies, and glycoprotein IIb/IIIa expression on the platelet membranes [
107]. Consuming 6.6 g of n-3 LCPUFAs reduced serum P-selectin expression, which may help to decrease platelet activity [
99]. However, the increase in the n-6/n-3 ratio has shifted the balance into a pro-aggregatory state.
The data on the primary and secondary prevention of CVD using n-3 LCPUFAs are controversial. The latest meta-analysis suggested that regular intake of fish oil may be a risk factor for atrial fibrillation and stroke among the general population. However, it may be beneficial in certain CVD cases [
108].
The published data support the use of n-3 LCPUFAs in reducing the risk of CVD or CVD-related death. The expert guidelines consistently recommend consuming at least 250 mg/day of n-3 LCPUFAs or at least two servings/week of oily fish for the general population [
109]
. However, the beneficial role of n-3 LCPUFAs in CVD is still not sure [
110,
111,
112]
. The clinical trials showed limited or no effect on cardiovascular health, which may be the result of heterogeneous populations, background n-3 LCPUFAs status, and consumption discrepancies [
113]
.
However, it is considered appropriate for all individuals to consume n-3 LCPUFA daily as there are some benefits associated with CVD risk reduction and no adverse effects at the recommended levels. Epidemiological and intervention studies showed that dietary intakes between 0.4 g and 1.8 g/day of n-3 LCPUFAs are optimum for cardiovascular health. Several systematic reviews, meta-analyses, and experts examined the role of n-3 LCPUFAs on the cardiovascular system [
109,
114,
115,
116,
117,
118,
119,
120]. Expert recommendations generally support the cardiovascular health benefit of n-3 LCPUFAs with a recommendation for a daily intake of 500 mg as DHA and EPA or 1–2 servings of seafood per week. The US Dietary Advisory Committee recommends at least two servings of seafood per week. American Heart Association recommends one to two seafood meals per week to prevent the risk of congestive heart failure, coronary heart disease, ischemic stroke, and sudden cardiac death [
116].
Metanalyses of several randomized trials indicated that n-LCPUFAs positively affect CVD outcomes for primary and secondary prevention. Marine n-3 LCPUFAs also improve CVD risk factors, including blood pressure, plasma lipids, and inflammation; however, many physicians do not recommend n-3 fatty acids, mainly due to controversial results in randomized trials.
Plant Polyphenols
Plant polyphenols protect the cardiovascular system by reducing platelet hyperactivity and oxidative stress [
121]. Polyphenols can impart several health benefits, including protection from atherosclerosis, thrombosis, inflammation, and platelet hyperactivity [
121,
122,
123,
124]. The amount of polyphenols varies in plant-based foods, including fruits, chocolate, beverages, vegetables, and grains[
125]. All polyphenols have the basic structure of an aromatic ring with a hydroxyl group. Polyphenols are mainly two groups, flavonoids, and nonflavonoids, despite numerous classes based on their carbon skeleton, phenol rings, and structural elements [
125]. Flavonoids are further classified into flavonols, isoflavones, flavanones, anthocyanins, and flav-3-ols, whereas non-flavonoids consist of phenolic acids, hydrolyzable tannins, and stilbenes.
There is accumulating epidemiological and clinical evidence demonstrating that flavanol-rich foods can positively influence hemostasis through mechanisms that directly or indirectly affect platelet function and, in this way, ultimately decrease the risk for hypertension and stroke [
126,
127]. Plant-derived foods and beverages, such as red wine, tea, grapes, grape juice, cocoa, and chocolate, are typically flavonol-rich. Hamed et al. (2008) proposed that flavonoids can competitively inhibit binding to platelet-derived growth factor and TxA
2 receptors, negating the effects of ARA - and collagen-induced platelet aggregation [
128]. In addition to their antioxidant activity, flavonoids inhibit platelet lipoxygenase or reduce phospholipase C activity [
129].
Most clinical studies were conducted with cocoa because cocoa products contain more flavonoids than teas and wines [
130,
131]. Wright et al. [
132] demonstrated that functional groups of the flavonoid skeleton regulated the polyphenol inhibition of collagen-induced aggregation. The flavonoid aglycone increases the hydroxyl groups on the A and B rings, decreasing flavonoid activity. In contrast, the presence of O-methyl groups can increase activity. On the other hand, a hydroxyl group at position C3 can increase flavonoid activity [
133]. In a study of 30 healthy adults, Rein et al. (2000) demonstrated that a cocoa beverage containing 18.75 g procyanidin and a total epicatechin content of 897 mg inhibited platelet aggregation and suppressed membrane GPIIa/IIIb expression and reduced the shedding of PMPs. PMPs are hemostatically active, phospholipid-rich microvesicles formed by activated platelets [
134]. Using the same level of flavonoids in another study of sixteen healthy young men, Pearson and coworkers (2002) showed no effect on GPIIa/IIIb activity or P-selectin expression. Heptinstall et al. (2006) evaluated the impact of different amounts of cocoa-containing flavonoids in twelve healthy volunteers[
126]. Study participants consumed 80 mg, 300 mg, 600 mg, or 900 mg cocoa flavanols. Cocoa drinks containing 600 or 900 mg of cocoa flavanols significantly inhibited platelet aggregation [
126].
Flavonols are present in red wine, tea, grapes, grape juice, cocoa, and chocolates. Hermann and colleagues (2006) showed 40 gm of dark chocolate consumption by 20 healthy adult male smokers significantly improved flow-mediated dilation and decreased platelet adhesion[
131]. Hamed and coworkers also evaluated the benefits of cocoa flavanols through dark chocolate consumption [
128]. Consumption of dark chocolate (100 g) for one week (~70% cocoa; 700 mg flavonoids) significantly decreased GPIIa/IIIb expression [
128]. Both the studies mentioned here are consistent with the findings of Innes et al. (2003) [
135]. Consuming cocoa-related products in moderate amounts inhibited platelet aggregation [
136].
Several reviews documented the impact of polyphenols on platelet function. Using different agonists, polyphenols' antithrombotic properties are determined by measuring their inhibitory effect on whole blood or platelet-rich plasma aggregation [
23,
26,
137,
138,
139].
Table 1 summarizes the impact of the consumption of polyphenols on platelet aggregation ex vivo. Cocoa is a rich flavonoid source that modulates platelet activity, including catechins, proanthocyanins, anthocyanins, and flavonol glycosides [
140]. Cocoa supplementation inhibited platelet aggregation when consumed acutely or chronically [
141].
Olive leaf extract contains various polyphenols and flavones that inhibit platelet aggregation and ATP release [
142]. The olive leaf polyphenols inhibit oxidative stress-induced platelet activation via antioxidant activity [
143]. Polyphenol reduces degranulation by scavenging H
2O
2, a substrate involved in the COX-1 activation. Nevertheless, polyphenols can inhibit aggregation and secretion by inhibiting intracellular pathways in platelets.
Chlorogenic acid present in fruits inhibits collagen- and ADP-induced platelet aggregation [
144]. Polyphenols dose-dependently inhibit platelet aggregation and ATP release mediated via the purinergic receptor- and GPVI pathways [
144].
In vitro studies showed that ellagic acid modulates platelet intracellular signaling pathways involving PLC/PKC pathways.
Zhou et al. [
145] reported that anthocyanin cyanidin-3-glucoside (C3G) significantly attenuated thrombin-induced platelet activation and ATP secretion in mice fed with high-fat diets. C3G also inhibited thrombin and collagen-induced platelet aggregation [
146]. Other low bioavailable polyphenols also had antiplatelet activity [
147].
Hydroxytyrosol (HT) acetate and aspirin have similar anti-aggregatory activity [
148]. However, HT-acetate had higher anti-aggregation activity than HT. A more significant anti-aggregation impact of aspirin and HT acetate was observed in whole blood aggregation induced by ADP or collagen compared with aggregation in platelet-rich plasma, indicating an alternative aggregation pathway involving leucocytes, erythrocytes, platelets, and other plasma proteins. Aspirin and the two phenolic compounds increase NO production in leucocytes, thus contributing to the anti-aggregation effect. NO can also affect platelet aggregation by modulating cAMP, cGMP, and TxA
2 synthesis. Propolis inhibited ADP-induced platelet aggregation via the P2Y12 pathway [
149] by decreasing the expression of the fibrinogen receptor (GPIIb/IIIa) [
150].
Gallic acid inhibits ADP-induced platelet aggregation via decreasing intracellular Ca
2+ levels, reducing phosphorylation and P-selectin secretion [
151] Olas et al. [
152] demonstrated that grape seed extracts (gallic acid, falvan-3-ols, and proanthocyanins) inhibited thrombin- and thrombin receptor-activation peptide (TRAP)-induced platelet activation and PMPs formation more than resveratrol [
153]. Furthermore, resveratrol and its analog isorhapontigenin inhibited ADP-induced platelet aggregation [
154]. Polyphenols inhibit the COX-1 and P2Y
12 pathways and may also attenuate PMP generation in activated platelets [
155]. Several polyphenols in grape seed extracts may interact with different pathways involved in platelet function.
Trimethyl-N-oxide (TMAO) is involved in the pathology of various diseases, including cancer and CVD [
156].
TMA is synthesized by the gut microbiota using dietary choline and L-carnitine as substrate; then, it is carried into the liver and converted to TMAO by flavin-containing monooxygenase 3 [
156]
. The conversion of choline and carnitine to TMA depends on gut microbiota diversity [
156]
. Therefore, gut dysbiosis increases high plasma TMAO levels and thus may ultimately result in atherosclerosis and CVD. TMAO induces platelet hyperreactivity and dyslipidemia and enhances platelet-mediated diseases such as atherosclerosis, insulin resistance, CVD, and other diseases [
157,
158].
TMAO enhances sub-maximal stimulus-dependent platelet activation by agonists through increased Ca2+ release [
157]
. Gut dysbiosis promotes atherosclerosis by increasing the production of TMAO [
159,
160,
161]. Gut metagenome analysis showed a relatively lower abundance of
Roseburia and
Eubacterium, while TMA-producing
Collinsella was higher in CVD patients [
162]. Targeting the gut microbiota and its metabolites can effectively treat and prevent CVD by modulating TMAO levels [
163,
164].
Several polyphenol-rich products lower plasma TMAO levels both in animals and humans [
165,
166,
167]
. Chen et al. [
165]
first showed that resveratrol decreases atherosclerosis via reduced production of TMAO synthesis via remodeling gut microbiota. This observation was corroborated in rodents [
166]
. A study involving 20 normal-weight subjects showed a significant decrease in serum TMAO after four weeks of supplementation with 300 mg of polyphenol-rich grape pomace [
167]
. The
polyphenol-rich extract tomato extracts lowered plasma TMAO in obese adults via modulation of gut microbiota[
168]
.
Water-Soluble Extracts from Tomato and Kiwifruit: The Latest Dietary Antiplatelet Regimes
Hyperlipidemia, hypertension, and hyperactivity of blood platelets are critical contributors to the pathogenesis of CVD [
169]. Hyperactive platelets, as observed in diabetes mellitus, insulin resistance, obesity, sedentary life, and smoking, contribute to the development of CVD[
170,
171,
172,
173,
174,
175]. Hyperactivity of platelets contributes to the progression of atherosclerotic plaque and other diseases [
86,
176]. Therefore, there is a need to decrease platelet hyperactivity through safe, effective, and practical approaches to prevent the risk of CVD and other platelet-mediated diseases. Consumption of fruits and vegetables protects against CVD [
177,
178,
179]. The bioactive compounds in fruits and vegetables may protect the cardiovascular system via different mechanisms, such as favorably modulating oxidative stress, plasma lipid levels, hypertension, normalizing platelet hyperactivity, and other CVD risk factors[
25,
180]. For example, plant flavonoids inhibit cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterase enzyme and platelet TxA
2 synthesis, the main mechanisms responsible for inhibiting platelet activation.
Consequently, these bioactive components in fruits may reduce more than one CVD risk factor, such as platelet hyperactivity [
23,
181]. Such nutritional antiplatelet regimes were identified in the water-soluble extract in tomatoes and kiwifruits[
27,
78,
182]. The aqueous extract of tomatoes, also known as Fruitflow® has undergone the most extensive preclinical and clinical testing to demonstrate its efficacy in inhibiting platelet hyperactivity. Recent studies showed that tamarillo, horned melon (kiwano), and raspberry extracts inhibited ADP-induced platelet aggregation [
183].
Tomato
Epidemiological studies demonstrated that consumption of tomato and tomato products are associated with a reduced risk of CVD [
184,
185,
186]. Tomatoes contain several compounds that might affect plasma lipids and platelet aggregation. The aqueous extract of tomato and kiwifruit inhibited platelet aggregation by 75-80%, whereas apple and pear had very little activity (2-5%) [
25,
180,
182]. These tomato anti-platelet compounds had a molecular mass of less than 1000Da and were highly water soluble and stable to boiling[
27]. After removing sugars, the isolated active tomato extract accounted for 4% of the aqueous tomato extract dry matter, later named Fruitflow®. Sugar-free aqueous tomato (later named Fruitflow® extract) showed potent inhibition of platelet aggregation
in vitro [
187]. Fruitflow® extract had three categories of compounds: nucleosides, simple phenolic derivatives, and flavonoid derivatives.
Though the mechanisms are not yet well known, however, Fruitflow® inhibits the GPIIb/IIIa activation step [
187]. Fruitflow® unalter basal platelet cyclic AMP levels
in vitro studies. In addition, Fruitflow® decreased the expression of P-selectin in the platelet membranes in response to ADP in whole blood [
78,
187]. Fruitflow® can strongly affect the size and longevity of platelet aggregates. Fruitflow® was also found to affect tissue factor (TF) binding to activated platelets, at least in part due to effects on P-selectin. These results demonstrate that the actions of Fruitflow® were consistent and mediated partly through polyphenols [
180,
188]. Effects on TF binding suggested that sugar-free aqueous tomato extract components could significantly impact some aspects of coagulation, such as thrombin generation. Fruitflow® inhibits platelet granule secretion by suppressing the Src-PLCγ2-PKC mediated granule secretory pathway. Platelet granule secretion occurs when collagen and thrombin bind to its receptor GPVI and PARS, and that causes activation of the downstream signaling pathway [
189]. In this pathway, sarcoma, a tyrosine-protein kinase (Src) family member such as Lyn, Fyn, and Src, is first activated by phosphorylation, activated Syk, then phosphorylate and activate LAT, which in turn causes phosphorylation of an adaptor protein PLCγ2 in which protein kinase C (PKC) bind leading to the activation of downstream effector, which induces platelet granule secretion. one study reported that Fruitflow® have the ability in alteration of generation of different interleukins such as IL-1β, IL-6, IL-10 and IL-12 and chemokines such as CCL2/MCP-1, CCL3/MIP-1α, CCL5/RANTES, CXCL8/IL-8, CXCL10/IP-10 of blood leukocytes[
189]. Fruitflow® interacts with immune cells and endothelial cells[
190]. It distinctly modulates the production of inflammatory modulators in a context-specific way and
in extenso presumably in different body compartments.
Consequently, Fruitflow® may beneficially enhance and attenuate inflammatory processes during acute and chronic inflammation. Fruitflow® modulates cytokines, chemokines, and adhesion molecules that produce cell trafficking, activation, and differentiation in different immune system compartments. However, the modulatory roles of Fruitflow® in immune and inflammation response in platelets are yet to be known. Fruitflow® is expected to have similar effects in platelets as observed with different immune cells.
The Fruitflow® prevents activation of integrin αIIbß3 (GPIIb/IIIa) [
78]. Fruitflow® also inhibited platelet aggregation and P-selectin expression in collagen-stimulated human platelets[
191]. Proteomics study demonstrated that compared with the Fruitflow®-treated collagen-stimulated platelets, only collagen-stimulated platelets, 60 proteins, were upregulated, and 10 proteins were downregulated. Additionally, 66 phosphorylated peptides were upregulated, whereas 37 were downregulated. Proteomic studies also demonstrated Fruitflow® also strongly affected proteins was protein disulfide isomerase (PDI), an oxidoreductase that catalyzes disulfide bond formation and isomerization. In platelets, blocking PDI with inhibitory antibodies inhibits several platelet activation pathways, including aggregation, secretion, and fibrinogen binding [
192,
193]. Glycosides related to quercetin in Fruitflow® demonstrated that they interact with PDI in this way [
194,
195]. The interaction of polyphenols with PDI suggested a possible mechanism by which Fruitflow® ingredients inhibit different platelet activation pathways.
Fruitflow® inhibited platelet function, possibly via suppression of Akt, GSK3β, p38 MAPK, and Hsp27 phosphorylation in collagen-induced platelet aggregation. The inhibition of platelet aggregation and modification of platelet proteins in collagen-stimulated platelets by Fruitflow® suggest that it can provide health benefits for people at risk of platelet hyperactivity-related thrombosis. The figure describes the mechanisms of Fruitflow®'s actions on the platelet activation pathway.
Human Trials and Animal Experiments Using Fruitflow®
Several human trials were conducted using Fruitflow® to determine the
ex vivo and the onset time of an acute anti-platelet effect after consumption [
24,
187]. An acute lowering of platelet aggregation response to ADP and collagen was observed three hours after consuming Fruitflow®. The range of onset times was from one and a half hours to three hours after Fruitflow® consumption. On average, these studies have shown an inhibition of the platelet response to ADP of approximately 17 - 25%, and platelet aggregability returned to baseline level 18 h after consumption of a single dose (150mg) of Fruitflow® [
196]. A study involving 93 men and women showed that men responded more than women, and people with higher risk factors for CVD were more responsive than others [
197]. Fruitflow® ingredients affect many aspects of platelet function, including thrombin generation. However, clotting time showed no significant increases from baseline levels in all intervention studies[
24].
A human trial demonstrated that the efficacious range for Fruitflow® lies between 75 mg and 300 mg [
198]. A single dose of Fruitflow® was compared with 75mg aspirin, either as a single dose or taken continuously for one week, and the platelet aggregability response was measured ex vivo [
199]. The effects of a single dose of Fruitflow® were similar to a 75mg dose of aspirin in terms of antiplatelet action, effects on thromboxane synthesis, and time to form a primary hemostatic clot in a study involving 47 healthy subjects [
199]. Unlike aspirin, Fruitflow®
’s effects were not cumulative as its effects did not irreversibly disable platelet signaling pathways[
199]. The antiplatelet effects of aspirin in healthy subjects are incredibly heterogeneous, with some subjects experiencing a massive increase in time to form a primary hemostatic clot while others respond poorly
. The more moderate effects of Fruitflow® were related to the reversibility of its antiplatelet action, rendering its use as primary prevention of CVD, in contrast to aspirin at any dosage.
Both Fruitflow® and aspirin affected 26 platelet proteins involved in platelet structure and function, coagulation, platelet secretory proteins, fibrinogen beta chain 5, Ras-related proteins, redox system proteins, and HSP70s. As described earlier, the platelet protein disulfide isomerase was affected by Fruitflow®, which regulates αIIbβ3 integrin activation.
Four weeks of supplementation of Fruitflow® decreased platelet aggregation and granule secretion in healthy Chinese middle-aged and older individuals [
200]. After a 2-week washout period, the platelet suppressive effect of Fruitflow® had disappeared. After four weeks of Fruitflow® treatment in the obese subgroup (
n = 14), significant declines in aspirin reaction units by 8.6% and in P2Y12 reaction units (PRU) by 7.5% were observed [
201]. Patients with arterial hypertension and obesity may potentially benefit from consuming Fruitflow® [
201].
The supplementation of Fruitflow® for four weeks in strenuous exercise rats reduced platelet hyperreactivity [
202]. Fruitflow® treatment also reduced black tail length, blood flow pulse index, and vascular resistance index, ameliorating microcirculation perfusion in a rat thrombosis model. Fruitflow® inhibited platelet aggregation induced by shear flow and alleviated the blood flow and microcirculation abnormities.
EFSA authorized Fruitflow® for daily consumption in 2009[
24]. The first Article 13 claim based on newly developed evidence or proprietary data (a particular category under Article 13(5)) was approved for Fruitflow® in 2009[
24]. The approved claim was based on the eight human studies (seven proprietaries) and seven non-human studies (three proprietaries) conducted with Fruitflow®.
Fruitflow® differs fundamentally from aspirin or other antiplatelet drugs in that its effects are reversible. This very significant property of Fruitflow® makes it suitable for use by the general population as a dietary functional ingredient, while antiplatelet drugs cannot be used.
Kiwifruit and Its Anti-Platelet Factors
Kiwifruit contains substantial quantities of several bioactive polyphenols [
203]. The familiar green kiwifruit,
Actinidia deliciosa has been investigated for bioactivity, especially its effects on the risk of CVD [
25,
204,
205,
206]. As in tomato extract, the aqueous extract of kiwifruits has maximum anti-platelet factors, which was unrelated to the fruits' antioxidant potential[
180]. Daily consumption of 2 or 3 kiwifruits reduced ex vivo platelet aggregation response, blood pressure, and plasma lipids [
25,
204,
205,
206]. The diverse activities of the aqueous extract of kiwifruit, such as anti-platelet, plasma triglycerides lowering, and anti-angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) activity, were shown [
25,
207]. The aqueous kiwifruit extract (KFE) inhibited ADP and collagen-induced platelet aggregation.
In contrast, KFE was not that effective against ARA-induced platelet aggregation. KFE-mediated inhibition of platelet aggregation may not involve TxA
2 pathway. The anti-platelet compounds in kiwifruit are water soluble and heat stable, and their molecular mass is less than 1000 Da[
25]. KFE had glucose (8.9 ± 0.4 mg/ml), fructose (9.9 ± 0.5 mg/ml) and sucrose (2.3 ± 0.2 mg/ml)[
182]. The inhibition of platelet aggregation by sugar-free KFE was concomitantly associated with inhibition of TxB
2 synthesis and inhibited PF4 release in a dose-dependent manner. KFE at 1.68mg/ml inhibited ADP- and collagen-induced TxB
2 synthesis by 91% and 81% [
208].
Human Trials
Several human intervention trials were conducted to investigate the
ex vivo effects of whole kiwifruits and KFE on platelet aggregation, ACE, and blood pressure [
25,
209,
210,
211]. In one human trial involving 30 healthy volunteers aged 20–51 years [
25] , consuming two or three kiwifruits daily for 28 days reduced platelet aggregation ex vivo. Consuming two kiwifruit daily inhibited platelet aggregation induced by ADP significantly (18% in case of 4 μM ADP and 15% in case of 8 μM ADP) compared with those at day 0 (
p < 0.05). A similar reduction in platelet aggregation was observed in response to collagen. Plasma triglyceride levels were significantly lowered on day 28. The total plasma cholesterol, LDL, and HDL levels were unchanged from days 0 to 28 in both groups [
25].
Another human trial showed that consuming one kiwifruit daily for four weeks reduced whole-blood platelet aggregation in healthy volunteers[
209]. The effects of consumption of 3 kiwifruit for eight weeks on blood pressure, plasma lipids, and whole-blood aggregation were investigated in a randomized, controlled trial in male smokers (aged 44–74 years) [
211]. In the kiwifruit group, reductions of 10 mm Hg in systolic blood pressure and 9 mm Hg in diastolic blood pressure were observed[
211]. Additionally, a 15% reduction in whole-blood aggregation and an 11% reduction in ACE activity were observed in the kiwifruit group[
211]. Although only blood pressure was decreased in hypertensives, no effects on other parameters were observed in the antioxidant-rich diet group. These diverse activities of kiwifruits, such as anti-platelet and anti-ACE, were also demonstrated in differently processed aqueous extracts of kiwifruits[
25,
207]. Not only green kiwifruits, consuming one gold kiwifruit daily for four weeks also reduced whole-blood platelet aggregation and plasma triglycerides in healthy volunteers[
209]. Consuming 2 mg of KFE in 10 g margarine inhibited
ex vivo platelet aggregation by 12.7% two hours after consumption by healthy volunteers (n = 9)[
182]. Another randomized, double-blinded, and placebo-controlled cross-over study in 50 subjects showed that KFE reduced systolic blood pressure by 5 mM of Hg after consuming KFE for a week (unpublished data).
Conclusions
Many studies have explored the relationship between dietary components, platelet function, and CVD risk factors. Several anti-platelet regimes have been developed, such as polyphenols, n-3 fatty acids, and fruits and vegetables. The overall data is positive for nutritional antiplatelets (such as fish and fish oil, polyphenols, Fruitflow, and KFE) to prevent CVD. However, platelet hyperactivity is also associated with many non-hemostatic diseases. Therefore, the impacts of these anti-platelet dietary factors on these diseases must be further investigated. The next question is, which of these nutritional antiplatelets is superior in its efficacy as an antiplatelet ingredient? At present, the Fruitflow® is the most studied potent anti-platelet functional food. Fruitflow®, developed from tomato-containing bioavailable cardioprotective compounds, can benefit people vulnerable to developing CVD.
Beyond efficacy, one must also consider the practical aspects of consuming such dietary antiplatelets daily. For example, dosing, product form, commercial viability, and cost should also be considered. Finally, reliable markers of platelet activity and blood flow and the techniques thereof need to be further studied.
Platelets become hyperactive in obesity, diabetes, a sedentary lifestyle, or hypertension, and in people who smoke. Platelet hyperreactivity is not merely an inevitable adverse effect of conditions but also a substantial contributing factor that exacerbates most human pathologies [
23,
173,
212]. Recent studies indicate that platelet hyperactivity is not just a biomarker of adverse effects but a condition that requires management. Modulating platelet reactivity towards collagen, ADP, and plasma triglyceride levels by functional foods could be of potential prophylactic and therapeutic benefit in preventing and halting pathologic processes.
An array of extensive basic, mechanistic, compositional, and several human trials testify to the cardio-protective benefits of Fruitflow® [
25,
180,
188,
213]. In addition to Fruitflow®, Kiwifruits have great potential for maintaining normal platelet activity.
It is now recognized that 20–30% of persons experience the so-called aspirin-resistance syndrome, in which the expected antiplatelet effects are not observed [
214]. This finding indicates an advantage of functional foods’ broad antiplatelet activity profile over single-target drugs such as aspirin. Dietary antiplatelet functional foods help provide suitably gentle and safe yet efficacious therapies to improve public health in response to various health challenges involving platelet hyperactivity.