3.1. Structural Characterization and Degree of Phase Separation of PUs
The polycarbonates of 1,6-hexanediol with molecular weights 1000 (CD1000) and 2000 Da (CD2000) have a linear structure differing in the number of carbonate groups (13 in CD1000 and 30 in CD2000) and carbonate of 1,6-hexanediol units (6 in CD1000 and 13 in CD2000). Therefore, the soft segments in the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 mixtures will have a different number of carbonate groups/carbonate of 1,6-hexanediol units depending on their polyols blends composition, i.e. the higher CD2000 content, the higher number of carbonate groups/carbonate of 1,6-hexanediol units, the higher length of the soft segments. On the other hand, a decrease of the hard segments (HS) content is expected in the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 by increasing their CD2000 polyol content [
39,
40]. In fact, C1000 shows the highest HS content and C2000 the lowest, and the HS contents of the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 are intermediate (
Table 1).
The ATR-IR spectra of the PUs are influenced by their HS content and number of carbonate groups in the soft segments. All ATR-IR spectra show the same absorption bands due to N-H stretching at 3356-3384 cm
−1, C=O stretching of urethane and urea groups at 1729–1737 cm
−1, C-H stretching at 2938-2942 and 2867-2869 cm
−1, and O-C(O)-O stretching of carbonate groups at 1256-1259 cm
−1 (
Figure 2) The wavenumbers of the C=O bands are higher in 80C1000-20C2000 (1741 cm
-1) and C1000 (1737 cm
-1), and lower in C2000 (1729 cm
-1), and gradually decrease by increasing the CD2000 polyol content in the PUs. This trend agrees well with that of the HS contents of the PUs. Furthermore, the ratio of the intensities of the C=O and the O-C(O)-O stretching bands - I
C=O/I
OC(O)O – in the ATR-IR spectra increases by increasing the CD2000 content in the PUs made with mixtures of polycarbonate polyols because the higher number of carbonate groups (
Figure 3). However, the I
C=O/I
OC(O)O ratio is higher in C1000 than in 80C1000-20C2000 indicating a structural change caused by intercalation of 20 wt.% CD2000 soft segments among the dominant CD1000 soft segments in 80C1000-20C2000.
The carbonyl species in the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 blends correspond to urethane, urea and carbonate groups, and the interactions between them should change depending on the relative percentages of CD1000 and CD2000 polyols. The percentages of C=O species in the PUs were assessed by curve fitting of the carbonyl region (1600-1800 cm
-1) of the ATR-IR spectra. A Gaussian function was used and the assignment of the different species was carried out following previous literature [
36,
41].
Figure 4 and
Figure S1 of the Supplementary material file show the curve fitting of the carbonyl region of the ATR-IR spectra of the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 mixtures. All PUs exhibit five different C=O species : Free C=O of carbonate (1743-1745 cm
-1), free urethane and carbonate-carbonate interactions (1733-1735 cm
-1), hydrogen-bonded urethane (1713-1725 cm
-1), free urea (1695-1697 cm
-1), and hydrogen-bonded urea (1654-1664 cm
-1). According to
Table 2, the lowest percentages of free C=O species correspond to C1000 and 80C1000-20C2000, i.e. they have a significant number of carbonate-carbonate interactions. It can be expected that the number of free C=O species in the PUs increases by increasing the amount of CD2000 soft segments, but 60C1000-40C2000 exhibits a higher percentage (33 %) than expected (
Table 2). This is an indication of the existence of a particular structure in 60C1000-40C2000. Furthermore, the percentage of free urethane and carbonate-carbonate species is dominant in all PUs and varies between 34 and 48 %.
The existence of interactions between carbonate groups via C−H···O intermolecular interactions has been demonstrated elsewhere [
42]. The increase of the C2000 soft segments in the PUs should decrease the percentage of free urethane species, but, at the same time, the percentage of carbonate-carbonate species should increase. However, the percentage of free urethane and carbonate-carbonate species is higher than expected in 80C1000-20C2000 because the existence of only 20 % CD2000 soft segments favors the carbonate-carbonate interactions. Similarly, the percentage of free urethane and carbonate-carbonate species in 20C1000-80C2000 is higher than in C2000 because the addition of only 20 % CD1000 soft segments favors the carbonate-carbonate interactions. In fact, the interactions between similar carbonate molecules are less stable than among the carbonate molecules of different natures [
42]. On the other hand, the lowest percentage of free urethane and carbonate-carbonate species corresponds to 60C2000-40C1000 which also has a high percentage of free C=O species indicating a particular structure.
The percentage of hydrogen-bonded urethane groups is somewhat similar (14-18 %) in all PUs except in C2000 in which is lower (
Table 2). The percentage of free urea is higher in C1000 and lower in 20C1000-80C2000, and the rest of PUs show similar percentages (10-12 %). The percentage of hydrogen-bonded urea is low and similar (3-4 %) in all PUs except in C1000 in which is higher (9 %).
The interactions among the polycarbonate soft segments impart crystallinity to the PUs [
36]. The X-ray diffractograms (
Figure 5) of the PUs show two diffraction peaks at 2θ = 20.0-20.1° and 2θ = 23.2-23.3° which intensities increase by increasing their CD2000 soft segments content (
Figure 6). 80C1000-20C2000 shows a noticeable crystallinity with respect to C1000 (
Figure 6) because the intercalation of 20 % CD2000 soft segments favours the interactions between CD1000 soft segments. This agrees well with the high percentage of carbonate-carbonate interactions at 1733-1735 cm
-1 in the ATR-IR spectrum of 80C1000-20C2000 (
Table 2). On the other hand, the increase of the crystallinity in the other PUs is continuous and gradual as their CD2000 soft segment content increases. However, the intensity of the diffraction peak at 2θ = 20.1° of 60C1000-40C2000 is somewhat lower because of its low percentage of carbonate-carbonate species, in agreement with its ATR-IR spectrum (
Table 2).
The structure of the PUs was also assessed by DSC.
Figure 7 shows the glass transition temperature (T
g) of the soft segments that decreases by increasing the CD2000 soft segments content in the PUs (
Table 3). The heat capacity at constant pressure (∆c
p) values in the glass transition of the soft segments of the PUs increase when they have 20-60 % CD2000 soft segments because of stronger interactions among the polycarbonate soft segments, and decreases in 20C1000-80C2000 and C2000. In the DSC curves of these PUs, a cold crystallization appears and the melting of the soft segments is also present (
Table 3). Furthermore, 20C1000-80C2000 and C2000 exhibit high crystallinity (X-ray diffractograms). Therefore, the mobility of the polycarbonate soft segments in 20C1000-80C2000 and C2000 is restricted with respect to the other PUs and the self-healing should not be favored.
After cooling down to -80 °C, a second DSC heating run was carried out. The DSC curves (
Figure S2 of Supplementary Material File) show the glass transitions of the soft (T
ss) and hard (T
hs) segments. In general, the T
ss values decrease and the T
ss values increase by increasing the CD2000 content in the PUs. Thus, C2000 shows the lowest T
ss value and the highest T
hs value, so this PU exhibits the highest micro-phase separation. In general, the degree of micro-phase separation in the PUs increases by increasing their CD2000 soft segment content.
TGA curves of the PUs should be sensitive to the interactions between CD1000 and CD2000 soft segments in the PUs.
Figure 8 shows that the TGA curves of C1000 and C2000 appear at lower temperatures than those of the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 blends. Because of the longer chains of CD2000 soft segments, the TGA curve of C2000 appears at a higher temperature than the one of C1000. On the other hand, all TGA curves of the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 blends are very similar. In fact, they have similar temperatures of maximum thermal decomposition (334-337 °C) and temperatures at which 50 % mass is lost (324-330 °C) (
Table S1 of Supplementary material file).
The thermal decompositions in the PUs can be better evidenced in the derivatives of TGA curves.
Figure 9 and
Table S2 of the Supplementary material file show two thermal degradations in C1000 (311 and 409 °C) and C2000 (317 and 421 °C) due to the soft and hard segments; the thermal decomposition temperatures are higher in C2000 because its higher number of carbonate groups. All PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 blends show one additional thermal decomposition at 334-337 °C with weight losses of 41-50 wt.% which is associated with the interactions between the carbonate groups of CD1000 and CD2000 soft segments (mix phase).
The viscoelastic properties of the PUs are affected by the interactions between the polycarbonate soft segments of different length [
43]. The most important decline of the storage modulus by increasing the temperature corresponds to C1000 and the storage moduli of the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 blends are higher, particularly in the region of the rubbery plateau (
Figure 10). The highest storage moduli values correspond to the PUs made with 20-40 % CD1000 + 80-20 % CD2000. On the other hand, the tan delta vs temperature plots of the PUs (
Figure 11) show one structural relaxation only in which the tan delta value and temperature in the maximum of tan delta vary. The tan delta value of the PUs decreases continuously from 0.38 to 0.16 by increasing their CD2000 soft segment content due to higher interactions between the polycarbonate soft segments and higher crystallinity. In other words, whereas C1000 and 80C1000-20C2000 exhibit a dominant rheological viscous regime, the rest of the PUs exhibit a dominant rheological elastic regime. Furthermore, the temperatures of the maximum tan delta in C1000 and C2000 are lower (10-17 °C) than in the PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 blends (24-30 °C) due to the more net interactions between the polycarbonate soft segments of different nature than the ones of similar nature [
42], and to the existence of a mixed phase of polycarbonate soft segments of different molecular weights.
Table 5.
Values of tan delta and temperature of the maximum of tan delta for PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 mixtures. DMA experiments.
Table 5.
Values of tan delta and temperature of the maximum of tan delta for PUs made with CD1000+CD2000 mixtures. DMA experiments.
PU |
tan delta |
Ttan delta (°C) |
C1000 |
0.38 |
10 |
80C1000-20C2000 |
0.27 |
30 |
60C1000-40C2000 |
0.21 |
26 |
40C1000-60C2000 |
0.20 |
26 |
20C1000-80C2000 |
0.17 |
24 |
C2000 |
0.16 |
17 |
3.3. Assessment of Self-Healing at 20 °C of the PUs
The intrinsic self-healing of PUs is mainly favored by the existence of free carbonate groups and carbonate-carbonate interactions, low micro-phase separation and crystallinity, and high mobility of the soft segments [
36].
Figure 13 shows the kinetics of self-healing of PUs made with CD1000 +CD2000 mixtures. The faster kinetics of self-healing and short self-healing time correspond to C1000 (1.4 s) and CD2000 does not exhibit self-healing at 20 °C. The increase of CD2000 soft segments reduces the kinetics of self-healing and increases the self-healing time of the PUs, more noticeably in 20C1000-80C2000 (8.3 s) (
Figure 14). Therefore, the presence of CD1000 soft segments, even in a small amount, imparts self-healing to the PUs, and the higher the amount of CD1000 soft segments, the faster kinetics and shorter self-healing time. This trend agrees well with the experimental evidences of ATR-IR, X-ray diffraction and DSC. Thus, C1000 and 80C1000-20C2000 exhibit fast kinetics and short self-healing times (1.4-3.1 s) because of the existence of free carbonate groups and important number of carbonate-carbonate interactions; furthermore, these PUs exhibit low degree of micro-phase separation and dominant rheological viscous regime. On the contrary, 20C1000-80C2000 exhibits an important percentage of free carbonate groups and carbonate-carbonate interactions, but also shows high degree of micro-phase separation and high crystallinity; therefore, the kinetics of self-healing is slower and self-healing time is higher. Interestingly, although 20C1000-80C2000 exhibits cool crystallization and low tan delta value, self-healing at 20 °C is shown.
Based on the previous experimental results, a dynamic non-covalent exchange self-healing mechanism between polycarbonate soft segments of different molecular weights can be proposed. Taking as a typical example the structure of 60C1000-40C2000,
Figure 15 shows how the intercalation of C1000 soft segments favors the interactions between urethane/urea and carbonate groups by hydrogen bonds with C2000 soft segments, disrupting the carbonate-carbonate interactions. At the same time, the number of hydrogen bonded urethane groups between C1000 and C2000 soft segments is reduced. Therefore, the higher number of carbonate-carbonate interactions and hydrogen bonded urethane groups in C1000 justify its faster kinetics and short self-healing time. Furthermore, the intercalation of CD2000 soft segments should decrease the number of carbonate-carbonate interactions and hydrogen-bonded urethane groups between CD1000 soft segments, which justifies slower kinetics and higher short self-healing time. Thus, upon application of a stress or a damage, the weak hydrogen bonds and carbonate-carbonate interactions are broken. Upon removing the stress, the mobile C1000 soft segments reform the broken interactions and self-healing is produced.
3.4. Adhesion of Stainless Steel/PU Adhesive/Stainless Steel Joints
In previous studies [
5,
7,
8,
24,
27,
30], PU adhesives with self-healing ability have been synthesized and their adhesion properties have been tested by single lap-shear tests. A broad range of shear values between 52 kPa and 5.7 MPa have been recorded.
The adhesion of the PU adhesives made with CD1000+CD2000 blends was determined by single lap-shear tests of stainless steel/PU adhesive/stainless steel joints. The shapes of the curves of the shear strength vs displacement of the joints made with 20C1000-80C2000 and C2000 are typical of the ones of structural adhesive joints [
44], i.e. the shear strength increases by increasing the displacement until a maximum shear strength is reached and, then, the joint is de-bonded and the shear strength suddenly decreases to zero (
Figure 16). However, in the curves of the joints made with 80C1000-20C2000 and 60C1000-40C2000, after reaching the maximum shear strength, the shear strength declined gradually (
Figure 16). This may be an indication of the existence of self-healing in these joints because once the adhesive is detached from the substrate during the shear test, it seems to re-join again losing gradually shear strength.
Figure 17 shows the variation of the shear strength values as a function of the CD2000 polyol content in the PUs. The shear strength values of the joints made with PU adhesives synthesized with CD1000+CD2000 mixtures range between 1.3 and 4.6 MPa, values which are quite acceptable for polyurethanes. In fact, these shear strength values are comparable with the reported shear strength value (5.69 MPa) reported by Wang et al. [
5] and by Longfang et al. (1.73 MPa) [
7]. Furthermore, the shear strength values of the joints made with PU adhesives synthesized with CD1000+CD2000 mixtures are significantly higher than the ones obtained by Li et al. (0.9 MPa) [
30] and by Xu et al. (51.6 kPa) [
27].
The shear strength values of the joints made with C1000 and 80C1000-20C2000 adhesives are similar (1.9-2.2 MPa) and they exhibit a mixed failure being mainly cohesive in the adhesive. The lowest shear strength (1.3 MPa) corresponds to the joint made with 60C1000-40C2000 adhesive in which a mixed failure, mainly adhesion failure, is obtained. The lowest adhesive strength of 60C1000-40C2000 agrees well with its particular structure derived from the competition of the polycarbonate soft segment of different molecular weights to interact. On the other hand, the shear strength values increase noticeably in the joints made with 20C1000-80C2000 and C2000 adhesives (4.1-4.6 MPa), and these PUs show self-healing at 20 °C, high mechanical properties and dominant elastic rheological behavior. These joints exhibit a mixed failure mainly adhesion in the joint made with 20C1000-80C2000 adhesive and mainly cohesive in the adhesive in the joint made with C2000 adhesive.