3.1. Complex Dielectric Permittivity
The frequency dependences of the real εʹ and imaginary εʺ components of the complex dielectric permittivity at different
H values are shown in
Figure 2 a) and b) for the investigated ferrofluid sample.
From Fig. 2 a) it is observed that for each constant value of
H, in the range (0 - 135) kA/m, the εʹ component decreases gradually by increasing the frequency from 0.1 GHz to 3 GHz. Regarding the variation with frequency of the εʺ component in Fig. 2 b) it is observed that εʺ shows a maximum at a frequency,
fmax between (1-2) GHz, for each
H value of the polarizing magnetic field, which indicates the existence of a dielectric relaxation process [
20]. Similarly, from Fig. 2 a) and b) it is shown that by increasing
H from zero to 24.47 kA/m, both εʹ and εʺ decrease compared to the value corresponding to
H=0, after which they start to increase with increasing
H, between 24.42 kA/m and 135.45 kA/m. This behavior of the components
εʹ(f,H) and
εʺ(f,H) depends on the shape of the particles and the orientation of the electric dipoles in the direction of the electric field [
21]. In the ferrofluid located in a coaxial line and subjected to a magnetic field perpendicular to the axis of the coaxial line, changes occur in its local structure, forming both small agglomerations of particles and large agglomerations of magnetic particles (so-called condensed-phase droplets) [
21], which can coexist with un-aggregated particles. The formation of small agglomerations of particles in the form of a chain in the presence of the magnetic field, as shown in Ref. [
22], leads to an increase in the eccentricity of the agglomeration, which results in an increase in both the εʹ and εʺ components, of the complex dielectric permittivity. Due to the large agglomerations of particles in the ferrofluid, their rotation is hindered by the neighbors in the agglomeration, the dielectric behavior of the ferrofluid being like that of a magnetic powder [
22,
23].
The presence of the magnetic field causes a reduction of the charge carriers on the surface of the particles, so that the electric dipolar moment of the particles decreases compared to the electric dipolar moment of the particle in the absence of the magnetic field, which leads to the decrease of both the real, εʹ, and imaginary component, εʺ, of the complex dielectric permittivity. As a result, in the case of ferrofluids, where there is a combination of the effect of condensed-phase droplets with small agglomerations and non-agglomerated particles, it will lead to the decrease or increase of the components of the complex dielectric permittivity on different domains of magnetic field, as we obtained experimentally in Fig. 2.
As previously mentioned, from Fig. 2b) the
εʺ(f, H) component has a maximum for each value of
H, which indicates the existence of a interfacial relaxation process, characterized by the relaxation time,
τ. Using the
fmax values corresponding to the maximum of the εʺ component for each
H value (Fig. 2 b)), in the Debye equation which states that
2πfmaxτ =1 [
24], we determined the
τ values of the relaxation time, whose dependence on the magnetic field is shown in
Figure 3.
As can be seen from Fig. 3, by increasing the field
H from 0 to approximately 60 kA/m, the relaxation time τ increases from 0.09 ns to approximately 0.13 ns, then for values H>60 kA/m, τ remains approximately constant at the value of 0.133 ns. If the values of τ(
H), corresponding to the εʺ component at all investigated values of
H, obeys an Arrhenius-type law, the following relationship can be written:
where τ
0 is a constant;
k is the Boltzmann constant;
T is the constant room temperature and
EA(H) is the activation energy of the relaxation process which depends on the applied magnetic field,
H. Considering equation (1), the relaxation time τ (
H=0), in the absence of the magnetic field and the relaxation time τ(H≠0), in the presence of the magnetic field, can be written in the form:
In relation (2),
Ea,0 and
Ea,h represent the activation energy of the interfacial relaxation process both in zero field and in the presence of a magnetic field
H, respectively, from which we immediately obtain:
This relationship allows the determination (for the first time) of the magnetic field dependence, and the variation of the activation energy of the relaxation process, in the presence of a magnetic field,
ΔEa(H), compared to the activation energy in zero field, using the τ values of the relaxation time from Fig. 3. The dependence
ΔEa,h(ΔH) is shown graphically in
Figure 4.
From Fig. 4, it can be seen that the variation of activation energy of the relaxation process,
ΔEa,h increases from 0 meV to approximately 9.3 meV, with increasing of the applied magnetic field,
ΔH from 0 kA/m to approximately 60 kA/m, then for values, H>60 kA/m,
ΔEa,h remains approximately constant at the value of 9.88 meV. This increase of
EA(
H), compared to
EA(
H = 0), can be correlated with the changes that take place in the local structure of the ferrofluid due to the presence of the magnetic field perpendicular to the axis of the coaxial line in which the ferrofluid is located, forming both small agglomerations of particles and condensed-phase droplets [
21], in agreement with the dielectric experimental results obtained, in Fig. 2.
3.2. Complex Polarizability
Starting from the Clausius-Mossotti equation [
20], in the harmonic regime, as shown in reference [
8] for the computing of the real (αʹ) and imaginary (αʺ) components of the complex polarizability, α, of a ferrofluid the following equations were used:
In Eq. (4),
NA is the Avogadro number; ε
0 is the permittivity of free space and
M is the molar mass of the ferrofluid. Also,
Kʹ and
Kʺ represent the real and imaginary components of the complex form of the Clausius-Mossotti factor,
K=(ε-1)/(ε+2). Considering the complex form of the dielectric permittivity,
ε=εʹ-iεʺ, the components
K' and
K'' are given by the relations:
Using the values of components
εʹ(f, H) and
εʺ(f, H) of the complex dielectric permittivity, from Fig. 2 a) and b) with relations (5) and (6) the components
Kʹ and
Kʺ were computed. The frequency dependence of these components (
K' and
K''), for different values of the magnetic field, is shown in
Figure 5. As can be observed from fig. 5, the frequency dependence of the
K' and
K'' components of the Clausius-Mossotti complex factor, for different values of
H, are similar to the dependencies
εʹ(f, H) and
εʺ(f, H) of the complex dielectric permittivity (Fig. 2 b)).
To determine the real,
α'(f, H), and imaginary,
α''(f, H), components of the total complex polarizability,
α, using equation (4) and the values
K'(f, H) and
K''(f, H) from Fig. 5, it is necessary to compute the factor (
3ε0M/ρFNA). For this ferrofluid sample, the molar mass M, was computed as shown in Ref. [
25], and the obtained value is M=196.73 g/mol. As a results, the value obtained for the factor (
3ε0M/ρFNA) is 6.97 ·10
−39 F·m
2. Consequently, the real,
α'(f,H) and imaginary,
α''(f,H) components of the total complex polarizability, α, from equation (4), were determined and their frequency dependence at different values of the magnetic field is shown in
Figure 6.
In the microwave frequencies range (between 0.1 GHz and 3 GHz), as can be observed from Fig. 6, the component α' decreases for all magnetic field values, and α'' component, presents a maximum at a frequency fmax,α, as in the case of the K'' component of the Clausius-Mossotti complex factor (Fig. 5). At the same time, from Fig. 6 it can be seen that by increasing of H from zero to 24.47 kA/m, both α' and α'' decrease compared to the value corresponding to H=0, after which they start to increase by increasing H from 24.42 kA/m up to 135.45 kA/m.
It is known that [
20] the total polarizability can be due to the combined effects corresponding to both electrical conduction losses and different polarization mechanisms: electronic or ionic displacement and dipolar polarization. As shown in Ref. [
8], at high frequencies (above 200 kHz), the dipolar orientation mechanism is predominant in the total polarization of the ferrofluid, the polarizability,
α’ is given by the relation [
20].
Using relation (7) and knowing the
αʹ values of the polarizability corresponding to each
H value of the magnetic field, we determined for the first time the dependence on the magnetic field,
H of the electric dipolar moment,
p of the ferrofluid nanoparticles, at different frequencies of the microwave field, represented graphically in
Figure 7.
As can be seen in Fig. 7, for all investigated microwave frequencies, by increasing the magnetic field from zero to approximately 30 kA/m, the electric dipolar moment decreases to a minimum value, after which it increases with increasing magnetic field. The electric dipolar moment p decreases with increasing frequency, between the approximate values of 6.3 x 10-30 C·m and 5.9 x 10-30 C·m. This result is in agreement with the frequency and magnetic field dependence of the component εʹ(f H) of the complex dielectric permittivity (Fig. 2 a)). In the presence of the magnetic field, there is a decrease in the number of charge carriers on the surface of the particles, so that the electric dipolar moment of the particles decreases compared to the electric dipole moment of the particle in the absence of magnetic field.
3.3. The electrical conductivity
Using the experimental data of the complex dielectric permittivity in Fig. 2 b), the real component σ, of the complex electrical conductivity can be calculated [
20] from the relation:
The frequency dependence of σ, in the microwave range and at different values
H of polarizing magnetic field is shown in
Figure 8.
As can be observed from Fig. 8, at a constant value
H, the conductivity,
σ, of the ferrofluid presents a linear region at low frequencies, similar to DC-conductivity (σ
DC) and a dispersion region, at higher frequencies, corresponding to AC-conductivity (σ
AC), in accordance with the Jonscher universal law [
26], generally known for the variation with frequency and temperature of the electrical conductivity of a sample [
27]:
In this work, the temperature is constant and the variation of the conductivity
σ, of the ferrofluid was studied as a function of frequency and magnetic field, the result obtained in Fig. 8, agreeing with Jonscher's universal law like a dependence on frequency and temperature of electrical conductivity [
27]. As can be seen in Fig. 8, the
σDC conductivity does not depend on the frequency but only on the magnetic field
H, while the conductivity
σAC depends on both the frequency and the field
H. In relation (10), according to Jonscher's law [
26], the
σAC conductivity is given by the relation:
where
n is an exponent dependent on the magnetic field, at constant temperature (0 < n < 1) and
A0 is a pre-exponential factor [
26,
28]. From Fig. 8, the conductivity values
σDC(H) were determined for all the measured
H values of the magnetic field. Using the experimental values obtained for the static conductivity,
σDC(H), we plotted the magnetic field dependence of the static conductivity,
σDC(H), as shown in
Figure 9.
From figure 9, it is observed that
σDC(H), increases when the magnetic field
H increases from zero to approximately 30 kA/m, and then decreases with the increase of
H from 30 kA/m to 135 kA/m, this behavior agreeing with Mott's VRH theory [
29]. The increase in conductivity, σ
DC, around low magnetic fields, between zero and 30 kA/m, can be attributed to the increase in the mobility of electric charge carriers, which are magnetically activated when
H increases [
29]. At magnetic fields
H above 30 kA/m, the static conductivity decreases with increasing magnetic field, which indicates a decrease in the mobility of charge carriers [
29,
30]. This behavior of the static conductivity with the magnetic field
H can be correlated with the variation of the dielectric permittivity depending on the value of
H, from Fig. 2.
In the high frequency range, between (0.8-3) GHz, corresponding to the
σAC component of the conductivity (see Fig. 9), by logarithmisation of equation (10), a linear relationship between
ln(σAC) and
ln(ω) is obtained, graphically represented in
Figure 10, at different values of the magnetic field
H, applied to the ferrofluid sample. By fitting the experimental dependencies
ln(σAC)(ln(ω)), from Fig. 10, it was possible to determine both the exponent
n and the parameter
A0, corresponding to each
H value of the magnetic field, the obtained results being presented in
Table 1.
Based the Mott’s variable-range-hopping (VRH) model [
29], and the electrical conduction mechanism by hopping of charge carriers [
28,
31], we established for the first time in the microwave range, the following equation that allows the determination of the hopping distance
Rh of the charge carriers, between the localized states.
In Eq. (11),
e is the electric charge of the electron and α=10
9 m
-1, represents the degree of localization [
29]. Using the obtained values for
σDC (Fig. 9), exponent
n and parameter
A0 (
Table 1), with Eq. (11) the values
Rh corresponding to each value
H of magnetic field, were determined, being listed in
Table 1 and the
Rh(H) dependence is presented in
Figure 11.
As can be seen, from both
Table 1 and Fig. 11, the hopping distance,
Rh, initially decreases with increasing magnetic field
H, applied to the ferrofluid, from 10.27 nm (for H = 0) to 7.43 nm (for H = 24.47 kA/m), after which
Rh begins to increase with the increase of
H, reaching the value of 16.43 nm corresponding to
H=135.45 kA/m. This result shows that the conduction mechanism (DC-conductivity) in the microwave frequency range is established by the hopping of charge carriers between the localized states due to the Mott VRH mechanism [
29] inside the ferrofluid magnetite particles; the latter being influenced by the presence of the magnetic field,
H. Thus, around low magnetic fields, between zero and approximately 30 kA/m, the decrease in the hopping distance
Rh will cause a greater number of charge carriers to participate in the electrical conduction, which leads to the increase electrical conductivity
σDC, in this domain of low magnetic field as observed experimentally (see Fig. 9). The increase of the magnetic field
H from approximately 30 kA/m to 135 kA/m, causes the increase of the hopping distance
Rh which will lead to a smaller number of charge carriers participating in the electrical conduction and therefore to the decrease of the electrical conductivity
σDC, as was also obtained experimentally (see Fig. 9).
In the high frequency region, corresponding to the
σAC conductivity, the variation with frequency at different
H values of the magnetic field (Fig. 9), is like the
σAC dependence for different
T values of the temperature [
32]. As a result, for the analysis of the conduction mechanism at high frequencies, we used the correlated barrier hopping model (CBH) [
33], which explains that the dependence
σAC(f,H) is due of the short-range hopping of the charge carriers between the sites separated by energy barriers of varied heights [
26,
31,
34]. In a first approximation, from the CBH model, the exponent n is given by the relation:
where
Wm is the maximum barrier height (equal to the band gap energy) [
26]. The dependence of the maximum energy barrier height,
Wm(H), versus magnetic field,
H, is shown in
Figure 12 for the ferrofluid sample.
From figure 12 it can be seen that by increasing the magnetic field
H, there is a decrease in the energy of the band gap,
Wm, from 2.6 eV (for H=0) to approximately 1.82 eV (for H=135 kA/m), being in agreement with the values of the bandgap energy of magnetite nanoparticles (Fe
3O
4), obtained by other authors: 1.76 eV [
35] and 2.24 eV [
36] respectively, at room temperature.