4.1. Rapid Weight Loss in Judo
Official (International Judo Federation, IJF) judo competitions for seniors (adults) are conducted in 7 female and 7 male weight categories. The lowest senior female weight category is -48 kg and the lowest male weight category is -60 kg. Senior female athletes heavier than 78 kg and male athletes heavier than 100 kg compete in weight categories without upper weight limit. Adapted weight categories exist for other age groups. Most competitively active judo athletes tend to reduce their body weight in just a few days immediately preceding competition with the purpose of remaining just under the upper limit of their weight category, in this way attempting to obtain competitive advantages over lighter adversaries [
22,
57,
58]. They use either long-term or rapid weight loss practices for this purpose [
59]. A similar organization in weight categories also exists in many other combat sports [
45]. It has been estimated that about 60-90% of combat sports athletes [
45] use methods for weight loss, such as intensive exercise, reduced fluid intake, fasting (including reduced carbohydrate/fat intake and not eating at all the day before weigh in), sauna, dedicated clothing, diuretics, laxatives and purgative behaviors/vomiting [
21,
60,
61,
62,
63]. Rapid weight loss refers to such practices with the goal of losing weight (on average about 2-10% of the body weight) within approximately 1 week before a contest to compete in a lower weight class [
60]. Judo athletes often start to use rapid weight loss strategies at an early age [
45,
64]. A study indicated that by the age of 13 years, 74% of the athletes engage in rapid weight loss practices before competitions [
65]. Most athletes use rapid weight loss methods to reduce body weight by about 2-5% but many also occasionally lose 5-10% and some more than 10%, with more severe weight loss being more common in elite athletes [
45,
64,
66]. Usually, the weight loss for a pre-competition weigh-in to compete in the lowest weight category possible, is followed by a post-competition weight regain. This means it is needed to decrease weight again for later competitions. Such patterns are called “weight cycling” [
66,
67]. While such practices may produce competitive advantages (competing in a lower weight category), they are also associated with health risks (see following section), for extreme approaches potentially even death as reported in the 90ies for 3 college wrestlers [
68].
Nevertheless, the impact of rapid weight loss on performance is debated [
69] and appropriate fasting strategies might even lead to metabolic and general health benefits, as discussed in section 3. In addition, the association between weight loss and competitive success is difficult to establish due to the many confounding variables involved [
59]. In terms of physiological or overall performance, Štangar and colleagues surveyed 138 elite-level female and male judo athletes and found 96% of them applying rapid weight loss methods, with 91% reporting negative effects of these methods on their energy level, to the extent that 21% of them experienced a collapse period as result of their weight loss practices [
70]. In addition, Fortes et al. showed that rapid weight loss resulted in lower performance in a judo fitness test and concluded that rapid weight loss should not be used for performance optimization in judo [
58].
In summary, rapid weight loss strategies are commonly applied in competitive judo but how they affect performance remains poorly understood. In addition, severe forms of such approaches can pose threats to the athlete’s health.
4.2. Health Risks of Rapid Weight Loss in Judo
Weight loss in judo and other sport disciplines is often performed too rapidly [
22], likely without sufficiently adhering to nutritional guidelines. Such behaviors are associated with acute and chronic health risks [
71]. In addition, Chapa et al. [
25] in a meta-analysis showed that athletes participating in sports that have weight categories, such as judo, had higher levels of disordered eating.
An open question is whether weight loss habits in judo may promote unhealthy dietary behavior and possible even facilitate the development of eating disorders. Eating disorders have been reported to be more prevalent in sports with weight categories than in the general population or other sports as a consequence of such athletes’ strong focus on weight [
72,
73,
74]. Common eating disorders that are of relevance for athletes in weight-sensitive sports [
23,
25,
75] include anorexia, bulimia and binge-eating disorders. People with anorexia nervosa dramatically restrict their food intake and/or apply purgative behaviors. Bulimia nervosa describes behaviors of food restrictions combined with compulsive binge-eating episodes and associated vomiting induction. Binge eating disorder is characterized by regular episodes of ingesting greater than normal amounts of food and perception of losing control over one’s own eating behaviors [
76]. The surprisingly small body of relevant literature on the topic of disordered eating or eating disorders in judo athletes is summarized below in the context of potentially adverse health consequences of rapid weight loss.
Rapid weight loss can cause diverse symptoms, including impairments in memory, concentration and vigor, but also feelings of confusion, rage, and depression and it can lead to fatigue [
45]. Furthermore, perceptual motor-skill performance [
77], decision making [
78] and mood [
79] of judo athletes may be negatively affected by rapid weight loss strategies. The acute health risks of rapid weight loss are mostly related to hypohydration, which generally can impair cardiovascular, cognitive and motor function [
44]. Fluid restriction and ‘sauna suits’ remain an often-used tool for rapid weight reduction [
70]. Accordingly, a prevalence of hypohydration in judo athletes of 89% in the morning of the competition day has been reported in a study [
80]. Over 50% of these athletes were seriously hypo-hydrated at morning weigh-in [
80]. Repeated dehydration in rapid weight loss has been associated with increased markers for acute kidney injury in wrestlers and thus may represent risk factors for the development of kidney injuries [
60], although an actual connection remains to be confirmed. Also, impaired erythropoiesis and hormonal imbalances were reported to be induced by rapid weight loss in athletes of different combat sports [
81,
82]. The hormonal changes were characterized by a decrease in testosterone and triiodothyronine concentrations [
81]. An increase in muscle damage markers has been observed following a combination of dietary restriction and intense exercise training for weight reduction before competition [
83,
84]. This suggests impaired muscular function and increased susceptibility of muscle tissue to injury [
83,
84].
Beyond those acute risks, some studies report potential psychopathological effects in response to rapid weight loss in judo athletes. Among those risks are the development of eating disorders, which may be increased as a consequence of repeated unhealthy rapid weight loss practices, particularly in women [
85]. Rouveix and colleagues [
86] found an overall low prevalence of manifest eating disorders in judo athletes using the Eating Attitudes Test (EAT-26). However, 25% of the tested female judo athletes (3 out of 12) were “at risk” for eating disorders according to this test. Furthermore, the corresponding EAT-26 scores of the female judo athletes were strongly correlated to body esteem [
86]. These results were accompanied by a substantially higher occurrence of menstrual dysfunction in the female judo athletes (58.3%) as compared to female controls (7.1%) [
86]. In another study rapid weight loss did not acutely affect the menstrual cycle but had negative consequences on development, e.g., reduced body growth, in juvenile female judo athletes [
87].
Using also the EAT-26, Filaire and colleagues [
88] observed a higher prevalence of disordered eating attitudes among the judo athletes (30% vs. 20% in controls) in a small questionnaire-based study in 20 judo athletes and 25 controls. These authors reported a significant positive correlation of disordered eating attitudes with body dissatisfaction and negative correlations with stress tolerance, emotional self-awareness and mood. Importantly, the EAT-26 has later been doubted to adequately reflect eating disorders in sports [
22]. Escobar-Molina and co-authors [
89] in an observational, descriptive study conducted in 144 Spanish judo athletes observed eating disorders and symptoms of anxiety, especially in young women. Beside the mentioned menstrual dysfunction, also risks related to bone health have been suggested to be associated with rapid weight loss in female judo athletes [
90]. However, clear relationships remain to be established. Furthermore, judo training appears to be linked to improved bone metabolism and density, possibly counteracting potentially detrimental effects of rapid weight loss on bone health [
37].
Long-term effects of rapid weight loss practices in combat sports have rarely been studied [
91]. Maksimovic and colleagues recently found a higher prevalence of metabolic syndrome, a higher systolic and diastolic blood pressure, increased values of fasting blood glucose and trends of higher triglyceride levels in former elite combat sports athletes who had employed rapid weight loss strategies during their competitive careers, compared to former elite athletes from other sports, who did not [
92]. They concluded that the first group of athletes is susceptible to negative metabolic alterations at the end of the competitive period [
92]. The study’s weight-category sports included judo, jujitsu, karate, kickboxing, taekwondo and boxing [
92].
Taken together, rapid weight loss might compromise capacities that determine performance and increases the probability of injuries. However, long term outcomes of the dietary strategies associated with weight management in judo (including the potential modulation of eating disorder development) have rarely been investigated and remain largely unknown.