Mitochondrial introgression raises questions of biogeography, and extent of reproductive isolation and natural selection. Previous phylogenetic work on the Sorex araneus complex revealed apparent mitonuclear discordance in Iberian shrews indicating past hybridization of S. granarius and the Carlit chromosomal race of S. araneus, enabling introgression of the S. araneus mitochondrial genome into S. granarius. To further study this, we genetically typed 61 S. araneus/coronatus/granarius from localities in Portugal, Spain, France and Andorra at mitochondrial, autosomal and sex-linked loci, and combined our data with the previously published sequences. Our data are consistent with the earlier data that S. coronatus and S. granarius are the most closely related of the three species and confirm that S. granarius from the Central System mountain range in Spain captured the mitochondrial genome from a population of S. araneus. The mitochondrial capture event can be explained by invoking a biogeographical scenario whereby S. araneus was in contact with S. granarius during the Younger Dryas in central Iberia despite the two species currently having disjunct distributions. We discuss whether selection favoured S. granarius with an introgressed mitochondrial genome. Our data also suggest recent hybridization and introgression between S. coronatus and S. granarius and between S. araneus and S. coronatus.